Skip to main content

Consultation

SRA Principles

The seven Principles apply to solicitors, RELs, RFLs, RSLs, firms and firm managers. Where Principles pull in different directions, those that protect the wider public interest come first.

7 paragraphs. Each has our summary, a link to the SRA's text, where Signal & Line would apply it and why, the authorities behind that reading, and what we are asking you. Responses are anonymous, and due by 2 February 2027.

Principle 1

Principle 1: support the rule of law and the proper working of the justice system.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL, firm, firm manager
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Linked

For reference. The paragraph has its own page, with our summary, a link to the SRA's text and its authorities, but nothing on a matter raises it.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • No activity raises Principle 1 on its own
  • Listed beside Code 1.4 and 2.4 as a candidate when an item concerns material put before a court, regulator or tribunal

Why we apply it this way

The rule-of-law limb is statutory context only (A7, CO4), and the justice limb is engaged through conduct that Code 1.4 and 2.4 already name, such as false citations (Ayinde, Halborg). So Legal Workflows opens no Principle 1 item of its own, but lists it beside those paragraphs without needing a finding of intent (SDT 12822). SDT 12884 is why regulators and tribunals are in scope as well as courts.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • False or unverified citations engage P1 together with Code 1.4 and 2.4, so the lists of events list all three.
  • The SRA’s Misuse of AI warning notice (17 August 2026) applies here. The paragraph's page links it, and the assistant verifies every quotation and keeps a person in the loop on every draft.
  • P1 is not confined to court hearings: SDT 12884 applied it to material put before the regulator and the Tribunal.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

E3 (A guide to the application of Principle 1), E1 (SRA enforcement strategy), G1 (Misuse of AI), G8 (Convictions arising from matters of principle or social conscience), G14 (Balancing duties in litigation), C4 (Use of non disclosure agreements (NDAs)), C5 (Conduct in disputes), C6 (Strategic Lawsuits against Public Participation (SLAPPs)), R4 (Offering inducements to potential clients or clients), P8 (Marketing your services to members of the public)

Two limbs: the rule of law, and the proper administration of justice. The second is engaged by:

  • misleading the court, or recklessly letting it be misled
  • interfering with witnesses
  • abusive or delaying process
  • tipping off
  • defying lawful investigative powers
  • not reporting a conviction
  • false AI citations (G1)

The duty to the court can override P7. Conduct outside practice can breach P1.

Legislation

A7 (LSA 2007 s1: regulatory objectives (s1(1)) and professional principles (s1(3))) (LSA s1(1)(b), s1(3)(d)); CO4 (Constitutional Reform Act 2005 s1 (rule of law)) (CRA 2005 s1)

The rule of law is a statutory regulatory objective, and CRA 2005 s1 recognises it as an existing constitutional principle. Cite these as context only: the Principle creates no event-level duty.

Civil courts

A30 Halborg; A10 Ayinde; A9 Hamid

P1 was found breached by a solicitor's own abusive litigation (Halborg). Putting false citations before a court engages the rule-of-law duty as well as S1.4 and S2.4.

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12884 (SDT 12884-2026, 25 Aug 2026; under appeal). Paragraphs found or considered: P1, P2, P5, Code 1.4, 2.4.

The Tribunal treated filing unverified, AI-generated authorities in its own proceedings as a P1 breach, and held that the duty is the same whether the material goes to a court, the regulator or the Tribunal. For Legal Workflows: P1 is not confined to court hearings. Submissions to regulators and tribunals belong in scope.

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12822 (SDT 12822-2025, 8 Jul 2026). Paragraphs found or considered: P1, P2, Code 1.4.

Misleading a court by omission was held a P1 breach even without dishonesty or recklessness. For Legal Workflows: a P1 flag does not need an intent finding.

