Skip to main content

Open consultation

How Legal Workflows reads the IAA Code of Standards

Before we build it into Signal & Line, we want immigration advisers, solicitors and academics to check how we read the Immigration Advice Authority's Code of Standards 2024, Principle by Principle and Code by Code. Tell us where we have it wrong, and suggest better wording.

Status
Open for comment
Responses by
February 2, 2027
Version
Consultation draft 1, November 10, 2026

How to respond

  1. Find a Principle or Code below, read our summary, where we would apply it and why, and follow the link to the IAA's published code.
  2. Each one ends with What we are asking you: the questions we most want answered on it.
  3. Choose Respond, then give your view: approve, approve with changes, query or reject.
  4. To change our summary, choose Suggest a wording and edit it. Your edits are shown and sent as tracked changes: deletions struck through, insertions underlined.
  5. Add a comment if you wish, and send. You can respond on as many paragraphs as you like.

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask for your name or contact details, and we would rather you did not include them. You can tell us your background if you wish.

How to read a review

The Code has 9 Principles and 59 Codes. Each shows our summary, who it applies to and the kinds of duty it creates, then the activities in Signal & Line it would apply to, why, how the product would act, the authorities behind our reading, and the questions we are asking. How it would act is one of these:

Integrated (already live)
Legal Workflows already acts on this duty today. It will add the paragraph's own page, and cite the paragraph on what the product already does.
Integrated
When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.
Linked
For reference. The paragraph has its own entry, with our summary, a link to the IAA's code and its authorities, but nothing on a matter raises it.
Parallel (self-certified)
Legal Workflows does not monitor this duty. The organization certifies, with evidence it chooses, that it monitors the duty outside the platform, and certifies again at an interval it sets.

The Code, paragraph by paragraph

The Code of Standards 2024 has applied since September 1, 2024. Work completed before then is still under the 2016 code, which this consultation does not cover. The IAA publishes the code as a PDF on GOV.UK, with its Guidance Notes.

Principle 1: Rule of law

Principle 1 and Codes 1.1 to 1.3 bind organizations and advisers alike. They cover keeping the law, never knowingly or recklessly letting anyone be misled, and not abusing court, tribunal or immigration processes.

Principle 1

Principle 1: uphold the rule of law and the proper running of the justice system.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations and advisers
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Linked

For reference. The paragraph has its own entry, with our summary, a link to the IAA's code and its authorities, but nothing on a matter raises it.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • No activity raises Principle 1 on its own
  • Listed beside Code 1.2 or 1.3 as a candidate when an item concerns material sent to the Home Office, a court or a tribunal
Why we apply it this way

Principle 1 states the aim, and Codes 1.1 to 1.3 give it content: keeping the law, not letting anyone be misled, and not abusing process (G1). The statute sets the same aims for the scheme (L2). So Legal Workflows opens no Principle 1 item of its own, but lists it beside the Code an item already cites, so the person sees the Principle as well.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • No event raises Principle 1 on its own. It is listed beside Code 1.2 or 1.3 when an item concerns material sent to the Home Office, a court or a tribunal.
  • Principle 1 is about the person's own conduct. Reporting other people's misconduct sits under Codes 2.3 and 2.4.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G28 (Criminal enforcement policy)

The Guidance Notes aim Principle 1 at lawful conduct at work and in private life, and keep it to the person's own conduct; dealing with other people's misconduct belongs to Principle 2.

The IAA prosecutes illegal advice and advertising under its own criminal enforcement policy.

Legislation

L2 (IAA 1999 s83), L9 (IAA 1999 s91), L25 (IA 1971 s25)

The statute's aims for the scheme include not knowingly misleading a court or tribunal and not abusing immigration procedures (s83(5)). Advising when not qualified is an offense (s91).

Courts and tribunals

C1 (Dhall), UT1 (UK and Munir)

Supporting applications with false documents can be the offense of assisting unlawful immigration as well as a conduct matter (Dhall). Citing an authority that does not exist is a matter for the regulator as well as the court (UK and Munir).

What we are asking you
  1. Is it right that Principle 1 is only listed beside Codes 1.2 and 1.3, and never opens an item of its own?
  2. Should material sent to the Home Office be treated in the same way as material put before a court or tribunal?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Principle 1.

Respond on Principle 1
Your view of Principle 1

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 1.1

Code 1.1: obey the law of the United Kingdom, at work and, where it shows serious disregard for the law, outside it.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations and advisers
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Linked

For reference. The paragraph has its own entry, with our summary, a link to the IAA's code and its authorities, but nothing on a matter raises it.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • No activity raises Code 1.1
  • Shown as reference on its own page, which links the offenses that bear on immigration advice and its advertising
Why we apply it this way

Code 1.1 reaches conduct outside work where it shows serious disregard for the law, and seriousness and repetition both weigh (G1). Legal Workflows holds nothing that would show whether a person has kept the law, and should not. A charge or conviction reaches the IAA through the notification duty in Code 3.7, which the organization certifies. So the paragraph is reference only.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • No event raises Code 1.1. Legal Workflows holds no record of a person's criminal or private conduct and does not look for one.
  • A charge or conviction is a notification matter for the organization under Code 3.7, which it certifies.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G14 (Promotional material)

A criminal offense may engage the Code, and seriousness and repetition both weigh. Private conduct counts: the Guidance Notes' example is repeated driving without insurance.

The promotional material note covers the law on advertising immigration services.

Legislation

L25 (IA 1971 s25), L5 (IAA 1999 Sch 6), L9 (IAA 1999 s91), L12 (IAA 1999 s92B), L21 (BSAIA 2025 s17)

A conviction for assisting unlawful immigration (IA 1971 s25) disqualifies a person from registration (Sch 6 para 4). Advising when not qualified, and advertising such advice, are offenses (s91, s92B). Since February 2, 2026, promoting an unlawful immigration service online is an offense too (BSAIA 2025 s17).

Courts and tribunals

C1 (Dhall)

An adviser's casework can itself be the offense: false payslips supporting applications engaged s25 (Dhall).

What we are asking you
  1. Is a reference page enough for Code 1.1, given that a criminal charge is handled through the organization's certification under Code 3.7?
  2. Should the page give more weight to the offenses of advertising unqualified advice (s92B) and promoting unlawful services online (BSAIA 2025 s17)?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 1.1.

Respond on Code 1.1
Your view of Code 1.1

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 1.2

Code 1.2: never knowingly or recklessly let a client, the Commissioner, the Home Office, a court or tribunal, or any other body be misled.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations and advisers
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Linked

For reference. The paragraph has its own entry, with our summary, a link to the IAA's code and its authorities, but nothing on a matter raises it.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • No activity raises Code 1.2 on its own
  • Listed beside Code 4.2 when an item concerns an authority or expert report that a person could not verify
  • Drafting with the assistant, where a person approves every draft and every quotation is checked
Why we apply it this way

The 2024 Code needs the person to have known or been reckless, which is narrower than the 2016 rule that caught negligent advice (D2). Intent is for a person to judge, not software. So Legal Workflows opens no Code 1.2 item, sends careless advice to Code 4.2, and lists Code 1.2 beside it where a citation or expert report could not be checked, the risks UK and Munir (UT1) and Hoxha (UT2) describe.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • No event raises Code 1.2. It needs knowledge or recklessness, which only a person can judge; careless or mistaken advice is considered under Code 4.2 instead.
  • Listed beside Code 4.2 as a candidate when an item concerns a citation or an expert report that could not be verified.
  • Events before September 1, 2024 fall under the 2016 code, whose rule reached negligent advice; Legal Workflows picks the edition by the date of the event.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes)

The duty covers the person's own acts and omissions and taking part in someone else's deception, such as passing on doctored client documents without a check. Advisers should take reasonable steps to satisfy themselves that supporting documents are genuine.

Legislation

L2 (IAA 1999 s83)

The statute's aim is narrower: not knowingly misleading a court or tribunal (s83(5)). The 2024 Code adds recklessness and widens the audience to clients, the IAA, the Home Office and others.

Courts and tribunals

UT1 (UK and Munir), UT2 (Hoxha), D2 ([2025] UKFTT 290 (GRC))

Citing a case that does not exist (UK and Munir) and relying on an expert report without checking how its information was gathered (Hoxha) are the clearest risks.

Under the 2016 code negligent advice could mislead (D2 at [54]). The 2024 wording needs knowledge or recklessness, so carelessness now belongs under Code 4.2.

What we are asking you
  1. Is it right that Code 1.2 never opens an item, given that it needs knowledge or recklessness?
  2. Should an unverified citation in a draft list Code 1.2 beside Code 4.2, or only Code 4.2?
  3. Should Legal Workflows prompt a check of supporting documents a client provides before they are sent to the Home Office?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 1.2.

Respond on Code 1.2
Your view of Code 1.2

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 1.3

Code 1.3: do not misuse any court, tribunal or immigration procedure, or advise anyone to do so.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations and advisers
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Linked

For reference. The paragraph has its own entry, with our summary, a link to the IAA's code and its authorities, but nothing on a matter raises it.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • No activity raises Code 1.3 on its own
  • Shown as reference on its own page, beside the judicial review practice note (G23)
Why we apply it this way

Whether a step abuses a process depends on its merits and purpose, which only a person can weigh (G1). The leading example, repeated hopeless applications to delay removal, would need a judgment about prospects that Legal Workflows does not make. So Code 1.3 is a reference page, and advice on prospects is considered under Codes 4.2 and 5.1 (UT2).

How it works in Signal & Line
  • No event raises Code 1.3. Whether an application or appeal abuses a process depends on its merits and purpose, which a person judges.
  • The page links the judicial review practice note, because judicial review work needs Level 3 and its own category (Code 3.3).
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G23 (Judicial review case management)

The main example is a run of hopeless applications made to put off removal. Private conduct, such as failing to give a breath specimen, can also engage the Code.

The judicial review note sets the standards for that work and lists the Codes a failure in it may engage.

Legislation

L2 (IAA 1999 s83), L19 (BSAIA 2025 Sch 1)

Not abusing immigration procedures, or advising others to, is one of the statute's aims for the scheme (s83(5)). The 2025 Act would link abuse of immigration procedures to new interim powers, but those provisions are not in force.

Courts and tribunals

UT2 (Hoxha)

A client's distress does not justify going beyond what the adviser is authorized to do, and failures in judicial review work may be referred to the regulator (Hoxha).

What we are asking you
  1. Should recording a further application or appeal on the same matter list Code 1.3 as a candidate beside Code 4.2?
  2. Is the judicial review practice note (G23) the right companion for this page?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 1.3.

Respond on Code 1.3
Your view of Code 1.3

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Principle 2: Honesty and integrity

Principle 2 and Codes 2.1 to 2.8 bind organizations and advisers. They cover honesty, saying who you are, reporting serious misconduct, referral inducements, the bar on charging by non-fee-charging organizations, and telling clients about legal aid.

Principle 2

Principle 2: be honest and act with integrity.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations and advisers
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Parallel (self-certified)

Legal Workflows does not monitor this duty. The organization certifies, with evidence it chooses, that it monitors the duty outside the platform, and certifies again at an interval it sets.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • An admin or the IAA primary contact certifying, with evidence it chooses, its honesty, candour and social media policies (a certification this would add)
  • Certifying again at the interval the organization sets, or when the evidence it cited is replaced
  • Never raised by an event on a matter
Why we apply it this way

Honesty and integrity reach every dealing, including private life and social media (G1), and the tribunal decisions turn on candour with regulators (D4, D5, Dean). There is usually no matter to hang this on, and watching staff conduct would be intrusive. So the organization certifies how it upholds the Principle, and Legal Workflows never infers Principle 2 from anything recorded on a matter.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Covered by the organization's certification of its policies on honesty, candour with the IAA and other regulators, and public statements and social media.
  • Principle 2 is never inferred from anything recorded on a matter.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G20 (Fitness of advisers and owners)

Integrity is wider than honesty. The Guidance Notes treat abusing a client on personal social media as a lack of integrity, and treat dishonesty as among the most serious matters.

The IAA assesses honesty as part of fitness, looking at a person's history of honesty and of keeping the law.

Legislation

L5 (IAA 1999 Sch 6)

Honesty is weighed in the statutory test of whether a person is competent and otherwise fit to be registered (Sch 6 para 2).

Courts and tribunals

D4 ([2026] UKFTT 1284 (GRC), FT/IMS/2025/0013), D5 ([2026] UKFTT 146 (GRC), FT/IMS/2025/0007), C6 (Dean)

Candour with the regulator is part of honesty: the scheme depends on full disclosure (D4 at [107]), and failing to declare another regulator's investigation goes to fitness (D5). False statements to the IAA or another regulator about supervision are a question of honesty (Dean).

What we are asking you
  1. Is a certified policy the right evidence for Principle 2, or should organizations be asked for something more, such as a record of training?
  2. Should the certification ask expressly about candour with the IAA and other regulators, given how the tribunal decisions turn?
  3. What interval would you expect an organization to set for certifying this duty again?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Principle 2.

Respond on Principle 2
Your view of Principle 2

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 2.1

Code 2.1: be honest and act with integrity in every dealing, professional or personal.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations and advisers
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Linked

For reference. The paragraph has its own entry, with our summary, a link to the IAA's code and its authorities, but nothing on a matter raises it.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • No activity raises Code 2.1
  • Writing or editing a matter note: an edit keeps the earlier version, and a note written after the event shows both times
Why we apply it this way

Code 2.1 applies the Principle to every dealing, and a finding of dishonesty is for the IAA or a tribunal on strong evidence (D15). Legal Workflows does not judge people. What it can do is keep records that show when they were made, which answers the Guidance Notes case study about notes written up later (G1). So the paragraph is reference only, with the note history as supporting evidence.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • No event raises Code 2.1. Whether someone acted honestly is a judgment about a person, which Legal Workflows never makes.
  • Matter notes keep each earlier version and show when a note was written after the event, which helps an organization show its records are genuine.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G20 (Fitness of advisers and owners)

The Guidance Notes list ways integrity can fail, including reckless disregard of the rules, letting someone be deceived and taking unfair advantage. One case study involves attendance notes written up later and a client care letter that was never sent.

Legislation

L5 (IAA 1999 Sch 6)

Honesty is part of the statutory fitness test (Sch 6 para 2).

Courts and tribunals

D4 ([2026] UKFTT 1284 (GRC), FT/IMS/2025/0013), D5 ([2026] UKFTT 146 (GRC), FT/IMS/2025/0007), D15 (IMS/2020/0009), C6 (Dean)

Dishonesty towards another regulator, including about qualifications, goes to fitness for the IAA scheme (D15, D5). Serious allegations are decided on the balance of probabilities but need strong evidence (D15 at [112]). One wrong answer on a form does not alone show unfitness (D4 at [89]).

What we are asking you
  1. Is it right that Code 2.1 never opens an item?
  2. Would the version history of matter notes help you answer an IAA question about when a note was made?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 2.1.

Respond on Code 2.1
Your view of Code 2.1

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 2.2

Code 2.2: tell clients, prospective clients and third parties who you are whenever you advise, act or deal with them.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations and advisers
Kinds of duty (provisional)
identify
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Issuing a letter from a matter on the organization's letterhead, with the sender's name and signature
  • Recording a member as a registered adviser, with their job title, level and categories (a record this would add)
  • Issuing correspondence signed by a member who is not recorded as a registered adviser (a check this would add)
Why we apply it this way

Only a qualified person may give immigration advice (L3), so clients and the Home Office must be able to see who advised. The tribunal reads identification as including who is not an adviser: an unregistered sender signing as supervised suggested they were advising (D2), and an unauthorised person in a consultation risks confusion (D3). So Legal Workflows would check each signer against a record of the organization's registered advisers.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Identify: letters issued from a matter go out on the organization's letterhead, with its regulatory line, and carry the sender's name and signature.
  • The item opens when correspondence is issued by a member the organization has not recorded as a registered adviser (a check this would add).
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G3 (IAA registration explained)

Give your full name, business address, organization and job title, and be ready to show the tribunal, judges and Home Office staff that you are authorized.

Legislation

L3 (IAA 1999 s84), L29 (DMCC 2024)

Only a qualified person may advise (s84), so the client needs to know who advised them. Claiming an approval one does not hold can also be a banned commercial practice (DMCC 2024 Sch 20).

Courts and tribunals

D2 ([2025] UKFTT 290 (GRC)), D3 ([2024] UKFTT 901 (GRC), FT/IMS/2024/0002)

Identification includes making clear who is not an adviser. Emails from unregistered staff signed as working under a registered adviser's supervision suggested they were advising (D2 at [46]), and an unauthorised person sitting in on consultations risks the client thinking they advise (D3 at [72]).

What we are asking you
  1. Should correspondence from a member who is not a registered adviser be held for a person to check, or only flagged?
  2. Should an adviser's job title and IAA status come from the adviser record, so every letter shows them the same way?
  3. Should an unregistered colleague attending a consultation be recorded on the attendance note?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 2.2.

Respond on Code 2.2
Your view of Code 2.2

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 2.3

Code 2.3: tell the Commissioner promptly about any sign of serious misconduct inside your own organization.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations and advisers
Kinds of duty (provisional)
report
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Closing a Code 3.2 or 3.3 item where the facts suggest serious misconduct, which asks whether to report to the IAA (a step this would add)
  • Recording the decision whether to report, by whom and why, and the notification if one is made
Why we apply it this way

Code 2.3 needs a prompt report of any sign of serious misconduct inside the organization, and the IAA keeps reports confidential (G1, G19). Some signs show up on a matter, such as advice from someone not authorized or work above level. So Legal Workflows asks a person for a recorded reporting decision when those items close, and never decides seriousness or sends a report itself, because seriousness is a judgment.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Report: the item asks for a recorded decision on whether to tell the IAA, and records any notification made. Legal Workflows never sends a report itself.
  • Raised when an item on a matter suggests serious misconduct inside the organization, such as advice from someone not authorized (Code 3.2) or work above level (Code 3.3).
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G19 (Whistleblowing policy)

Examples include advice from unregulated staff, work above level, misleading the authorities and improper demands on clients. The IAA keeps reports confidential.

The whistleblowing policy explains how to raise a concern with the IAA and how the reporter is protected, and says organizations must not obstruct a report. The IAA is not a prescribed person under whistleblowing law.

Legislation

L16 (IAA 1999 Sch 5), L14 (IAA 1999 s93)

The reporting duty sits beside the statutory duty to assist the IAA's investigations (Sch 5 para 6), and no restriction on disclosure stops information reaching the IAA (s93(1)).

What we are asking you
  1. Which items on a matter, beyond Codes 3.2 and 3.3, should prompt a decision on reporting to the IAA?
  2. Should the reporting decision be visible only to admins and the primary contact, to protect the person who raised the concern?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 2.3.

Respond on Code 2.3
Your view of Code 2.3

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 2.4

Code 2.4: report serious misconduct you learn of to the regulator or other body responsible for it, without delay.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations and advisers
Kinds of duty (provisional)
report, confidentiality
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Recording a concern about another firm's or adviser's conduct met on a matter, such as a client's former representative (a new record this would add)
  • Recording whether the client consents to the disclosure, or the legal basis for making it
  • Recording the decision whether to report, to which body, and any report made
Why we apply it this way

The duty reaches misconduct by others, for example a client's former representative, but it does not displace confidentiality unless the law or the client permits (G1, L14). So the item asks the confidentiality question first and the reporting decision second, and records both. Legal Workflows sends nothing itself, and never judges whether someone else's conduct is serious.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Report: the item asks for a recorded decision on whether to report to the regulator or body responsible, and records any report made. Legal Workflows never sends one.
  • Confidentiality: before anything is reported, the item asks whether the law or the client's consent permits the disclosure, because Code 4.5 still applies.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G19 (Whistleblowing policy)

Covers misconduct by others that you meet in your work, such as a client's former representatives, reported to their own regulator. It does not override confidentiality unless the law or consent permits, and if the two duties cannot be reconciled you may need to stop acting.

Legislation

L14 (IAA 1999 s93)

Disclosure to the IAA or the tribunal is protected by s93(1). A report to another regulator needs its own lawful route or the client's consent.

What we are asking you
  1. Is recording the consent or legal basis before a report the right order, or should the reporting decision come first?
  2. Should a concern about a former representative also prompt a check of whether the client needs advice about that representative's work?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 2.4.

Respond on Code 2.4
Your view of Code 2.4

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 2.5

Code 2.5: never ask for or take a payment or other benefit, directly or through someone else, in return for referring or recommending a client.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations and advisers
Kinds of duty (provisional)
conflict, record
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Recording how a client was referred when opening a matter, including the referrer (a field this would add)
  • Recording a referral arrangement with another organization or person, and anything given or received under it (a new record this would add)
  • Confirming, when the item closes, that nothing was asked for or accepted in return for the referral
Why we apply it this way

The Code bans asking for or accepting any benefit for a referral, however it is described (G1, G15), and no statute adds to it, so the rule is the IAA's own. The risk shows up in how matters arrive and in arrangements with referrers. So Legal Workflows records the referral source and any arrangement, and asks a person to confirm nothing was received for the referral.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Record: the item asks for any referral arrangement to be recorded, with what passes in each direction, and closes only with evidence attached.
  • Raised when a matter is opened from a referral source the organization has recorded as an arrangement involving payment or another benefit (a record this would add).
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G15 (Signposting and referrals)

Any money or benefit for referring a client fails the Code, whatever it is called.

The signposting note explains how to refer clients properly and why referrals for gain are banned.

Legislation

None specific found

No statute bans referral fees for IAA advisers. The ban is the IAA's own.

What we are asking you
  1. Should every referral source be recorded at matter opening, or only those under a standing arrangement?
  2. Which payments or benefits from third parties should prompt a Code 2.5 check: all of them, or only those from a known referrer?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 2.5.

Respond on Code 2.5
Your view of Code 2.5

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 2.6

Code 2.6: never offer a payment or other benefit, directly or through someone else, to anyone in return for referring or recommending a client.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations and advisers
Kinds of duty (provisional)
conflict, record
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Recording an expense paid to someone who refers clients, with its purpose (a check this would add on the expense record)
  • Recording a marketing arrangement that pays per client introduced (a new record this would add)
  • Confirming, when the item closes, that the payment is genuine advertising and not a reward for referrals
Why we apply it this way

Paying for referrals is banned whether it goes direct or through an intermediary, and a label such as marketing or administration does not change that (G1). Genuine advertising is permitted (G14). The difference lies in what the payment buys, which a person must judge. So Legal Workflows records the arrangement and its payments and asks a person to confirm which side of the line they fall on.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Record: a payment or other benefit to a person or organization that refers clients is recorded with its purpose and evidence.
  • A fee described as administration or marketing is checked like any other, because what matters is what the payment buys, not its label.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G14 (Promotional material), G15 (Signposting and referrals)

Paying a third party under an administration or marketing label to pass clients on fails the Code; genuine advertising does not.

Legislation

None specific found

The ban is the IAA's own; no statute was found that adds to it.

What we are asking you
  1. Is paying per client introduced always a referral payment, or are there advertising models you would treat as genuine?
  2. Should organization-level marketing contracts be recorded in Legal Workflows at all, or kept outside it?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 2.6.

Respond on Code 2.6
Your view of Code 2.6

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 2.7

Code 2.7: an organization registered as non-fee-charging must not charge clients for immigration advice, directly or indirectly.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations registered as non-fee-charging, and their advisersOnly organisations registered as non-fee-charging
Kinds of duty (provisional)
account
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Recording billable time, a recharged expense or an invoice in an organization registered as non-fee-charging
  • Recording a donation or contribution from a client on a matter (a new record this would add)
  • Recording legal aid billing on a matter in an organization registered as non-fee-charging
Why we apply it this way

A non-fee-charging organization may not charge clients at all, and the Guidance Notes read that widely: cost recovery, a demanded donation and legal aid contract income all count (G1). Billing records are where this would show. So Legal Workflows uses the organization's registration category to raise an item on any charging event, and a person records why it is not a charge, or puts it right.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Account: in an organization recorded as non-fee-charging, recording a fee, an invoice or a client payment opens an item (a setting this would add).
  • Income from a legal aid contract counts as charging indirectly, so legal aid billing on a matter raises the same item.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G3 (IAA registration explained)

Any payment for advice needs fee-charging registration, including cost recovery and a donation the client is told to make, and income from a legal aid contract counts as charging indirectly.

Legislation

L5 (IAA 1999 Sch 6), L15 (IAA 1999 s93A)

The registration category affects the fees the organization pays the IAA. The ban on charging clients is the Code's own.

What we are asking you
  1. Should the organization's fee-charging status be a setting, so that billing in a non-fee-charging organization always opens an item?
  2. How should voluntary donations made after a case ends be recorded so they are not mistaken for a fee?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 2.7.

Respond on Code 2.7
Your view of Code 2.7

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 2.8

Code 2.8: where it is relevant, tell clients that legal aid or free advice may be available to them.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations and advisersWhere it is relevant to the client
Kinds of duty (provisional)
inform
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Opening a matter, which asks whether legal aid or free advice was discussed and records the answer
  • Recording that the client was told about legal aid or free advice, by letter or in a matter note
  • Assigning work above the adviser's level, which prompts a referral elsewhere (Code 3.3)
Why we apply it this way

The Code applies where it is relevant, and the Guidance Notes put the moment at take-on, especially for clients who may struggle with fees or disbursements (G1). The tribunal treats pointing a client elsewhere as part of their best interests (D3). So Legal Workflows asks at opening, records the answer, and asks again when the work needed is beyond the adviser's level.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Inform: the item asks for the client to be told about legal aid or free advice, and closes by recording what was said, when and how.
  • Raised when a matter is opened, and again when the work needed is above the adviser's level, where pointing the client elsewhere is part of their best interests (Code 5.1).
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G15 (Signposting and referrals)

At take-on, explain how billing works and consider legal aid, especially where the client may not afford the fees or disbursements such as expert reports.

Courts and tribunals

D3 ([2024] UKFTT 901 (GRC), FT/IMS/2024/0002)

An adviser who cannot help must say so promptly and point the client elsewhere; charging for work that could not help took advantage of the client (D3 at [74] to [75]).

What we are asking you
  1. Is matter opening the right moment, or should the prompt come with the client care letter (Code 5.3)?
  2. Should an organization that only does legal aid work be able to record that, so the prompt is skipped?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 2.8.

Respond on Code 2.8
Your view of Code 2.8

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Principle 3: Regulatory requirements

Principle 3 and Codes 3.1 to 3.8 govern dealings with the IAA, which the statute still calls the Immigration Services Commissioner. They cover authorization, levels and categories, outsourcing, complaints, notifications and exemptions; some bind the adviser personally, others the organization.

Principle 3

Principle 3: meet your legal and regulatory obligations to the IAA and deal with it openly, promptly and cooperatively.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations and advisers
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Linked

For reference. The paragraph has its own entry, with our summary, a link to the IAA's code and its authorities, but nothing on a matter raises it.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • No activity raises Principle 3 on its own
  • Listed beside a Code under Principle 3 when an item cites it, so the person sees the Principle's spirit as well as the Code
Why we apply it this way

Principle 3 states the duty to deal with the IAA openly and promptly, and the Codes beneath it give that content (G1). The Guidance Notes show the Principle can be missed while a Code is met, so the page shows the Principle above each Code rather than raising it separately. Visa Joy (C2) is why the page treats a Code failure as evidence about fitness, not a result.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • No event raises Principle 3 on its own. It is listed beside Codes 3.1 to 3.8 when an item cites one of them.
  • A Code can be met in its letter while the Principle is missed, as the Guidance Notes' example of an adviser lending their name to junior staff's work shows.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G5 (Complaints scheme)

The case study: a Level 2 adviser put their name to work done by Level 1 staff, keeping the letter of Code 3.3 but not its spirit.

Organizations must cooperate with the IAA's complaint investigations, produce documents and give access when required.