What we are asking you

  1. Is it right that Principle 1 is only ever listed beside Code 1.4 and 2.4, and never opens an item of its own?
  2. Should material sent to a regulator or tribunal be treated like court material, given that SDT 12884 is under appeal?
  3. Is a link to the Misuse of AI notice (G1) on the page enough, or should it also appear where a draft is saved?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Principle 1.

Respond on Principle 1
Your view of Principle 1

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Principle 2

Principle 2: behave in a way that keeps public trust in solicitors and in the legal services that authorised persons provide.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL, firm, firm manager
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Parallel (self-certified)

Legal Workflows does not monitor this duty. The organization certifies, with evidence it chooses, that it monitors the duty outside the platform, and certifies again at an interval it sets.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • An admin or the COLP certifying, with evidence it chooses, the organization's public statements and social media policy (a certification this would add)
  • Certifying again at the interval the organization sets, or when the evidence it cited is replaced
  • Never raised by an event on a matter, including a Code 1.4 candidate

Why we apply it this way

Public trust is contextual: the test is whether a fully informed member of the public would lose confidence (SDT 12904), and conduct outside practice counts only where it realistically touches practice (Beckwith, Husain). There is usually no matter to hang this on, and watching staff communications or social media would be intrusive. So the organization certifies how it monitors the duty, and Legal Workflows never infers Principle 2 from a Code 1.4 event.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Covered by the organisation’s certification of its public statements and social media policy.
  • P2 is never inferred automatically from a Code 1.4 event; SDT 12904 shows it is contextual.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

G5 (Public trust and confidence), G6 (SRA Principle 2: public trust and confidence - Case studies), E5 (Topic guide: Criminal offences outside of practice), E6 (Topic guide: Social media offensive communications), E8 (Topic guide: Driving with excess alcohol convictions), G8 (Convictions arising from matters of principle or social conscience), G9 (Sexual Misconduct), G10 (Offensive communications), G7 (Complying with Principle 6 - encouraging equality, diversity and inclusion)

Not every rule breach engages P2, but dishonesty or lack of integrity, criminal offences, discrimination, harassment and offensive communications usually do, including outside practice. Harm to many or to vulnerable clients aggravates.

Legislation

A7 (LSA 2007 s1: regulatory objectives (s1(1)) and professional principles (s1(3))) (LSA s1(1)(a), (d), (i))

Public trust is tied to the public interest, consumer and economic crime objectives. Because of A9, an economic crime failure that breaches P2 can attract an uncapped SRA fine, and the product's severity label should reflect that.

Civil courts

A3 Beckwith; A31 Husain; A2 Wingate; A37 Iqbal; A30 Halborg; A28 Hurst

P2 reaches conduct outside practice only when it realistically touches practice or the profession's standing (Beckwith [54]). Offensive social-media posts by a solicitor were caught (Husain). Manifest incompetence, not ordinary negligence, can breach the public-trust principle (Wingate [105]-[106]; Iqbal [23]).

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12904 (SDT 12904-2026, 22 Sep 2026). Paragraphs found or considered: P2, P4, P5, P7, Code 1.4.

The Tribunal asked whether a member of the public fully informed of the circumstances would lose confidence. Knowingly misleading a vulnerable client about a medical report, out of concern for his welfare, failed that test for P2 but still breached 1.4. For Legal Workflows: P2 is contextual. The product should not infer P2 automatically from a 1.4 event.

Tribunal or SRA decision

Husain v SRA [2025] EWHC 1170 (Admin), 14 May 2025 (appeal from SDT 12463-2023, 28 Mar 2024). Paragraphs found or considered: P2, P5, P6.

Offensive and antisemitic tweets posted "in a personal capacity" by a solicitor who identified himself online as an employment solicitor were within reach of the Principles. Applying Beckwith, conduct in private life is covered when it realistically touches practice or the profession's standing. Article 10 requires a high bar, which the Tribunal had applied correctly. For Legal Workflows: P2, P5 and P6 reach out-of-work conduct, including social media, where the person is identifiable as a solicitor.