Legislation

L16 (IAA 1999 Sch 5), L3 (IAA 1999 s84)

Everyone the Code covers has a statutory duty to comply with it (Sch 5 para 3(4)), and the subject of an investigation must take reasonable steps to assist (para 6). Only qualified persons may advise (s84).

Courts and tribunals

C2 (Visa Joy), C4 (Clarke)

On appeal the tribunal decides fitness and competence for itself on all the evidence, so a failure under the Code is evidence about fitness, not an automatic result (Visa Joy). Supervision must be current and real (Clarke).

What we are asking you
  1. Is it right to show Principle 3 above every Code beneath it, rather than raising it as an item?
  2. Should a request from the IAA during a complaint or audit be recorded as an item under Principle 3 (a new record this would add)?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Principle 3.

Respond on Principle 3
Your view of Principle 3

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 3.1

Code 3.1: give immigration advice or services only for the organization or organizations the IAA has authorized you to work for.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Advisers
Kinds of duty (provisional)
supervise
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Adding a member to a matter as its adviser or as a team member
  • Recording an adviser's IAA registration for this organization, with its level, categories and dates (a record this would add)
  • Keeping an adviser on an open matter after their registration with this organization has ended
Why we apply it this way

Registration belongs to the adviser's work for a particular organization, so an adviser registered elsewhere is not authorized here (G1, G3). Advice without authorization can be an offense (L9), and the person who advised must show they were qualified (Clarke). So Legal Workflows would record registration for each adviser and organization pair and check it whenever someone is put on a matter.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Supervise: an adviser's registration is recorded for each organization they are authorized to work for, with level, categories and dates (a record this would add).
  • The item opens when an adviser is put on a matter in an organization where they have no current recorded registration.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G3 (IAA registration explained)

Working at another regulated organization needs the IAA's approval first.

Registration attaches to the adviser's work for a named organization, and the guide explains the primary contact and Portal administrator roles.

Legislation

L3 (IAA 1999 s84), L9 (IAA 1999 s91)

Advice from someone who is not a qualified person is an offense (s91), and registration is the usual way of being qualified (s84).

Courts and tribunals

C4 (Clarke), C3 (R v K)

Having once worked for a registered body does not qualify someone later, the qualified person must be principal and supervisor for the advice actually given, and the person who advised must prove they were qualified (Clarke at [26] to [36]). What counts is being regulated for the work, not a title (R v K).

What we are asking you
  1. Should the registration record be kept by an admin, or should each adviser keep their own with the organization confirming it?
  2. When a registration ends, should Legal Workflows raise an item on each live matter the adviser is on?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 3.1.

Respond on Code 3.1
Your view of Code 3.1

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 3.2

Code 3.2: make sure nobody who is not authorized gives immigration advice or services on your behalf.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations
Kinds of duty (provisional)
supervise
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Issuing a letter, or recording advice in a matter note, as a member not recorded as an adviser
  • Signing correspondence as working under an adviser's supervision, which opens an item for that adviser to review
  • Recording which adviser supervises each unregistered member's work on a matter (a record this would add)
Why we apply it this way

Unregistered staff may handle administration but must not advise, and a sign-off saying they work under supervision suggests they are advising (D2). Supervision must be live and specific to the advice (Clarke), and the supervisor stays responsible for delegated work, AI-drafted work included (UT1). So Legal Workflows checks advice-giving actions against the adviser record and sends them to a named supervisor.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Supervise: advice-giving actions on a matter, such as issuing a letter or recording advice in a note, by a member not recorded as an adviser open an item for the supervising adviser.
  • A supervisor stays responsible for work they delegate, including drafts made with AI tools (UK and Munir), so the item names the supervisor.
  • Limits on who may work under supervision in the 2025 Act are not yet in force, and the page says so.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G24 (Clarification of jurisdiction), G25 (Solicitors and barristers), G27 (VPRS and VCRS position statement)

Employment does not make someone authorized, and the Code reaches solicitors and barristers who are not regulated for the work. Explaining a Home Office letter to a client is advice; passing it on is not.

The jurisdiction, solicitors and barristers, and resettlement scheme notes explain who may help with which forms and when professionals fall inside IAA regulation.

Legislation

L3 (IAA 1999 s84), L9 (IAA 1999 s91), L4 (IAA 1999 ss84A to 84B, not yet in force)

Code 3.2 mirrors the statutory gate: advice by an unqualified person is an offense. Sections 84A and 84B, on who may work under supervision, are in force only for making regulations.

Courts and tribunals

D2 ([2025] UKFTT 290 (GRC)), D3 ([2024] UKFTT 901 (GRC), FT/IMS/2024/0002), C4 (Clarke), C6 (Dean), UT1 (UK and Munir)

Administrative staff may send invoices and receipts but not advise (D2 at [28], [46]), and an unauthorised person should not sit in on consultations (D3 at [72]).

Supervision must be current and specific to the advice (Clarke), and cannot be used to carry on a practice that is no longer registered (Dean). A supervisor stays responsible for delegated work and should warn staff about general-purpose AI tools (UK and Munir).

What we are asking you
  1. Which actions should count as giving advice: issuing a letter, a note recording advice, or anything the client sees?
  2. Should a supervisor's review be needed before a non-adviser's letter is issued, or only recorded afterwards?
  3. Should the organization's policy on AI tools be part of what the supervisor confirms (UK and Munir)?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 3.2.

Respond on Code 3.2
Your view of Code 3.2

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 3.3

Code 3.3: work only within your authorized level and categories unless the Commissioner has given written permission to go beyond them.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations and advisers
Kinds of duty (provisional)
supervise
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Opening a matter of a case type mapped to a minimum level and category (a mapping this would add)
  • Assigning a matter or task to an adviser whose recorded level or categories are below what it needs
  • Recording the IAA's written permission to work above level, with its scope and end date (a record this would add)
  • Instructing counsel from a matter where the adviser is Level 1
Why we apply it this way

This is the IAA's most product-relevant duty. Levels are fixed by the task (D3, UT2) and set out in the Guidance on competence (G2), and permission to go beyond them is written, scoped and time-limited (D12). Work above level is outside registration and can be an offense (L5, L9). So Legal Workflows compares each matter's work with the adviser's recorded level and categories, and accepts only recorded written permission as the exception.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Supervise: each case type maps to the minimum level and category in the Guidance on competence, and each adviser has a recorded level and categories (records this would add).
  • The item opens when a matter or task goes to an adviser below the level or outside the category, unless the IAA's written permission is recorded with its scope and dates.
  • Judicial review is its own category at Level 3, and a Level 1 adviser may not instruct a barrister (Code 3.4).
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G2 (Guidance on competence), G9 (Supervision of trainee advisers), G1 (Guidance Notes), G23 (Judicial review case management), G26 (EU Settlement Scheme advisers)

The Guidance on competence defines Levels 1 to 3 and the categories (Immigration; Asylum and Protection; Judicial Review Case Management, Level 3 only), and the work permitted at each.

The supervision note explains how an organization applies to supervise a trainee above their level, and the supervisor's file reviews and logbook. Every adviser must be registered before advising, and acting as a McKenzie friend is not permitted.

A Level 1 registration limited to the EU Settlement Scheme is available to non-profit organizations.

Legislation

L5 (IAA 1999 Sch 6), L3 (IAA 1999 s84), L9 (IAA 1999 s91)

Levels and categories are registration with limited effect (Sch 6 para 2(2)), so work above level is outside the authorization s84 gives and can engage the s91 offense.

Courts and tribunals

D3 ([2024] UKFTT 901 (GRC), FT/IMS/2024/0002), UT2 (Hoxha), D12 ([2025] UKFTT 454 (GRC), IMS/2023/0006), D10 ([2024] UKFTT 1084 (GRC), FT/IMS/2024/0003), D11 ([2025] UKFTT 809 (GRC), FT/IMS/2024/0007)

Levels are set by the task: taking detailed asylum instructions and drafting a witness statement is Level 2 work (D3 at [50]), and judicial review needs Level 3 and its own category (Hoxha).

Earlier permission to work above level under a supervision plan was limited in time and gave no entitlement (D12). A current assessment is needed at the level claimed (D10, D11).

What we are asking you
  1. Is mapping case types to a minimum level and category workable, or does the level needed change too often within a matter?
  2. Should a mismatch block the assignment, or open an item that a supervisor closes?
  3. Should individual tasks, such as drafting a witness statement or a judicial review claim, carry their own level?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 3.3.

Respond on Code 3.3
Your view of Code 3.3

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 3.4

Code 3.4: outsource only work that falls within your own approved level and categories, and get the client's consent before obtaining further advice, opinions or other professional services for them.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations and advisersOnly when work is outsourced or further advice is sought
Kinds of duty (provisional)
consent, supervise, record
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Instructing counsel, an expert or another provider from a matter (a new record this would add)
  • Recording the client's written consent to the instruction, with the document that evidences it
  • Recording the reason for outsourcing and confirming the work is within the organization's own level and categories
Why we apply it this way

The organization may only outsource work it could do itself, must have the client's prior consent, and stays responsible for what comes back (G1). Level 1 advisers may not instruct barristers, and Level 2 and 3 advisers may do so through licensed access (G2, G22). So Legal Workflows records each instruction with its consent and reason, and checks it against the organization's level before it goes out.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Consent: the item records the client's prior written consent before further advice or services are sought, and the document that evidences it.
  • Supervise: outsourcing is checked against the organization's own level and categories, so a Level 1 adviser instructing a barrister opens an item.
  • Record: the reason for outsourcing is recorded, and the organization stays responsible for the work.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G22 (Licensed access scheme), G2 (Guidance on competence), G15 (Signposting and referrals)

Get the client's written consent; outsource only part of a case, and only to regulated or lawfully permitted providers; the organization stays responsible and pays; record the reason; explain fully if work goes overseas; protect confidentiality.

Level 2 and 3 advisers may instruct barristers directly through the licensed access scheme; Level 1 advisers may not instruct barristers.

Courts and tribunals

D2 ([2025] UKFTT 290 (GRC))

Naming the third-party provider is not required, but the client's consent is (D2 at [80]).

What we are asking you
  1. Should consent be needed before each instruction, or can one consent in the client care letter cover a kind of instruction?
  2. Should outsourcing work overseas need a separate confirmation that the client was told?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 3.4.

Respond on Code 3.4
Your view of Code 3.4

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 3.5

Code 3.5: keep a written complaints procedure that works, and follow it whenever a complaint is made.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations
Kinds of duty (provisional)
record, inform, review
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Recording a complaint from a client on the matter, which adds it to the organization's complaints log (a new record this would add)
  • Setting a key date for each stage the organization's procedure sets, with reminders
  • Recording a complaint the IAA redirects to the organization, with a key date two weeks ahead
  • Issuing the response letter, recorded on the correspondence register
Why we apply it this way

The Code needs a procedure that works and is followed, and the Guidance Notes expect a central log and a response that tells the client about the IAA (G1). The redirection scheme gives the organization two weeks (G6). So Legal Workflows would record each complaint against its matter and in one log, time each stage with key dates, and check that the response mentions the IAA.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Record: a client complaint is recorded on its matter and in the organization's complaints log, with its dates, investigation and response (a new record this would add).
  • Inform: the response tells the client they may go to the IAA at any time, and the item checks that it does.
  • A complaint the IAA sends back to the organization gets a key date two weeks ahead for the organization's own investigation.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G7 (Investigating client's complaints), G6 (Complaints redirection scheme), G13 (Model documents), G5 (Complaints scheme), G4 (Regulations summary)

The procedure should say how and to whom to complain, including the IAA, set timescales, describe the investigation and the result, keep a central log, and say the client may go to the IAA at any time.

The IAA may send a complaint back for the organization to resolve under its own procedure within two weeks, and report back. A model complaints procedure is published.

Legislation

L16 (IAA 1999 Sch 5), L28 (CCR 2013)

The IAA's complaints scheme is statutory (Sch 5 paras 5 to 6). For retainers made at a distance or off premises, consumer information duties apply alongside the procedure.

Courts and tribunals

D2 ([2025] UKFTT 290 (GRC))

A client care letter with no complaints procedure was treated as a significant failure (D2 at [75]).

What we are asking you
  1. Should the complaints log be visible to every admin, or only to a named complaints handler?
  2. Should the two weeks for a redirected complaint run from the date the IAA sends it or the date it is received?
  3. Should the client care letter check (Code 5.3) confirm the complaints procedure was included?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 3.5.

Respond on Code 3.5
Your view of Code 3.5

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 3.6

Code 3.6: tell the Commissioner in writing, within a reasonable time, of significant changes to the business or to the personal circumstances of its advisers and the people who run it.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations and advisers, about advisers and those who run the business
Kinds of duty (provisional)
report
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Parallel (self-certified)

Legal Workflows does not monitor this duty. The organization certifies, with evidence it chooses, that it monitors the duty outside the platform, and certifies again at an interval it sets.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • An admin or the IAA primary contact certifying, with evidence it chooses, how it tells the IAA of significant changes (a certification this would add)
  • Certifying again at the interval the organization sets, or when the evidence it cited is replaced
  • Changing the organization's offices in Legal Workflows, which reminds an admin of the duty without recording the notice (a prompt this would add)
Why we apply it this way

Most changes the IAA wants to hear about concern people's health, finances, status or legal troubles, which Legal Workflows should not hold (G1). The tribunal decisions show the scheme depends on candid self-reporting (D4). So the organization certifies its notification process, and Legal Workflows only reminds an admin when an organization-level change is made in the platform, such as a new office.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Covered by the organization's certification that it tells the IAA of significant changes to the business and to the circumstances of its advisers and those who run it.
  • Legal Workflows never records staff health, finances, immigration status or legal proceedings. The provisional type (report) describes the duty; no product event opens an item.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G4 (Regulations summary), G10 (Cover in the absence of an adviser), G20 (Fitness of advisers and owners), G8 (CPD scheme)

The Guidance Notes list changes to notify, not exhaustively: how services are delivered, offshore work, ownership and management, staff, bank or insurer, address, closing, and a new legal entity before it happens; and for people, serious illness, long absence, bankruptcy, loss of the right to work, arrest or investigation, and another regulator's proceedings.

The regulations summary suggests changes affecting fitness or competence are notified within 10 days.

Legislation

L5 (IAA 1999 Sch 6)

Failing to give information asked for on continued registration can end the registration (Sch 6 para 3).

Courts and tribunals

D4 ([2026] UKFTT 1284 (GRC), FT/IMS/2025/0013), D8 ([2026] UKFTT 335 (GRC), FT/IMS/2025/0014), D9 ([2026] UKFTT 726 (GRC), FT/IMS/2026/0001)

The scheme depends on self-reporting and full disclosure (D4 at [107]). A new company is a new registration, which must meet current requirements (D8, D9).

What we are asking you
  1. Is certification right for Code 3.6, or would you want a private log of notifications made to the IAA?
  2. Should adding or moving an office prompt a reminder that the IAA expects a new business address within 10 working days (Code 8.1)?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 3.6.

Respond on Code 3.6
Your view of Code 3.6

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 3.7

Code 3.7: tell the Commissioner in writing straight away if an adviser or anyone running the business is criminally charged or convicted, or faces relevant civil proceedings.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations and advisers, about advisers and those who run the business
Kinds of duty (provisional)
report
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Parallel (self-certified)

Legal Workflows does not monitor this duty. The organization certifies, with evidence it chooses, that it monitors the duty outside the platform, and certifies again at an interval it sets.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • An admin or the IAA primary contact certifying, with evidence it chooses, how it tells the IAA of charges and proceedings (a certification this would add)
  • Certifying again at the interval the organization sets, or when the evidence it cited is replaced
  • Never recording any charge, conviction or civil claim against a member
Why we apply it this way

The duty is immediate and concerns criminal and civil matters about named people, which Legal Workflows should not hold (G1). What the product can help with is the effect on clients: cover arrangements and file transfers become urgent when an adviser stops working (D7). So the organization certifies its notification process, and Codes 5.6 and 5.9 deal with the client side.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Covered by the organization's certification that it tells the IAA straight away of any criminal charge, conviction or relevant civil proceedings against an adviser or anyone running the business.
  • Legal Workflows never records proceedings against staff. A charge may also affect client cover (Code 5.6) and file transfers (Code 5.9).
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G20 (Fitness of advisers and owners)

Notify as soon as reasonably practicable and do not wait for the result. Relevant civil matters include bankruptcy, insolvency, repossession and discrimination claims.

Legislation

L5 (IAA 1999 Sch 6)

A charge for certain offenses, including dishonesty and indictable offenses, lets the IAA ask the tribunal to act on the person's registration before any trial (Sch 6 para 4B).

Courts and tribunals

D7 (FT/IMS/2025/0005), D6 ([2026] UKFTT 135 (GRC), FT/IMS/2025/0006)

The tribunal's power after a charge is discretionary and weighs risk to the public, public confidence, the effect on adviser and clients, and proportionality; a company's registration is separate from its director's (D7). Past convictions also go to fitness under Code 4.1 (D6).

What we are asking you
  1. Is it right that Legal Workflows never records a charge against a member, even privately?
  2. When an adviser stops work suddenly, would a bulk handover of their matters, with letters to their clients, be useful (Codes 5.6 and 5.9)?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 3.7.

Respond on Code 3.7
Your view of Code 3.7

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 3.8

Code 3.8: to be excused from any part of the Code, apply to the Commissioner in writing and wait for written approval first.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
OrganisationsOnly an organisation seeking an exemption
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Linked

For reference. The paragraph has its own entry, with our summary, a link to the IAA's code and its authorities, but nothing on a matter raises it.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • No activity on a matter raises Code 3.8
  • Recording a written exemption from the IAA, with its letter, scope and dates, which stops items for that Code (a record this would add)
Why we apply it this way

An exemption exists only once the IAA approves it in writing (G1). Legal Workflows cannot know that until someone records it, and must not treat an application as an exemption. So Code 3.8 is a reference page, and a recorded exemption with its letter changes which items the organization sees, for as long as the exemption lasts.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • No event raises Code 3.8. An exemption the IAA grants in writing would be recorded with its letter, and would stop items for that Code in that organization.
  • Until the written approval arrives, the Code applies in full.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes)

Exemption is for a justified case where a Code does not fit a type of organization, and the requirement stands until written authority arrives.

Legislation

L16 (IAA 1999 Sch 5)

No express statutory power to grant exemptions from the Code was found in Sch 5 para 3.

What we are asking you
  1. Should a recorded exemption need a second admin to confirm it before items stop?
  2. Do you hold an exemption, and what kind of Code does it cover?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 3.8.

Respond on Code 3.8
Your view of Code 3.8

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Principle 4: Competence and confidentiality

Principle 4 and Code 4.5 bind organizations and advisers, and Codes 4.1 to 4.4 bind each adviser personally. They cover fitness, competent advice, current knowledge, continuing professional development and client confidentiality.

Principle 4

Principle 4: act competently and keep client information confidential.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations and advisers
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Linked

For reference. The paragraph has its own entry, with our summary, a link to the IAA's code and its authorities, but nothing on a matter raises it.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • No activity raises Principle 4 on its own
  • Listed beside Code 4.2 or 4.5 when an item cites one of them
Why we apply it this way

Principle 4 joins two different duties, competence and confidentiality, and its Codes give each its content (G1). The statutory tests of fitness and competence are judged overall (L2, L5, C2). So Legal Workflows raises the Codes and shows the Principle above them, and never treats a single item as a finding about a person's fitness.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • No event raises Principle 4 on its own. It is listed beside Codes 4.2 and 4.5 when an item cites them.
  • A persistent pattern of failures can itself show a lack of fitness, so the page links Code 4.1.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G2 (Guidance on competence)

A pattern of failures, especially after audits or complaints, can itself show a lack of fitness.

Legislation

L2 (IAA 1999 s83), L5 (IAA 1999 Sch 6)

Fitness and competence are the statutory tests for registration (s83(5), Sch 6 para 2).

Courts and tribunals

C2 (Visa Joy), D1 ([2026] UKFTT 1305 (GRC), FT/IMS/2025/0015)

Fitness is judged overall and at the date of the hearing; a failure under the Code is evidence, not the end of the analysis (Visa Joy at [40] to [44]; D1 at [69]).

What we are asking you
  1. Is it right to show Principle 4 only above its Codes?
  2. Would a count of items on an adviser's matters be useful to a supervisor, or would it be read as a judgment of fitness?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Principle 4.

Respond on Principle 4
Your view of Principle 4

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 4.1

Code 4.1: remain fit to give immigration advice and services.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Advisers
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Parallel (self-certified)

Legal Workflows does not monitor this duty. The organization certifies, with evidence it chooses, that it monitors the duty outside the platform, and certifies again at an interval it sets.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • An admin or the IAA primary contact certifying, with evidence it chooses, the organization's fitness checks on advisers (a certification this would add)
  • Certifying again at the interval the organization sets, or when the evidence it cited is replaced
  • Never recording a person's convictions, debts or regulatory history
Why we apply it this way

Fitness is a judgment about a person's character, honesty and history, and the tribunal weighs allegations, other regulators' findings and spent convictions (D4, D5, D6). Holding that information in a practice platform would be intrusive and outside its purpose. So the organization certifies its own fitness checks, and Legal Workflows stays out of the judgment.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Covered by the organization's certification that it checks its advisers' fitness when they join and as time goes on.
  • Legal Workflows never records a person's convictions, finances or character, and never judges fitness.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G20 (Fitness of advisers and owners), G1 (Guidance Notes), G8 (CPD scheme)

The fitness guidance explains how the IAA judges advisers and those who own or run an organization, including honesty, keeping the law and financial history.

Fitness covers good character, safeguarding and meeting the role's requirements; convictions, regulatory findings, finances and dishonesty are all weighed.

Legislation

L5 (IAA 1999 Sch 6), L2 (IAA 1999 s83)

Fitness is a statutory test for registration and continued registration (Sch 6 paras 2 and 3).

Courts and tribunals

D4 ([2026] UKFTT 1284 (GRC), FT/IMS/2025/0013), D5 ([2026] UKFTT 146 (GRC), FT/IMS/2025/0007), D6 ([2026] UKFTT 135 (GRC), FT/IMS/2025/0006), D13 ([2025] UKFTT 1136 (GRC), FT/IMS/2024/0006), D15 (IMS/2020/0009), C2 (Visa Joy)

Competence and fitness are separate, and a competent adviser who lacks candour can fall short (D4 at [103]). Another regulator's findings and spent dishonesty convictions are relevant (D5, D6), and dishonesty outside casework still goes to fitness (D15).

The IAA's assessment is its own route, separate from qualification as a solicitor (D13). Fitness is judged at the date of the hearing (Visa Joy).

What we are asking you
  1. Should the certification list what the organization checks, such as employment disciplinary findings, allegations and other regulators' investigations, which the tribunal treats as relevant?
  2. Is a yearly certification the right interval for fitness?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 4.1.

Respond on Code 4.1
Your view of Code 4.1

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 4.2

Code 4.2: give clients advice that is timely, easy to follow and competent.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Advisers
Kinds of duty (provisional)
inform, review
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Recording advice in a matter note, with the options, requirements, timescales, risks and costs explained
  • Recording that an interpreter was used, drawing on the client's recorded interpreter language
  • Drafting with the assistant, where a person approves every draft and every quotation is checked
  • No advice recorded on a matter within a set number of days of instructions (a check this would add)
Why we apply it this way

Competent advice is timely, clear and correct, and the Guidance Notes list what the client must be told (G1). The Upper Tribunal has shown how AI drafting and unchecked reports go wrong (UT1, UT2), and that the client usually bears the cost (UT3). Careless advice belongs here rather than under Code 1.2, which now needs knowledge or recklessness. So Legal Workflows records advice given and checks drafts before they go.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Inform: advice given is recorded in a matter note or letter, covering the course of action, requirements, timescales, risks and costs.
  • Review: the assistant verifies every quotation and a person approves every draft, because unverified citations are the risk UK and Munir describes.
  • Careless or mistaken advice is considered here, not under Code 1.2, which needs knowledge or recklessness.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G17 (Interpreters and translators), G16 (Vulnerable clients), G2 (Guidance on competence), G23 (Judicial review case management)

Take instructions; explain the course of action, the requirements, timescales, risks and costs; consider an interpreter. A case study involves advice on a remedy that had been abolished months earlier.

The interpreters and vulnerable clients notes explain how to make advice clear to clients who need language or other support.

Courts and tribunals

UT1 (UK and Munir), UT2 (Hoxha), UT3 (Mansur), D2 ([2025] UKFTT 290 (GRC)), D3 ([2024] UKFTT 901 (GRC), FT/IMS/2024/0002)

Authorities must be real and checked, and a supervisor stays responsible for delegated drafting (UK and Munir). A representative relying on an expert report must check how its information was obtained (Hoxha). An adviser's failure usually falls on the client, so poor advice has high stakes (Mansur).

Under the 2016 code negligent advice could mislead (D2 at [54]); under the 2024 Code it belongs here. Advising promptly that the adviser cannot help is part of competent advice (D3).

What we are asking you
  1. Should Legal Workflows prompt for advice to be recorded within a set time of instructions, and what time would you use?
  2. Is checking every quotation and keeping a person on every draft enough, or should drafts with citations need a second reader?
  3. Should the use of an interpreter be recorded on each note, not only the client's language?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 4.2.

Respond on Code 4.2
Your view of Code 4.2

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 4.3

Code 4.3: keep your immigration and asylum knowledge up to date and deep enough for the work you do.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Advisers
Kinds of duty (provisional)
supervise, review
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Parallel (self-certified)

Legal Workflows does not monitor this duty. The organization certifies, with evidence it chooses, that it monitors the duty outside the platform, and certifies again at an interval it sets.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • An admin or the IAA primary contact certifying, with evidence it chooses, how it keeps advisers' knowledge current (a certification this would add)
  • Certifying again at the interval the organization sets, or when the evidence it cited is replaced
Why we apply it this way

Keeping knowledge current is a personal duty, shown by learning and supervision rather than by anything on a matter (G1). Whether an adviser knows enough for a particular case is a judgment Legal Workflows cannot make. So the organization certifies how it identifies and fills gaps, and Code 3.3 deals with the separate question of whether an adviser is authorized for a matter's work (D11).

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Covered by the organization's certification that it identifies and fills gaps in its advisers' and staff's knowledge.
  • The provisional types (supervise, review) describe the duty; because the organization certifies it, no product event opens an item.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G2 (Guidance on competence), G8 (CPD scheme)

Identify and fill gaps for yourself and your staff, and do not act in an area where your knowledge is thin, even if you are authorized for it.

Courts and tribunals

D10 ([2024] UKFTT 1084 (GRC), FT/IMS/2024/0003), D11 ([2025] UKFTT 809 (GRC), FT/IMS/2024/0007), D12 ([2025] UKFTT 454 (GRC), IMS/2023/0006), D14 ([2025] UKFTT 959 (GRC), FT/IMS/2025/0003)

A current assessment is needed at the level claimed, and long experience does not replace one when the last assessment and audit are years old (D11 at [226], [237]). The question is whether the person is competent (D14).

What we are asking you
  1. Should the certification be made for each adviser or for the organization as a whole?
  2. Would a reminder to the supervisor be useful when an adviser takes a first matter of a new case type?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 4.3.

Respond on Code 4.3
Your view of Code 4.3

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 4.4

Code 4.4: be able to show that you meet the Commissioner's continuing professional development requirements.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Advisers
Kinds of duty (provisional)
record, review
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Parallel (self-certified)

Legal Workflows does not monitor this duty. The organization certifies, with evidence it chooses, that it monitors the duty outside the platform, and certifies again at an interval it sets.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • An admin or the IAA primary contact certifying, with evidence it chooses, that advisers keep CPD records (a certification this would add)
  • Certifying again each year, or when the evidence it cited is replaced
Why we apply it this way

The CPD scheme is based on outcomes and expects a yearly cycle of planning, doing, recording and reviewing (G8), and organizations already keep these records. Recording learning has no matter to hang on. So the organization certifies that it keeps them, with evidence of its choice, and Legal Workflows does not duplicate a CPD log.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Covered by the organization's certification that its advisers plan, record and review their continuing professional development at least once a year.
  • The evidence can be the organization's own CPD records, uploaded as it chooses.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G8 (CPD scheme), G1 (Guidance Notes), G3 (IAA registration explained)

The scheme sets no hours: advisers plan, do, record and review their development at least yearly, and the adviser and organization must be able to show it.