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12660 (SDT 12660-2024, 11 Jun 2025; costs varied on appeal by consent). Paragraphs found or considered: P2, P5, Code 1.2.

Non-consensual touching of a colleague at after-work socialising among firm colleagues engaged P2 and P5, even though the respondent argued it was private social life. For Legal Workflows: workplace-conduct items should cover firm-connected social events, not only office hours.

What we are asking you

  1. Is a certified public statements and social media policy the right evidence for Principle 2, or should firms be asked for something more?
  2. Should the certified policy expressly cover firm-connected social events, as SDT 12660 suggests?
  3. What interval would you expect a firm to set for certifying this duty again?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Principle 2.

Respond on Principle 2
Your view of Principle 2

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Principle 3

Principle 3: keep your professional independence.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL, firm, firm manager
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Linked

For reference. The paragraph has its own page, with our summary, a link to the SRA's text and its authorities, but nothing on a matter raises it.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • No activity raises Principle 3 on its own
  • Shown as reference on its own page, which notes that payment or fee-sharing arrangements with staff can engage independence (SDT 12716)

Why we apply it this way

Independence is lost when a client, introducer, funder or employer steers the advice, which is a question about influence rather than a recorded event (G11, R1). SDT 12716 shows the risk can sit in payment arrangements inside the firm, but whether they compromised independence needs a person's judgment. So Legal Workflows keeps Principle 3 as a reference page and does not guess at influence from the data it holds.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • No event raises P3. SDT 12716 shows fee-sharing or payment flows with staff can engage independence, which the page notes.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

G11 (Lack of independence - Case studies), F12 (Key points for governing boards, chief executives and senior officers in organisations employing in-house solicitors), F13 (Understanding in-house solicitors professional obligations employer), R1 (Referral fees LASPO and SRA Principles), R2 (Q&As on the ban of personal injury referral fees), C4 (Use of non disclosure agreements (NDAs))

Independence means not letting clients, introducers, funders or employers use your status, or steer your advice. It is especially at risk in referral arrangements and in-house.

Legislation

A7 (LSA 2007 s1: regulatory objectives (s1(1)) and professional principles (s1(3))) (LSA s1(3)(a), (d))

Independence is a statutory professional principle. For advocates and litigators it is reinforced by the s1(3)(d) duty to the court. No event-level legislation.

Civil courts

None found that turns on the 2019 wording

No change.

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12716 (SDT 12716-2024, 17 Sep 2025). Paragraphs found or considered: P2, P3, P5, P7, Code 3.5, 1.4, 4.2, Firms 9.2.

The respondent's independence (P3) was compromised by financial arrangements with an unsupervised caseworker who ran a branch as if separate. For Legal Workflows: P3 can be engaged by fee-sharing or payment flows with staff, not only by outside pressure.

What we are asking you

  1. Should recording a referral or fee-sharing arrangement on a matter list Principle 3 as a candidate beside it?
  2. Is anything missing for in-house solicitors, where the employer is also the client (F12, F13)?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Principle 3.

Respond on Principle 3
Your view of Principle 3

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Principle 4

Principle 4: be honest.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL, firm, firm manager
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Linked

For reference. The paragraph has its own page, with our summary, a link to the SRA's text and its authorities, but nothing on a matter raises it.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • No activity raises Principle 4 on its own
  • Cited on its page beside Code 1.4, which can be listed as a candidate on another paragraph's item

Why we apply it this way

Honesty turns first on what a person actually believed, then on the standard of ordinary decent people (Ivey). Software cannot see belief, and a genuine belief can defeat Principle 4 even where Code 1.4 is engaged (SDT 12861, SDT 12904). So Legal Workflows never infers dishonesty from an event, and leaves the judgment to a person.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • The product never infers P4 from an event. Honesty follows the two-stage Ivey test, which needs evidence of state of mind.
  • Items that engage other paragraphs never use the word “breach”.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

G4 (Acting with honesty), A3 (Reporting concerns about wrongdoing when working in-house), E1 (SRA enforcement strategy)

Dishonesty is judged by the Ivey two-stage test. Misleading a regulator, insurer, court or client, or backdating documents, is dishonest. Lack of integrity can be found without dishonesty.