Legislation

None specific found

Continuing professional development is a requirement of the IAA alone.

What we are asking you
  1. Would you want a CPD log in Legal Workflows, or is certification with evidence enough?
  2. Should the yearly certification follow the organization's IAA continued registration date?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 4.4.

Respond on Code 4.4
Your view of Code 4.4

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 4.5

Code 4.5: keep each client's affairs confidential unless the law or the Code requires otherwise or the client expressly agrees to disclosure.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations and advisers
Kinds of duty (provisional)
confidentiality, consent
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Integrated (already live)

Legal Workflows already acts on this duty today. It will add the paragraph's own page, and cite the paragraph on what the product already does.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Opening a matter: only its members can see its documents, notes and chats
  • Setting up an information barrier that screens named members from a matter
  • Recording a disclosure outside the matter, with the client's consent or the legal basis for it (a new record this would add)
  • Using the assistant on a matter's documents, where nothing is used for training and a person approves every draft
Why we apply it this way

Confidentiality limits who sees a client's affairs, and data protection asks whether a disclosure has a lawful basis; they are separate questions (D1, L26). The Upper Tribunal has said that putting client documents into a general-purpose AI tool is inconsistent with confidentiality (UT1). So Legal Workflows keeps the boundary it already enforces, matter membership and barriers, and would add a record of each outside disclosure with its consent or legal basis.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Already live: matter membership is the confidentiality boundary, information barriers screen named members from a matter, and conflict results are shown in full only to reviewers.
  • Consent: a disclosure outside the matter would record the client's express consent or the legal basis that permits it, as separate questions (D1).
  • Uploading client documents to a general-purpose AI tool is inconsistent with confidentiality (UK and Munir). The assistant uses nothing for training and a person approves every draft.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G18 (Data protection), G21 (Premises audit)

Limit access; staff are responsible for secure handling and disposal; disclosure may be required by statute, a court order or the IAA; not misleading outranks confidentiality, so stop acting if they collide; serious harm or crime may justify disclosure after careful, recorded thought.

The data protection note explains UK GDPR duties and asks organizations to record decisions to share data, with whom and why.

Legislation

L26 (UK GDPR arts 5, 6, 32), L14 (IAA 1999 s93), L11 (IAA 1999 s92A), L16 (IAA 1999 Sch 5)

Confidentiality and data protection are separate tests, and consent is only one lawful basis (UK GDPR art 6). Disclosure to the IAA or the tribunal is protected (s93(1)), and a search warrant can reach privileged material (s92A(7)).

Courts and tribunals

D1 ([2026] UKFTT 1305 (GRC), FT/IMS/2025/0015), UT1 (UK and Munir)

Disclosure to a compliance consultant to answer a live complaint was not shown to fall short of confidentiality, and UK GDPR consent is only one lawful basis (D1 at [120] to [121]). Uploading confidential documents to an open AI tool waives privilege and should be referred to the Information Commissioner (UK and Munir, headnote 4).

What we are asking you
  1. Is matter membership the right default boundary for an advice organization, or do supervisors need wider access by default?
  2. Should a disclosure record ask for consent and legal basis separately, as D1 suggests?
  3. Should Legal Workflows remind a member about general-purpose AI tools when they download a matter document?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 4.5.

Respond on Code 4.5
Your view of Code 4.5

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Principle 5: Client's best interests and service

Principle 5 and Codes 5.1 to 5.10 follow the client relationship from the client care letter to updates, closure, file transfer and retention. Most bind organizations and advisers; cover arrangements (5.6) and retention (5.10) are for the organization.

Principle 5

Principle 5: act in each client's best interests, deal with clients professionally and give them a good standard of service.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations and advisers
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Linked

For reference. The paragraph has its own entry, with our summary, a link to the IAA's code and its authorities, but nothing on a matter raises it.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • No activity raises Principle 5 on its own
  • Listed beside a Code under Principle 5 when an item cites it, with Principle 6 where both may be engaged
Why we apply it this way

Principle 5 is given content by ten Codes that run from first contact to retention (G1), and those Codes are where events show up. Where the client's wishes pull against honesty, the rule of law or public trust, those come first, and weighing that is a judgment for a person. So Legal Workflows lists the Principles together and does not resolve the tension.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • No event raises Principle 5 on its own. It is listed beside Codes 5.1 to 5.10 when an item cites them.
  • Principles 1, 2 and 6 come before the client's interests where they conflict, so an item that may engage Principles 5 and 6 lists both and leaves the choice to a person.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes)

Where the Principles conflict, the rule of law, honesty and public trust come before the client's wishes.

Legislation

L2 (IAA 1999 s83)

Acting in clients' best interests is a statutory aim of the scheme (s83(5)).

Courts and tribunals

UT3 (Mansur)

An adviser's failure is usually borne by the client, not discounted against immigration control (Mansur).

What we are asking you
  1. Is it right that Legal Workflows lists Principles 5 and 6 together and never suggests which prevails?
  2. Are there events on a matter that should raise Principle 5 directly, without a Code beneath it?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Principle 5.

Respond on Principle 5
Your view of Principle 5

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 5.1

Code 5.1: act in your client's best interests at all times.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Advisers
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Linked

For reference. The paragraph has its own entry, with our summary, a link to the IAA's code and its authorities, but nothing on a matter raises it.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • No activity raises Code 5.1 on its own
  • Closing a matter because the organization withdrew, which records why (Code 5.8)
  • Assigning work above the adviser's level, which prompts a referral elsewhere (Code 3.3)
Why we apply it this way

Acting in the client's best interests is a judgment on each case's facts, and the Guidance Notes give withdrawal as the moment it most often goes wrong (G1). Legal Workflows cannot judge interests, but it can record why an organization stopped acting. So Code 5.1 is a reference page, listed beside Codes 3.3 and 5.8 where those events occur (D3).

How it works in Signal & Line
  • No event raises Code 5.1 on its own. Best interests are judged on the facts of each case.
  • Withdrawing from a case is recorded with its reason, because stopping suddenly without good reason may engage this Code (Code 5.8).
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G15 (Signposting and referrals), G23 (Judicial review case management)

Tailor advice, advise against groundless claims, and decline to act where right. Stopping suddenly may fall short unless there is good reason: a conflict, work above level, a breakdown in the relationship, a likely failure under the Code, or unpaid fees left unresolved.

Legislation

L2 (IAA 1999 s83)

Best interests is the statutory aim (s83(5)).

Courts and tribunals

D3 ([2024] UKFTT 901 (GRC), FT/IMS/2024/0002), UT3 (Mansur)

Charging for work that could not help the client was against their interests (D3 at [74] to [75]), and poor advice usually falls on the client (Mansur).

What we are asking you
  1. Should closing a matter because the organization withdrew need a reason from a fixed list that matches the Guidance Notes?
  2. Is a reference page right for Code 5.1, or should it be listed with every Code under Principle 5?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 5.1.

Respond on Code 5.1
Your view of Code 5.1

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 5.2

Code 5.2: where a conflict of interest exists or may arise, explain it to the client or prospective client in writing and get their written consent before acting.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations and advisersOnly where a real or potential conflict exists
Kinds of duty (provisional)
conflict, inform, consent, record
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Integrated (already live)

Legal Workflows already acts on this duty today. It will add the paragraph's own page, and cite the paragraph on what the product already does.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Running a conflict check against the organization's party register when a matter is opened
  • Recording a decision to act with consent, with the client's signed and dated consent document
  • Recording the organization's own links to companies or services it may use for clients (a register this would add)
Why we apply it this way

The Code needs the conflict explained in writing and written consent before acting (G1), and the tribunal held that oral notice is not enough and that a connected company is a potential conflict in itself (D2). The conflict search and its recorded decision already do most of this. So Legal Workflows ties the decision to the written explanation and consent, and would add a record of the organization's own connected businesses.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Already live: a conflict search runs on the party register, and its recorded decision and any consents are kept and never edited.
  • Inform and consent: the item records the written explanation to the client and their signed, dated consent before acting.
  • A company under common control with the organization is a potential conflict without proof of benefit (D2).
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G17 (Interpreters and translators)

Commercial, financial, cultural, community or political ties, and opposing clients, can conflict. Give the client time to decide, keep signed and dated consent, and still judge whether to act. Raise perceived conflicts too.

The explanation must be clear to the client, using an interpreter or translation where needed.

Courts and tribunals

D2 ([2025] UKFTT 290 (GRC))

Using a company under common control raised the potential conflict duty without proof of benefit. Disclosure must be in writing and consent given beforehand; telling the client orally is not enough (D2 at [60]).

What we are asking you
  1. Should the organization's own connected businesses be checked in every conflict search?
  2. Is a signed consent document enough evidence, or should the item also record that the client had time to decide?
  3. Should cultural, community or political ties an adviser declares be recorded, and if so, who should see them?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 5.2.

Respond on Code 5.2
Your view of Code 5.2

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 5.3

Code 5.3: give every prospective client a client care letter that does its job.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations and advisers
Kinds of duty (provisional)
inform, identify
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Recording a first consultation on a matter, which asks for a client care letter (a step this would add)
  • Generating the client care letter from a template and issuing it, recorded on the correspondence register
  • Raising an invoice or payment request on a matter with no issued client care letter
Why we apply it this way

Every prospective client must have an effective letter, and the Guidance Notes list what it must cover (G1, G13). The tribunal fixes the latest point as the first invoice or request for payment (D2). So Legal Workflows asks for the letter after a first consultation, raises an item if billing starts without one, and would offer a starter template built on the IAA's model.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Inform: the item asks for the client care letter to be issued, and closes by recording it on the correspondence register.
  • Raised after a prospective client's first consultation, and at the latest before an invoice or a request for payment (D2).
  • A starter client care letter template would follow the IAA's model and the listed contents, including complaints and indemnity insurance.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G13 (Model documents), G4 (Regulations summary)

A prospective client is someone who has had a first consultation and expects the relationship to continue. The Guidance Notes list the letter's contents: the client, their status, instructions and work, costs, client money, extra costs, adviser contact, originals, complaints, terms, IAA regulation and file access, and responsibility for the work.

The IAA publishes a model letter, and its regulations summary recommends a paragraph on professional indemnity insurance.

Legislation

L28 (CCR 2013)

Where the retainer is made at a distance or off premises, consumer information duties and cooling-off rights apply, and work during the cooling-off period needs the client's express request (regs 13 and 36).

Courts and tribunals

D2 ([2025] UKFTT 290 (GRC)), D1 ([2026] UKFTT 1305 (GRC), FT/IMS/2025/0015)

The duty arises at the latest when the adviser invoices or asks for payment, and a referral through a third party increases the need to deal with the client directly (D2 at [67]). An unsigned letter is weaker evidence but does not by itself show fabrication (D1).

What we are asking you
  1. Is the first consultation the right trigger, or should the letter be asked for when the matter is opened?
  2. Should Legal Workflows check a client care letter template for each listed content item before it can be published?
  3. Where the retainer is made at a distance, should the item also ask about cooling-off rights?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 5.3.

Respond on Code 5.3
Your view of Code 5.3

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 5.4

Code 5.4: keep evidence that the client agreed to the client care letter, either a signed and dated copy or an electronic record of agreement.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations and advisers
Kinds of duty (provisional)
consent, record
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Attaching the client's signed and dated client care letter to the matter
  • Recording a client's electronic agreement to the letter (a new record this would add)
  • Recording in a matter note why agreement could not be had yet, for example because the client is in detention
Why we apply it this way

The Code's own introduction gives detention as the case where the letter cannot be agreed at once, and the Guidance Notes ask for a file note and agreement before further work (G1). An unsigned letter is weaker evidence, though not proof of fabrication (D1). So Legal Workflows keeps the item open until agreement is recorded, and accepts a note of the reason in the meantime.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Consent: the item records the client's agreement to the client care letter, as a signed and dated copy or an electronic record of agreement.
  • Where agreement cannot be had at once, for example in detention, the item records the reason in a matter note and stays open until agreement is recorded.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G13 (Model documents)

The adviser must be able to show the client understood. In urgent cases, such as detention, work may start with a file note, but the letter must be agreed before further work.

Courts and tribunals

D1 ([2026] UKFTT 1305 (GRC), FT/IMS/2025/0015)

An unsigned letter may carry less weight as evidence, but that alone does not show it was made up later (D1).

What we are asking you
  1. Should the item stop further time being recorded on the matter until agreement is recorded, or only remind?
  2. What evidence of electronic agreement would you accept: an email reply, a portal click, or something else?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 5.4.

Respond on Code 5.4
Your view of Code 5.4

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 5.5

Code 5.5: keep each client regularly updated in writing on how their case is progressing.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations and advisers
Kinds of duty (provisional)
inform
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Issuing a letter or email to the client, which resets the three-month key date for the next update
  • Recording an outcome or Home Office decision on the matter, which sets a key date three working days ahead (a step this would add)
  • Reaching a key date with no written update recorded, which alerts the matter's adviser
Why we apply it this way

The Code needs regular written updates, and the Guidance Notes set the floor at three months and the outcome within three working days, by letter or email (G1). These are clocks Legal Workflows can keep from the correspondence register and key dates. So it times both, and treats them as expected unless a person records why the case needs something different, as the Code's introduction permits.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Inform: a key date is set three months after the last written update to the client, with a reminder before it, following the Guidance Notes' minimum.
  • Recording a decision or outcome on the matter sets a key date three working days ahead for telling the client in writing.
  • Only letters and emails count as written updates, not messaging apps (G1).
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes)

Update clients in writing at least every three months; tell them the outcome in writing within three working days; use letter or email, not messaging apps; explain material changes promptly. These are expected unless the organization can justify a departure.

Courts and tribunals

D1 ([2026] UKFTT 1305 (GRC), FT/IMS/2025/0015)

Records should show substantive updates, not just contact (D1).

What we are asking you
  1. Is three months the right default, or should the interval be shorter for some case types, such as detention?
  2. Should an email logged in a matter note count as a written update, or only items on the correspondence register?
  3. When the organization departs from the three-month expectation, should the reason be recorded on the matter?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 5.5.

Respond on Code 5.5
Your view of Code 5.5

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 5.6

Code 5.6: have cover in place so that a client's case can keep moving if you are temporarily unable to work.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations
Kinds of duty (provisional)
supervise
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Parallel (self-certified)

Legal Workflows does not monitor this duty. The organization certifies, with evidence it chooses, that it monitors the duty outside the platform, and certifies again at an interval it sets.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • An admin or the IAA primary contact certifying, with evidence it chooses, the organization's cover arrangements (a certification this would add)
  • Seeing a member's open matters and tasks on the member access tab, to plan cover
  • Certifying again at the interval the organization sets, or when the evidence it cited is replaced
Why we apply it this way

Cover is an arrangement made in advance, and the practice note treats it as part of running the organization (G10). No matter event shows whether cover exists. So the organization certifies its arrangements, and Legal Workflows helps when cover is needed by showing an adviser's open work. The cover must be at the right level, which Code 3.3 checks when matters are reassigned (D7).

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Covered by the organization's certification of its cover arrangements, including who takes over urgent cases and how clients are told.
  • The member access tab already shows each member's open matters and tasks, which helps an admin arrange cover.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G10 (Cover in the absence of an adviser), G1 (Guidance Notes)

The cover note deals with planned and unplanned absence and closing a practice, and treats failed supervision cover as a significant change.

Arrange cover quickly, refer urgent cases, tell the client in writing, and tell the IAA if an adviser will be away for more than a month.

Courts and tribunals

D7 (FT/IMS/2025/0005)

When an adviser stops work suddenly, clients need a suitably registered adviser at the right level to take over (D7).

What we are asking you
  1. Should an adviser's absence of more than a month prompt a reminder to tell the IAA?
  2. Would a planned absence record that moves key dates to the covering adviser be useful?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 5.6.

Respond on Code 5.6
Your view of Code 5.6

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 5.7

Code 5.7: hand back all of a client's case documents promptly when asked.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations and advisersWhen the client asks
Kinds of duty (provisional)
record
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Recording a client's request for the return of their documents (a new record this would add)
  • Recording what was returned, to whom and when, on the correspondence register
  • A request still not met after the number of days the organization sets, which alerts the matter's adviser
Why we apply it this way

The Code asks for documents back without delay when the client asks, and the Guidance Notes add keeping a copy (G1). Delay is measured from the request (D1). So Legal Workflows would record the request, time it, and close the item only when the return is recorded, keeping the copy the organization needs for six years.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Record: a client's request for their documents is recorded with its date, and the item closes when what was returned, and when, is recorded.
  • A copy is kept on the matter for the retention period (Code 5.10).
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes)

When the retainer ends, return the documents and file to the client or whoever they nominate, keeping a copy for Code 5.10.

Courts and tribunals

D1 ([2026] UKFTT 1305 (GRC), FT/IMS/2025/0015)

Timing runs from the client's signed request, and actual prejudice affects how serious a delay is (D1 at [133] to [138]).

What we are asking you
  1. What number of days would you treat as without delay for returning documents?
  2. Should a request to return documents be recorded separately from a request to transfer the file (Code 5.9)?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 5.7.

Respond on Code 5.7
Your view of Code 5.7

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 5.8

Code 5.8: send the client a written closure statement when the case ends, when they withdraw instructions or when you stop acting.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations and advisers
Kinds of duty (provisional)
inform, account
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Closing a matter, where the close checklist asks for the closure letter (a checklist item this would add)
  • Issuing the closure letter with the outcome, leave dates and originals returned, recorded on the correspondence register
  • Recording the client's withdrawal of instructions, or the organization's withdrawal, as the close reason
Why we apply it this way

The 2024 Code needs a closure letter whenever the case ends, including withdrawal by either side, which the 2016 code was read not to cover (D1). The Guidance Notes list what it should say (G1). Legal Workflows already closes matters with a reason and a checklist, so the closure letter would become a checklist item, and the item stays open until it is recorded.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Inform: closing a matter asks for the closure letter, recorded on the correspondence register, whether the case ended, the client withdrew or the organization stopped acting.
  • Account: where money was handled, the letter includes a final financial statement (Codes 9.5 to 9.7).
  • Events before September 1, 2024 fall under the 2016 code; Legal Workflows picks the edition by the date of the event.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G13 (Model documents)

Include the outcome and what it means, such as leave dates or conditions, the originals returned, and a final financial statement where relevant.

Courts and tribunals

D1 ([2026] UKFTT 1305 (GRC), FT/IMS/2025/0015)

Under the 2016 code, the closure letter rule was read not to apply where the client moved firms (D1 at [195]). The 2024 wording covers withdrawal expressly, so that reading should not be carried over.

What we are asking you
  1. Should the closure letter block a close, or be a reminder that a manager can waive with a reason?
  2. Should the closure letter template draw the outcome and leave dates from the matter's recorded outcome?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 5.8.

Respond on Code 5.8
Your view of Code 5.8

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 5.9

Code 5.9: when the client asks, transfer their file and documents quickly and without harming their position, even if fees are unpaid.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations and advisersWhen the client asks
Kinds of duty (provisional)
record
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Recording a client's request to transfer their file, with a key date three working days ahead (a new record this would add)
  • Recording the transfer: what went, to whom and when, keeping a copy on the matter
  • Recording unpaid fees on a matter with a transfer request, which never holds the transfer back
Why we apply it this way

Unlike a solicitor, an IAA adviser may not hold a file for unpaid fees, and the Guidance Notes expect transfer within three working days, sooner in detention or removal cases (G1). The tribunal measures delay from the signed authority and weighs prejudice (D1). So Legal Workflows would time each request from the date it arrives, and nothing about money can close the item.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Record: a client's request to transfer their file opens an item with a key date three working days ahead, the Guidance Notes' normal limit.
  • Unpaid fees are never a reason to hold the file back: it goes regardless, and the debt is pursued separately.
  • Detention and removal cases are marked urgent. Events before September 1, 2024 fall under the 2016 code.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes)

Transfer normally within three working days of notice; do not hold documents for unpaid fees; urgency is greatest in detention or removal cases.

Courts and tribunals

D1 ([2026] UKFTT 1305 (GRC), FT/IMS/2025/0015), D7 (FT/IMS/2025/0005)

Timing runs from the signed authority, and the seriousness of a delay turns on actual prejudice to the client (D1 at [133] to [138]). When an adviser stops work, file transfers become critical (D7).

What we are asking you
  1. Should detention and removal cases have a shorter key date than three working days?
  2. Is it right that unpaid fees can never be recorded as a reason for delay?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 5.9.

Respond on Code 5.9
Your view of Code 5.9

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 5.10

Code 5.10: keep every client file and record for a minimum of six years, then destroy it securely.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations
Kinds of duty (provisional)
record
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Closing a matter, which sets its retention date six years after closure (a rule this would add)
  • Recording a reason to keep a matter longer than six years, with a review date
  • Destroying a matter after its retention date, which removes its documents and keeps a record of the destruction
Why we apply it this way

The Code sets six years as a minimum, and the Guidance Notes ask for a reasoned note to keep files longer and a destruction schedule (G1). Data protection law means files should not be kept without purpose (L26). So Legal Workflows would date retention from closure, ask for a reason for anything longer, and use its existing destroy action, which a legal hold already stops.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Record: closing a matter would set its retention date six years after closure, and keeping it longer would need a recorded reason (a rule this would add).
  • Destroying a matter already removes its documents and keeps a record that it happened, and a legal hold already stops it.
  • A copy kept after a file transfer is held for the same period.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G18 (Data protection), G15 (Signposting and referrals)

Keep files even after transfer, by keeping a copy. Keeping them longer needs a reasoned note. Keep retention and destruction schedules and follow data protection law.

Legislation

L26 (UK GDPR arts 5, 6, 32)

Storage limitation (UK GDPR art 5(1)(e)) means a minimum period still needs a destruction schedule, and security (art 32) applies to how files are destroyed.

What we are asking you
  1. Should the six years run from the matter's close date or from the last activity on it?
  2. Should Legal Workflows destroy files when the date passes, or only list them for a person to approve?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 5.10.

Respond on Code 5.10
Your view of Code 5.10

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Principle 6: Professional conduct and public trust

Principle 6 and Codes 6.1 to 6.8 cover the organization's public face and conduct that keeps trust in the IAA scheme: the registration number, the logo, promotion, the organization's name and legal status. Legal Workflows does not monitor these duties; the organization certifies them.

Principle 6

Principle 6: hold yourself to a high professional and personal standard, protect public confidence in the IAA scheme and do not discredit it.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations and advisers
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Parallel (self-certified)

Legal Workflows does not monitor this duty. The organization certifies, with evidence it chooses, that it monitors the duty outside the platform, and certifies again at an interval it sets.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • An admin or the IAA primary contact certifying, with evidence it chooses, its conduct and social media policies (a certification this would add)
  • Certifying again at the interval the organization sets, or when the evidence it cited is replaced
  • Never raised by an event on a matter, except beside Principle 5 where a client's instructions conflict
Why we apply it this way

Principle 6 reaches personal conduct and the organization's public face, which have no matter to hang on and would be intrusive to monitor (G1). Where it does meet a matter, it is in a conflict with the client's instructions, and the Guidance Notes say Principle 6 wins. So the organization certifies its policies, and Legal Workflows lists Principle 6 beside Principle 5 without deciding between them.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Covered by the organization's certification of its policies on professional and personal conduct, public statements and social media.
  • Where a client's instructions would mean misleading the Home Office or a tribunal, Principle 6 can override them, so such an item lists Principles 5 and 6 together.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G14 (Promotional material)

Principle 6 can override a client's wishes: an adviser cannot keep acting when told to hide a separation from the Home Office and the tribunal.

Legislation

L29 (DMCC 2024)

Consumer law sits beside Principle 6: showing a trust mark without authority, or claiming approval by a public body while not meeting its terms, is a banned practice (DMCC 2024 Sch 20 paras 3 to 4).

Courts and tribunals

D15 (IMS/2020/0009)

Dishonesty towards another regulator goes to fitness under the IAA scheme (D15).

What we are asking you
  1. Is a certified conduct and social media policy the right evidence for Principle 6?
  2. Should a recorded withdrawal because of the client's instructions list Principle 6 as a candidate?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Principle 6.

Respond on Principle 6
Your view of Principle 6

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 6.1

Code 6.1: show your IAA registration number where it is appropriate to do so.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
OrganisationsWhere appropriate
Kinds of duty (provisional)
identify
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Parallel (self-certified)

Legal Workflows does not monitor this duty. The organization certifies, with evidence it chooses, that it monitors the duty outside the platform, and certifies again at an interval it sets.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • An admin or the IAA primary contact certifying, with evidence it chooses, where its registration number is shown (a certification this would add)
  • Publishing a letterhead whose regulatory line carries the registration number
  • Recording the registration number on the organization so letter templates can include it (a field this would add)
Why we apply it this way

Showing the registration number is mostly about the website and email signatures, which Legal Workflows does not control (G1). Its own letters are the exception, and letterheads already carry a regulatory line. So the organization certifies the duty, and a registration number field would let letters show it consistently. Legal Workflows never reproduces the IAA logo (Code 6.2).

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Covered by the organization's certification that its letterhead, website and email show its IAA registration number.
  • Letterheads in Legal Workflows already carry the regulatory line an organization types into them; a registration number field would let templates include it consistently (a field this would add).
  • The provisional type (identify) describes the duty; because the organization certifies it, no product event opens an item.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G14 (Promotional material)

Show the number on letterhead, website and email, with the digital badge on the website.

Legislation

L29 (DMCC 2024)

Claiming approval by a public body while not complying with its terms is a banned practice (DMCC 2024 Sch 20 para 4).

What we are asking you
  1. Should Legal Workflows warn when a letterhead is published without a registration number?
  2. Should the registration number appear on any email Legal Workflows sends for the organization?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 6.1.

Respond on Code 6.1
Your view of Code 6.1

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 6.2

Code 6.2: use the IAA logo only as your approval letter from the Commissioner allows.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Parallel (self-certified)

Legal Workflows does not monitor this duty. The organization certifies, with evidence it chooses, that it monitors the duty outside the platform, and certifies again at an interval it sets.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • An admin or the IAA primary contact certifying, with evidence it chooses, its use of the IAA logo (a certification this would add)
  • Certifying again when registration is renewed, or when the evidence it cited is replaced
Why we apply it this way

The logo's use is set by each organization's approval letter, and the artwork belongs to the regulator (G1). Legal Workflows cannot judge a website or leaflet, and should not hold the logo itself. So the organization certifies its use, and the product leaves the logo to the organization's own letterhead.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Covered by the organization's certification that it uses the IAA logo only as its approval letter allows.
  • Legal Workflows never supplies or reproduces the IAA logo or digital badge; an organization that puts the logo on its letterhead does so under its own approval.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G14 (Promotional material)

Use the logo only while registered, unaltered, at the minimum size, in its original colors or black and white, and keep unregulated services such as emigration or training clearly separate.

Legislation

L29 (DMCC 2024)

Displaying a trust mark without authority is a banned practice (DMCC 2024 Sch 20 para 3).

What we are asking you
  1. Should the certification ask expressly about unregulated services, such as emigration or training, shown alongside the logo?
  2. Is renewal of registration the right moment to certify again?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 6.2.