Legislation

A7 (LSA 2007 s1: regulatory objectives (s1(1)) and professional principles (s1(3))) (LSA s1(3)(a)); CR4 (Fraud Act 2006 s2 (false representation), s3 (failing to disclose information)) (Fraud Act ss2, 3)

Dishonest false representation, or dishonest failure to disclose where there is a legal duty to disclose, can be a criminal offence. The product may cite the Fraud Act as the criminal counterpart but must not suggest that every P4 issue is a crime.

Civil courts

A1 Ivey; A2 Wingate; A4 Day; A29 Grunhut; A5 Sharma; A6 James

The dishonesty test is in two stages: first the person's actual knowledge or belief, judged subjectively, then whether the conduct was dishonest by the standards of ordinary decent people, judged objectively. The person need not realise the conduct was dishonest (Ivey [74]). Dishonesty must be specifically alleged and put to the person (Wingate [149]; Day [272]). Inexperience is irrelevant to honesty (Grunhut [37]). James).

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12861 (SDT 12861-2025, 23 Oct 2026). Paragraphs found or considered: P2, P4, P5, Accounts Rules, Firms (COFA).

Improper client-to-office transfers were not dishonest, because the respondent genuinely believed the money was his. That defeated the first, subjective limb of Ivey. For Legal Workflows: client-money events support P2 and P5 flags; P4 needs evidence of state of mind and should never be auto-flagged.

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12904 (above). Paragraphs found or considered: P4.

Knowingly giving a client false information was not dishonest by the standards of ordinary decent people, given the welfare motive the Tribunal accepted. For Legal Workflows: "knowingly false" does not equal "dishonest" at the SDT. Keep P4 separate from 1.4.

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12552 (SDT 12552-2024, 2 Oct 2024). Paragraphs found or considered: P2, P4, P5, Code 1.4.

A partner who drafted a misleading email and pressed a newly qualified solicitor to send it was dishonest even though she refused and the email was never sent. Exceptional circumstances were found because the episode was brief, unplanned, not carried through and caused no prejudice. For Legal Workflows: attempts count (see Code 1.4).

Tribunal or SRA decision

Grunhut v SRA [2025] EWHC 592 (Admin), 14 Mar 2025 (SDT 12488-2023, 18 Jan 2024). Paragraphs found or considered: P2, P4, P5, Code 1.4, 7.1.

The court approved the Tribunal's two-stage Ivey approach. Backdating a trust deed for an HMRC refund claim, and a false "confirmed" answer to the employer about financial ties with clients, were dishonest. A respondent's claim that he followed a colleague's usual practice, not raised in evidence, could not help on appeal. For Legal Workflows: a declaration to one's own firm is in scope for 1.4 and P4.

What we are asking you

  1. Is it right that the product never raises Principle 4, even where an event engages Code 1.4?
  2. Would a reference page on the two-stage test help at the point a Code 1.4 candidate is reviewed?
  3. Should the page say more about the Fraud Act overlap (CR4), or would that suggest every honesty issue is a crime?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Principle 4.