Respond on Code 6.2
Your view of Code 6.2

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 6.3

Code 6.3: do not tout for immigration advice or services work.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations and advisers
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Parallel (self-certified)

Legal Workflows does not monitor this duty. The organization certifies, with evidence it chooses, that it monitors the duty outside the platform, and certifies again at an interval it sets.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • An admin or the IAA primary contact certifying, with evidence it chooses, its marketing and client-contact policy (a certification this would add)
  • Certifying again at the interval the organization sets, or when the evidence it cited is replaced
Why we apply it this way

Touting happens in marketing and in person, outside any matter (G1, G14), and the Code's own introduction treats touting through a third party as missing the Principle's spirit. Legal Workflows does not see how an organization finds clients. So the organization certifies its policy, including approaches others make for it.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Covered by the organization's certification of its marketing and client-contact policy, including approaches made by third parties on its behalf.
  • Contacting current or former clients is permitted, so messages Legal Workflows sends to clients do not engage this Code.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G14 (Promotional material)

Touting means unsolicited approaches, in person, by phone, online or through someone else; cold calling and approaching people at detention centers are examples. Contacting current or former clients is permitted.

Legislation

L29 (DMCC 2024), L12 (IAA 1999 s92B), L21 (BSAIA 2025 s17)

Promotion is also tested against consumer law on misleading actions (DMCC 2024 s226). Advertising advice it would be an offense to give is itself an offense (s92B), and so is promoting an unlawful immigration service online (BSAIA 2025 s17).

What we are asking you
  1. Should the certification ask expressly about approaches made by third parties on the organization's behalf?
  2. Should a referral source recorded at matter opening (Code 2.5) be visible to whoever certifies this duty?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 6.3.

Respond on Code 6.3
Your view of Code 6.3

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 6.4

Code 6.4: do not criticise other organizations or advisers in promotional material.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations and advisers
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Parallel (self-certified)

Legal Workflows does not monitor this duty. The organization certifies, with evidence it chooses, that it monitors the duty outside the platform, and certifies again at an interval it sets.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • An admin or the IAA primary contact certifying, with evidence it chooses, its review of promotional material (a certification this would add)
  • Recording a concern about another adviser met on a matter, handled under Code 2.4 rather than in promotion
Why we apply it this way

Promotional material is made and published outside Legal Workflows, so the product cannot see it (G14). The right route for a genuine concern about a competitor is a report to the IAA, which Code 2.4 covers on a matter (G1). So the organization certifies its review of promotional material, and the product records concerns only where they arise on a matter.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Covered by the organization's certification that its promotional material does not criticise other organizations or advisers.
  • Concerns about another adviser go to the IAA instead (Code 2.4).
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G14 (Promotional material)

Report concerns about other advisers to the IAA rather than criticising them in promotion.

Legislation

L29 (DMCC 2024)

Promotional statements are also tested against consumer law on misleading actions (DMCC 2024 s226).

What we are asking you
  1. Is certification enough for Code 6.4, or should promotional material be stored and reviewed in Legal Workflows?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 6.4.

Respond on Code 6.4
Your view of Code 6.4

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 6.5

Code 6.5: do not promote your services with claims about your success rates, in public, orally or in writing.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations and advisers
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Parallel (self-certified)

Legal Workflows does not monitor this duty. The organization certifies, with evidence it chooses, that it monitors the duty outside the platform, and certifies again at an interval it sets.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • An admin or the IAA primary contact certifying, with evidence it chooses, its review of promotional statements (a certification this would add)
  • Reporting matter outcomes to a funder, which is permitted and does not engage this Code
Why we apply it this way

Success-rate claims are banned in public, orally or in writing, but honest answers to a client who asks and figures for funders are permitted (G14). Legal Workflows records outcomes for those permitted uses and cannot see what an organization says publicly. So the organization certifies the duty, and nothing in the product publishes outcome figures.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Covered by the organization's certification that it makes no public claims about its success rates.
  • Outcomes recorded on matters are for internal use and funder reports; an honest answer to a client who asks is permitted.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G14 (Promotional material), G1 (Guidance Notes)

Honest answers to a client who asks, and figures given to funders, are permitted.

Legislation

L29 (DMCC 2024)

A success-rate claim is also tested against consumer law on misleading actions (DMCC 2024 s226).

What we are asking you
  1. Should exports of outcome figures carry a reminder that they must not be used in promotion?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 6.5.

Respond on Code 6.5
Your view of Code 6.5

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 6.6

Code 6.6: do not use an organization name that could confuse or mislead clients; the Commissioner can require you to change it.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Parallel (self-certified)

Legal Workflows does not monitor this duty. The organization certifies, with evidence it chooses, that it monitors the duty outside the platform, and certifies again at an interval it sets.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • An admin or the IAA primary contact certifying, with evidence it chooses, that the organization's name was checked (a certification this would add)
  • Certifying again whenever the name changes (Code 6.7)
Why we apply it this way

Whether a name could mislead is a judgment about how clients read it, such as a suggestion of government links (G1). The IAA can require a change, and the decision is for the organization and the IAA. So the organization certifies the duty, and certifies again whenever its name changes.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Covered by the organization's certification that its name could not confuse or mislead clients.
  • The organization's name in Legal Workflows is configuration, and the product does not judge it.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G14 (Promotional material), G3 (IAA registration explained)

Avoid names that suggest a link with government, including some uses of UK, or that echo the acronyms of established bodies.

What we are asking you
  1. Is certification once, and again on a change of name, enough for Code 6.6?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 6.6.

Respond on Code 6.6
Your view of Code 6.6

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 6.7

Code 6.7: get the Commissioner's authorization before changing the organization's name or legal status.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations
Kinds of duty (provisional)
report
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Parallel (self-certified)

Legal Workflows does not monitor this duty. The organization certifies, with evidence it chooses, that it monitors the duty outside the platform, and certifies again at an interval it sets.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • An admin or the IAA primary contact certifying, with evidence it chooses, its process for changes of name and legal status (a certification this would add)
  • Changing the organization's name in Legal Workflows, which reminds an admin to get the IAA's authorization first (a prompt this would add)
Why we apply it this way

Authorization must come before the change, and a new legal entity is a new registration that must meet current requirements (G1, D8). Legal Workflows sees a name change only when an admin edits it, which may be after the event. So the organization certifies its process, and an edit to the name prompts a reminder.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Covered by the organization's certification that it gets the IAA's authorization before changing its name or legal status.
  • Changing the organization's name in Legal Workflows would remind an admin of the duty; it does not record the authorization.
  • The provisional type (report) describes the duty; because the organization certifies it, no product event opens an item.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G3 (IAA registration explained)

A change of legal status needs an application to register the new entity, or the new entity may be unregulated.

Legislation

L5 (IAA 1999 Sch 6)

Registration attaches to the entity, so a new entity needs its own (Sch 6 para 2).

Courts and tribunals

D8 ([2026] UKFTT 335 (GRC), FT/IMS/2025/0014), D9 ([2026] UKFTT 726 (GRC), FT/IMS/2026/0001)

A new company is a fresh application and must meet the requirements in force at the time, including evidence the IAA sets (D8 at [18]; D9).

What we are asking you
  1. Should an edit to the organization's name ask for the IAA's authorization letter before it takes effect?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 6.7.

Respond on Code 6.7
Your view of Code 6.7

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 6.8

Code 6.8: behave in a way that keeps public confidence in the IAA scheme and in the advice and services that authorized people provide.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations and advisers
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Parallel (self-certified)

Legal Workflows does not monitor this duty. The organization certifies, with evidence it chooses, that it monitors the duty outside the platform, and certifies again at an interval it sets.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • An admin or the IAA primary contact certifying, with evidence it chooses, its conduct policy and rules for unregulated services (a certification this would add)
  • Certifying again at the interval the organization sets, or when the evidence it cited is replaced
Why we apply it this way

Public confidence in the scheme can be affected by conduct away from casework, including unregulated services such as emigration advice (G1). That conduct is outside matters and outside what Legal Workflows should watch. So the organization certifies its policy, and the product records nothing about individuals' conduct.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Covered by the organization's certification of its conduct policy, including any unregulated services it offers, such as emigration advice or training.
  • A legitimate challenge to the IAA does not engage this Code.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes)

The Code reaches personal conduct and unregulated services, through the organization's link with the scheme. A legitimate challenge to the regulator does not engage it.

Legislation

L2 (IAA 1999 s83)

Public confidence in the scheme rests on the statutory aims in s83(5).

Courts and tribunals

C7 (Kingsley)

The regulator's published statements about advisers are made in its statutory role (Kingsley).

What we are asking you
  1. Should the certification ask separately about unregulated services the organization offers?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 6.8.

Respond on Code 6.8
Your view of Code 6.8

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Principle 7: Fairness

Principle 7 and Codes 7.1 to 7.3 bind organizations and advisers. They cover fair and dignified treatment, an equal chance of a good outcome for every client, and respect for clients, the IAA, the Home Office, courts and tribunals.

Principle 7

Principle 7: be fair to everyone and free of prejudice.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations and advisers
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Parallel (self-certified)

Legal Workflows does not monitor this duty. The organization certifies, with evidence it chooses, that it monitors the duty outside the platform, and certifies again at an interval it sets.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • An admin or the IAA primary contact certifying, with evidence it chooses, its equality and fair-treatment policy (a certification this would add)
  • Certifying again at the interval the organization sets, or when the evidence it cited is replaced
Why we apply it this way

Fairness is a standard for every dealing, and its evidence is a policy applied and reviewed, as the Guidance Notes expect under Code 7.2 (G1). Monitoring how staff treat people would be intrusive. So the organization certifies its policy, and Legal Workflows supports it by recording each client's language and access needs (L27).

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Covered by the organization's certification of its equality and fair-treatment policy.
  • Legal Workflows records clients' interpreter language and accessibility needs where the organization chooses, which supports Codes 7.1 and 7.2.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G16 (Vulnerable clients)

The Guidance Notes give their guidance under the Codes rather than the Principle. The vulnerable clients note explains how to identify vulnerability and adapt the service.

Legislation

L27 (Equality Act 2010 ss20, 29)

Service providers must not discriminate against, harass or victimise clients (s29), and must make reasonable adjustments (s20).

What we are asking you
  1. Is a certified equality policy the right evidence for Principle 7?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Principle 7.

Respond on Principle 7
Your view of Principle 7

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 7.1

Code 7.1: treat each person fairly and with dignity, and without prejudice.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations and advisers
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Parallel (self-certified)

Legal Workflows does not monitor this duty. The organization certifies, with evidence it chooses, that it monitors the duty outside the platform, and certifies again at an interval it sets.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • An admin or the IAA primary contact certifying, with evidence it chooses, its fair-treatment policy (a certification this would add)
  • Recording a client's preferred contact method, interpreter language and accessibility needs on the client register
Why we apply it this way

Fair and dignified treatment happens in conversations and correspondence that Legal Workflows cannot judge (G1). It can hold what helps staff get it right: how the client prefers to be contacted, and in what language. So the organization certifies its policy, and the client register keeps those preferences (G16).

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Covered by the organization's certification of its fair-treatment policy, including how staff respond to a client who complains.
  • A client's preferred contact method and interpreter language are already recorded on the client register.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G16 (Vulnerable clients)

Do not exploit vulnerability, and never threaten to report a complaining client to the Home Office; communicate with respect and in the way the person prefers.

Legislation

L27 (Equality Act 2010 ss20, 29)

Harassment and discrimination in providing a service are unlawful (s29).

What we are asking you
  1. Should a complaint recorded under Code 3.5 prompt the matter's adviser to confirm nothing was said about reporting the client to the Home Office?
  2. Are there other preferences you would want the client register to hold?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 7.1.

Respond on Code 7.1
Your view of Code 7.1

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 7.2

Code 7.2: give every client the same chance of a good outcome, whatever their vulnerability or exposure to discrimination.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations and advisers
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Parallel (self-certified)

Legal Workflows does not monitor this duty. The organization certifies, with evidence it chooses, that it monitors the duty outside the platform, and certifies again at an interval it sets.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • An admin or the IAA primary contact certifying, with evidence it chooses, its equality and diversity policy (a certification this would add)
  • Recording a client's accessibility needs on the client register, so adjustments can be made
  • Running the equality monitoring report, which holders of the manager role already can
Why we apply it this way

Equal opportunity is shown by a written policy applied in practice, and the Guidance Notes treat its absence as making a finding worse (G1). There is no fixed definition of vulnerability (D2), so Legal Workflows does not label clients as vulnerable. The organization certifies its policy, and the client register and equality monitoring report give it evidence to draw on.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Covered by the organization's certification of its written equality and diversity policy, and of any public statement limiting its services to particular groups.
  • The vulnerable clients practice note still cites an older number for this duty; the page uses the 2024 number.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G16 (Vulnerable clients), G23 (Judicial review case management)

The Guidance Notes cite the Equality Act's protected characteristics. Organizations should have a written equality and diversity policy, and its absence makes matters worse; if services are limited to particular groups, say so publicly.

Legislation

L27 (Equality Act 2010 ss20, 29)

Reasonable adjustments (s20) and the duty not to discriminate in services (s29) sit beside this Code.

Courts and tribunals

D2 ([2025] UKFTT 290 (GRC))

There is no Code definition of vulnerability, and the tribunal did not borrow other tribunals' definitions (D2 at [51]).

What we are asking you
  1. Should Legal Workflows let an organization mark a client as needing adjustments, without labelling them vulnerable?
  2. Would the equality monitoring report be useful evidence for this certification?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 7.2.

Respond on Code 7.2
Your view of Code 7.2

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 7.3

Code 7.3: treat clients, the Commissioner, the Home Office, courts, tribunals and other agencies and organizations with proper respect.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations and advisers
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Linked

For reference. The paragraph has its own entry, with our summary, a link to the IAA's code and its authorities, but nothing on a matter raises it.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • No activity raises Code 7.3
  • Issuing a fee reminder from a template the organization has approved
Why we apply it this way

Respect is about how people write and speak, including to the Home Office and tribunals, and the Guidance Notes' example is a reply to tribunal directions (G1). Judging tone is not something Legal Workflows should do. So Code 7.3 is a reference page, and approved templates for sensitive letters, such as fee reminders, are the organization's own control.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • No event raises Code 7.3. Courtesy in correspondence is a judgment about tone, which Legal Workflows does not make.
  • Letters chasing unpaid fees go out from templates the organization controls.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes)

Be courteous, with no aggression or threats, including over unpaid fees. The case study is an aggressive reply to Upper Tribunal directions.