Respond on Principle 4
Your view of Principle 4

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Principle 5

Principle 5: act with integrity.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL, firm, firm manager
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Parallel (self-certified)

Legal Workflows does not monitor this duty. The organization certifies, with evidence it chooses, that it monitors the duty outside the platform, and certifies again at an interval it sets.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • An admin or the COLP certifying, with evidence it chooses, how the organization oversees conduct outside the platform (a certification this would add)
  • Certifying again at the interval the organization sets, or when the evidence it cited is replaced
  • Cited on its page beside the Code paragraphs that give integrity its content, such as 1.2, 1.4 and 2.4

Why we apply it this way

Integrity means adhering to the profession's ethical standards (Wingate), and its content comes from the Code itself (Beckwith). Whether conduct shows a personal ethical failing is a judgment on the whole picture, often a pattern (Halborg), and the High Court is split on the standard (Hurst). So Legal Workflows does not monitor integrity, routes concrete events to the Code paragraphs, and asks the organization to certify its own oversight.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Covered by the organisation’s certification.
  • The P5 page cites Wingate, records that Hurst and Halborg currently disagree, and links the Code paragraphs that give integrity its content (1.2, 1.4, 2.x, 6.x).

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

G2 (Acting with integrity), G3 (Acting without integrity - Case study), E1 (SRA enforcement strategy), C5 (Conduct in disputes), C6 (Strategic Lawsuits against Public Participation (SLAPPs))

Integrity is wider than honesty and sets a higher professional standard. It covers what you do, not only what you say, and reaches dealings with people who are not clients.

Legislation

A7 (LSA 2007 s1: regulatory objectives (s1(1)) and professional principles (s1(3))) (LSA s1(3)(a))

No specific legislation beyond the professional principle.

Civil courts

A2 Wingate; A3 Beckwith; A28 Hurst; A11 Brett; A30 Halborg; A31 Husain

Integrity is wider than honesty: it means adhering to the profession's ethical standards (Wingate [100]-[101]). Its content is drawn from the Code itself (Beckwith [33]-[36]), so P5 should be mapped to concrete Code paragraphs, not used as a free-floating label. It implies personally substandard ethics, not merely a technical slip (Hurst [61]). Recklessly letting a court be misled lacks integrity (Brett). So does a persistent pattern of meritless litigation (Halborg).

Tribunal or SRA decision

Husain v SRA [2025] EWHC 1170 (Admin), 14 May 2025 (appeal from SDT 12463-2023, 28 Mar 2024). Paragraphs found or considered: P2, P5, P6.

Offensive and antisemitic tweets posted "in a personal capacity" by a solicitor who identified himself online as an employment solicitor were within reach of the Principles. Applying Beckwith, conduct in private life is covered when it realistically touches practice or the profession's standing. Article 10 requires a high bar, which the Tribunal had applied correctly. For Legal Workflows: P2, P5 and P6 reach out-of-work conduct, including social media, where the person is identifiable as a solicitor.

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12660 (SDT 12660-2024, 11 Jun 2025; costs varied on appeal by consent). Paragraphs found or considered: P2, P5, Code 1.2.

Non-consensual touching of a colleague at after-work socialising among firm colleagues engaged P2 and P5, even though the respondent argued it was private social life. For Legal Workflows: workplace-conduct items should cover firm-connected social events, not only office hours.

Tribunal or SRA decision

Halborg v SRA [2026] EWHC 636 (Admin), 19 Mar 2026 (SDT 12667-2024, 22 Jul 2025). Paragraphs found or considered: P1, P2, P5, Code 2.4, 2.6.

Lang J followed Wingate and expressly declined to follow the view in Hurst that lack of integrity implies "moral turpitude" or bad faith requiring a higher standard of proof. A pattern of totally-without-merit applications in his own family litigation, persisting despite judicial warnings, lacked integrity. Acting as a litigant in a personal capacity was no answer. For Legal Workflows: integrity can be found from a persistent pattern; personal litigation by a solicitor is in scope.

Tribunal or SRA decision

Hurst v SRA [2026] EWHC 85 (Admin), 20 Jan 2026 (SDT 12612-2024, 14 May 2025). Paragraphs found or considered: P2, P5, Code 1.2, 1.4, 2.4.

Collins Rice J described a lack of integrity as personal ethical failing, a degree of "moral turpitude", calling for clear reasoning. That gloss was later rejected in Halborg (above). For Legal Workflows: treat the integrity standard as Wingate, and note the conflict between two first-instance High Court judges.

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12731 (SDT 12731-2025, 6 Feb 2026). Paragraphs found or considered: P2, P5, P6, Code 1.5.

Applying Wingate and Beckwith, a senior partner's sexually motivated conduct towards junior women at the firm's Christmas event lacked integrity. Voluntary intoxication and claimed lack of recall were rejected as answers. For Legal Workflows: seniority and abuse of position are central facts; intoxication is not a mitigating flag.

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12678 (SDT 12678-2024, 2 Dec 2025). Paragraphs found or considered: P2, P5, Code 1.2.

Only one act was proved: a sexually motivated kiss that was not shown to be non-consensual. On that narrow basis there was no lack of integrity, no P2 breach and no abuse of position. For Legal Workflows: sexual motivation alone does not establish breach; whether the conduct was unwanted is pivotal.

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12822 (above). Paragraphs found or considered: P5, Code 2.5, 2.6.

Manifest incompetence does not of itself mean lack of integrity. Here, though, a principal's sustained failure to secure compliance with court orders went beyond negligence and lacked integrity.

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12703 (SDT 12703-2024, 4 Dec 2025). Paragraphs found or considered: P2, P5, Code 4.2, Firms 5.2, 2.1(a), 4.4, 8.1.

Facilitating fraudulent conveyancing through absent ID checks and poor governance was manifest incompetence, not lack of integrity.

What we are asking you

  1. Is it right to route events to the Code paragraphs that give integrity its content, rather than ever raising Principle 5 itself?
  2. Should the page keep noting the split between Hurst and Halborg, or simply follow Wingate as Halborg applied it?
  3. Should the certified policy reach personal litigation by staff and firm-connected social events (Halborg, SDT 12660)?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Principle 5.

Respond on Principle 5
Your view of Principle 5

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Principle 6

Principle 6: encourage equality, diversity and inclusion in the way you work.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL, firm, firm manager
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Parallel (self-certified)

Legal Workflows does not monitor this duty. The organization certifies, with evidence it chooses, that it monitors the duty outside the platform, and certifies again at an interval it sets.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • An admin or the COLP certifying, with evidence it chooses, the organization's equality, diversity and inclusion measures (a certification this would add)
  • Attaching evidence such as a policy, a training record or the aggregate client equality monitoring report
  • Certifying again at the interval the organization sets, or when the evidence it cited is replaced

Why we apply it this way

The duty is to encourage equality, diversity and inclusion across how a firm works: adjustments, an inclusive workplace, preventing harassment and handling discriminatory clients (G7). Most of that has no matter to hang on, and the Equality Act sets the legal floor while s158 limits positive action (EQ1, EQ7). So the organization certifies how it meets the duty, and Legal Workflows does not judge whether its evidence is enough.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Covered by the organisation’s certification. The Equality Act 2010 sets the legal floor; s158 limits lawful positive action.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

G7 (Complying with Principle 6 - encouraging equality, diversity and inclusion), F9 (Firm diversity data Q&A), E6 (Topic guide: Social media offensive communications), S4 (Terminating a retainer)

The guidance expects:

  • reasonable adjustments for clients
  • inclusive workplace measures
  • prevention of sexual harassment
  • a process for clients who behave in a discriminatory way
  • collection, reporting and publication of diversity data
  • lawful termination of retainers, considering the Equality Act

Legislation

EQ1 (Equality Act 2010 s4 (protected characteristics)), EQ2 (EA 2010 s20 (duty to make adjustments)), EQ4 (EA 2010 s29 (provision of services)), EQ7 (s158 positive action); A7 (LSA 2007 s1: regulatory objectives (s1(1)) and professional principles (s1(3))) (LSA s1(1)(f))

The Equality Act sets the legal floor: protected characteristics, adjustments, services and employment. s158 limits what positive action is lawful. The Principle's wording is "encourages" (see C1).

Civil courts

A31 Husain

Antisemitic and offensive posts breached P6 together with P2 and P5. Article 10 must be weighed, but regulation can lawfully restrict speech (Husain [77], [89], [131]).

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12731; Husain (above). Paragraphs found or considered: P6.

Sexual advances directed only at women were pleaded and admitted as a P6 (EDI) breach, alongside Code 1.5. For Legal Workflows: P6 can attach to harassment events, not only to policy failures.

What we are asking you

  1. Is self-certification right for Principle 6, given that SDT 12731 attached it to harassment events and not only to policy?
  2. Which evidence would you expect a firm to attach here: a policy, training records, diversity data or something else?
  3. Should a client's recorded accessibility needs count as evidence here, or stay only under Code 3.4?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Principle 6.

Respond on Principle 6
Your view of Principle 6

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Principle 7

Principle 7: act in each client's best interests.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL, firm, firm manager
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Linked

For reference. The paragraph has its own page, with our summary, a link to the SRA's text and its authorities, but nothing on a matter raises it.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • No activity raises Principle 7 on its own
  • Cited alongside Code 6.1 and 8.7, which the conflict search and cost estimates already act on

Why we apply it this way

Best interests means the client's best legal interests, and it gives way where the public-interest Principles pull the other way. It is a judgment about the advice as a whole, so Legal Workflows acts on the concrete duties that carry it, such as own-interest conflicts and cost information (K3, Belsner), rather than raising Principle 7 from an event. Where a client lacks capacity, the page also points to the Mental Capacity Act test (MC1).

How it works in Signal & Line

  • The Principles’ introduction (wider public interest takes precedence over an individual client’s interests) is shown as instrument introduction text, not as a row.
  • Best interests means best legal interests; where a client lacks capacity the Mental Capacity Act best-interests test also applies.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

G1 (Misuse of AI), E3 (A guide to the application of Principle 1), S1 (Accepting instructions from vulnerable clients or third parties acting on their behalf), S7 (Drafting and preparation of wills), R4 (Offering inducements to potential clients or clients), M4 (Using or arranging Third-Party Litigation Funding), K3 (Putting matters right when things go wrong, and own interest conflicts), P2 (Identifying your client when working in-house)

Best interests means the client's best legal interests (E1). It gives way to the public-interest principles where they conflict. Examples:

  • not steering clients into appointing the firm as executor
  • not entering funding arrangements that do not suit the client
  • assessing TPLF

Legislation

A7 (LSA 2007 s1: regulatory objectives (s1(1)) and professional principles (s1(3))) (LSA s1(3)(c)); MC1 (Mental Capacity Act 2005 s1 (principles), s2 (lack of capacity), s9 (lasting powers of attorney)) (MCA s1(5) best interests, where a client lacks capacity)

Best interests is a statutory professional principle. Where someone acts for a client who lacks capacity (attorney or deputy), the MCA best-interests test also applies.

Civil courts

A27 Belsner (via Mothew)

The fiduciary duty of loyalty is not owed in negotiating the solicitor's own retainer, but the Code's information duties are (Belsner [14], [73]).

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12579 (SDT 12579-2024, 23 Dec 2024). Paragraphs found or considered: P2, P5, P7, Code 1.4, 8.6.

Volume mortgage mis-selling claims: failing to tell clients of free routes (Financial Ombudsman Service, FSCS), failing to send adverse counsel's opinion to the ATE insurer, and issuing without the insurer's approval. For Legal Workflows: volume-claims workflows should check that alternatives were advised and that ATE insurer notifications were made.

What we are asking you

  1. Is it right that Principle 7 never raises an item, given that it yields to the public-interest Principles?
  2. Should volume-claims matters prompt a check that free routes and insurer notifications were considered, as SDT 12579 suggests?
  3. Should arranging third-party funding for a client list Principle 7 as a candidate (M4)?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Principle 7.

Respond on Principle 7
Your view of Principle 7

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.