What we are asking you
  1. Should Code 7.3 be certified by the organization with Principle 7, rather than kept as a reference page?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 7.3.

Respond on Code 7.3
Your view of Code 7.3

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Principle 8: Business affairs and records

Principle 8 binds the organization, as do most of Codes 8.1 to 8.7; attendance notes (8.5) and original documents (8.7) bind advisers too. They cover governance, indemnity insurance, financial records, files, attendance notes and the security of client records.

Principle 8

Principle 8: run the business and keep client records effectively.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Linked

For reference. The paragraph has its own entry, with our summary, a link to the IAA's code and its authorities, but nothing on a matter raises it.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • No activity raises Principle 8 on its own
  • Listed beside a Code under Principle 8 when an item cites it
Why we apply it this way

Principle 8 is about running the business, and its Codes split between duties the organization certifies (governance, insurance, accounts) and records Legal Workflows already keeps (files, notes, security). So the Principle is shown above its Codes, and audits are where the IAA tests both (G21).

How it works in Signal & Line
  • No event raises Principle 8 on its own. It is listed beside Codes 8.4 to 8.7 when an item cites them.
  • How staff use AI tools is a governance point under Code 8.1 (UK and Munir).
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G21 (Premises audit)

The premises audit note explains remote and premises audits and what the IAA looks at.

Legislation

L16 (IAA 1999 Sch 5)

The IAA's rules may require indemnity insurance and the keeping of accounts, and records must be produced on inspection (Sch 5 paras 1(4) and 10A).

Courts and tribunals

C5 (Kaikai), UT1 (UK and Munir)

A poorly run practice does not protect its clients, and missing indemnity details were treated as a threshold matter (Kaikai at [3] to [4]). Supervising staff use of AI tools is part of running the practice (UK and Munir).

What we are asking you
  1. Would a summary of the records the IAA asks for at audit, drawn from Legal Workflows, be useful before an audit?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Principle 8.

Respond on Principle 8
Your view of Principle 8

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 8.1

Code 8.1: have effective governance, processes and policies that keep the business viable and sustainable.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations
Kinds of duty (provisional)
supervise, review
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Parallel (self-certified)

Legal Workflows does not monitor this duty. The organization certifies, with evidence it chooses, that it monitors the duty outside the platform, and certifies again at an interval it sets.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • An admin or the IAA primary contact certifying, with evidence it chooses, its governance, policies and recruitment checks (a certification this would add)
  • Recording which member is the IAA primary contact (a role this would add)
  • Certifying again at the interval the organization sets, or when the evidence it cited is replaced
Why we apply it this way

Governance is shown by policies and decisions held for inspection, not by events on a matter (G1, G21). The Upper Tribunal has added staff use of AI tools to what a supervisor must manage (UT1). So the organization certifies its arrangements with evidence it chooses, and Legal Workflows would record who the primary contact is.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Covered by the organization's certification of its governance, policies and recruitment checks, including a named primary contact.
  • A policy on staff use of AI tools is part of governance (UK and Munir), and the organization may cite it as evidence.
  • The provisional types (supervise, review) describe the duty; because the organization certifies it, no product event opens an item.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G21 (Premises audit), G3 (IAA registration explained), G14 (Promotional material)

Evidence must be available for inspection. Recruit with fit and proper checks; name a primary contact; tell the IAA of business addresses within 10 working days; advertise services, levels and categories accurately; online services should state their scope, timeframes, costs and cooling-off rights.

Legislation

L28 (CCR 2013)

Services sold online or at a distance carry consumer information duties and cooling-off rights.

Courts and tribunals

UT1 (UK and Munir)

A supervisor should warn staff about general-purpose AI tools, which makes AI use a governance question (UK and Munir).

What we are asking you
  1. Should the primary contact be a compliance role in Legal Workflows, like the existing manager and supervisor roles?
  2. Should the certification ask expressly for a policy on AI tools, given UK and Munir?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 8.1.

Respond on Code 8.1
Your view of Code 8.1

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 8.2

Code 8.2: hold current, adequate professional indemnity insurance.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Parallel (self-certified)

Legal Workflows does not monitor this duty. The organization certifies, with evidence it chooses, that it monitors the duty outside the platform, and certifies again at an interval it sets.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • An admin or the IAA primary contact certifying, with evidence it chooses, its insurance, with the policy schedule (a certification this would add)
  • Certifying again when the policy renews, with a reminder before the renewal date
Why we apply it this way

Insurance is held by the organization, not by matter, and the evidence is the policy schedule (G1). The IAA expects a minimum level of cover, and the courts have treated insurance as a threshold for practice (C5). So the organization certifies it, and the next certification follows the policy's renewal date.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Covered by the organization's certification that it holds current, adequate professional indemnity insurance, with the policy schedule as evidence.
  • Certification would fall due again when the policy renews, with a reminder before the renewal date.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G4 (Regulations summary), G3 (IAA registration explained)

The Guidance Notes set a minimum level of cover the IAA expects. The regulations summary recommends a paragraph on indemnity insurance in client care letters.

Legislation

L16 (IAA 1999 Sch 5)

The IAA's rules may require indemnity insurance (Sch 5 para 1(4)).

Courts and tribunals

C5 (Kaikai), C4 (Clarke)

Insurance has been treated as a threshold matter (Kaikai), and its absence noted as a harm to clients (Clarke at [49]).

What we are asking you
  1. Should certification for insurance follow the policy's renewal date rather than an interval the organization sets?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 8.2.

Respond on Code 8.2
Your view of Code 8.2

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 8.3

Code 8.3: keep financial records that are complete, clear and accurate.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations
Kinds of duty (provisional)
account, record
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Parallel (self-certified)

Legal Workflows does not monitor this duty. The organization certifies, with evidence it chooses, that it monitors the duty outside the platform, and certifies again at an interval it sets.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • An admin or the IAA primary contact certifying, with evidence it chooses, its financial records, with its annual accounts (a certification this would add)
  • Recording time, expenses and invoices on matters, where billing is on
Why we apply it this way

Financial records span the whole business, most of it outside any matter, and the evidence the IAA asks for is the annual accounts (G1). Legal Workflows holds part of the picture where billing is on. So the organization certifies the duty, and the product does not claim to be its full set of accounts.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Covered by the organization's certification that it keeps complete and accurate financial records, with its annual accounts as evidence.
  • Where billing is on, time, expenses and invoices in Legal Workflows form part of those records, but not the whole of them.
  • The provisional types (account, record) describe the duty; because the organization certifies it, no product event opens an item.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G11 (Fees and accounts)

Keep annual audited, certified or verified accounts, and give the IAA access on request.

Legislation

L16 (IAA 1999 Sch 5)

The IAA's rules may cover the keeping of accounts (Sch 5 para 1(4)).

What we are asking you
  1. Should Legal Workflows offer an export of matter billing records for the organization's accountant?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 8.3.

Respond on Code 8.3
Your view of Code 8.3

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 8.4

Code 8.4: run and maintain a file management system that works.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations
Kinds of duty (provisional)
record
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Integrated (already live)

Legal Workflows already acts on this duty today. It will add the paragraph's own page, and cite the paragraph on what the product already does.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Opening a matter for a client from the client register, with its case type and open date
  • Closing a matter with a close date and a recorded outcome
  • Exporting the client list with the fields the IAA asks for at audit (an export this would add)
Why we apply it this way

The IAA checks the client list against Home Office data at audit, so its fields matter (G1, G3). Legal Workflows already keeps matters, clients, case types, dates and outcomes, which is most of the list. So it already acts on this duty, and would add the missing fields and an export in the shape the IAA asks for (D2).

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Already live: matters and the client register are the file management system and client list, with case types, open and close dates and recorded outcomes.
  • The IAA's client list also needs full date of birth, Home Office reference and application type, which the register does not yet hold (fields this would add).
  • Records need not be fully translated, but the gist should be in English (D2).
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G3 (IAA registration explained), G21 (Premises audit), G23 (Judicial review case management)

Keep a full client list with name, date of birth, Home Office reference, application type, opened and closed dates and outcome, and keep files orderly and complete with correspondence and evidence.

The registration guide explains that the IAA checks the client list at audit.

Courts and tribunals

D2 ([2025] UKFTT 290 (GRC)), D3 ([2024] UKFTT 901 (GRC), FT/IMS/2024/0002)

Records need not be translated in full, but the gist should be recorded in English (D2 at [84]).

What we are asking you
  1. Should full date of birth and Home Office reference be held on the client or on the matter?
  2. Would an export of the client list in the IAA's audit format save you time?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 8.4.

Respond on Code 8.4
Your view of Code 8.4

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 8.5

Code 8.5: record every dealing with or for a client in an attendance note.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations and advisers
Kinds of duty (provisional)
record
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Integrated (already live)

Legal Workflows already acts on this duty today. It will add the paragraph's own page, and cite the paragraph on what the product already does.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Writing a matter note of a call, meeting, email or letter, with when it happened
  • Editing a matter note, which keeps the earlier version
  • Recording a first substantive meeting with headings for instructions, advice and merits (a note template this would add)
Why we apply it this way

Attendance notes are what the IAA reads at audit and in complaints, and the Guidance Notes list what each should hold (G1). Matter notes already record every contact, show when a note was written after the event, and keep earlier versions. So Legal Workflows already acts on this duty, and would add a template for the first substantive meeting (D2).

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Already live: matter notes record each contact with its kind (phone, in person, email, letter, video), when it happened and who wrote it, and an edit keeps earlier versions.
  • A first substantive meeting needs a full note, and instant messages that matter are recorded too.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G15 (Signposting and referrals), G23 (Judicial review case management)

Record instructions, advice and merits, action taken and by whom; phone calls, emails and relevant instant messages; and a full note of the first substantive meeting. Outgoing letters show the adviser's name, address, organization and job title.

Courts and tribunals

D2 ([2025] UKFTT 290 (GRC)), D1 ([2026] UKFTT 1305 (GRC), FT/IMS/2025/0015)

The gist of a conversation in another language should be recorded in English (D2 at [84]). Poor records do not by themselves prove fabrication (D1).

What we are asking you
  1. Is a note template for the first substantive meeting useful, and what headings would you use?
  2. Should a note recording advice prompt the adviser to record the merits as well?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 8.5.

Respond on Code 8.5
Your view of Code 8.5

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 8.6

Code 8.6: keep client records secure, let the client see them at any time and produce them to the Commissioner on request.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations
Kinds of duty (provisional)
confidentiality, record
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Exporting a matter's documents with a manifest that lets each file be checked against what was held
  • Recording a client's request to see their records, and what was provided (a new record this would add)
  • Recording a request from the IAA to produce records, with a key date for the reply (a new record this would add)
Why we apply it this way

The Code joins three duties: security, client access at any time, and production to the IAA (G1). Legal Workflows already keeps records behind matter membership and barriers, which covers security (L26). What it lacks is a record of requests to see or produce records. So it would record each request with a key date, and the export already gives a checkable copy.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Confidentiality: matter membership and information barriers already keep records to those on the matter, and uploaded documents are scanned and kept with their versions.
  • Record: a request from the client to see their records, or from the IAA to produce them, would be recorded with a key date and closed by recording what was provided.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G21 (Premises audit), G18 (Data protection), G5 (Complaints scheme)

For paper, lockable storage, a fireproof safe and a shredder; for electronic records, a reliable system and a secure network.

Organizations must produce documents when the IAA investigates a complaint.

Legislation

L26 (UK GDPR arts 5, 6, 32), L16 (IAA 1999 Sch 5)

Security is a data protection duty too (UK GDPR art 32). The IAA may enter premises under warrant and require documents (Sch 5 para 10A).

What we are asking you
  1. Should a client's request to see their file follow the same timing as a data protection subject access request?
  2. Should requests from the IAA be recorded at organization level as well as on the matter?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 8.6.

Respond on Code 8.6
Your view of Code 8.6

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 8.7

Code 8.7: if you keep a client's original documents, make sure the client has copies, and return the originals as soon as they are no longer needed.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Organisations and advisersOnly where original documents are held
Kinds of duty (provisional)
record
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Recording an original document received from a client, such as a passport, with the reason it is held (a new record this would add)
  • Recording that the client has a copy
  • Recording the original's return when it has served its purpose, with a key date to prompt it
Why we apply it this way

Original documents, such as passports, are often vital to the client and needed by the Home Office, so the Code asks for a copy for the client and prompt return (G1). Legal Workflows can only know about originals if they are recorded. So it would record each one when received, and keep an item open until it goes back.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Record: receiving a client's original document would be recorded with what it is and why it is held, and the item asks for a copy to be given to the client.
  • When the original has served its purpose, a key date prompts its return, recorded on the correspondence register.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G23 (Judicial review case management)

Hold originals only where they are needed; otherwise copy them and give them back promptly.

What we are asking you
  1. Should an original's return be linked to the closure letter (Code 5.8), so nothing is missed at close?
  2. Is a register of originals on each matter useful, or do you track them elsewhere?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 8.7.

Respond on Code 8.7
Your view of Code 8.7

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Principle 9: Fees and client money

Principle 9 and Codes 9.1 to 9.7 bind only organizations that charge clients fees, and their advisers. They cover fee scales, invoices and receipts, card payments, client accounts and refunds. An organization registered as non-fee-charging may not charge at all (Code 2.7).

Principle 9

Principle 9: charge fairly and openly and handle client money properly.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Fee-charging organisations and their advisersOnly organisations that charge clients fees
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Linked

For reference. The paragraph has its own entry, with our summary, a link to the IAA's code and its authorities, but nothing on a matter raises it.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • No activity raises Principle 9 on its own
  • Listed beside a Code under Principle 9 when an item cites it, in fee-charging organizations only
Why we apply it this way

Principle 9 binds only organizations that charge fees, and its Codes set fixed rules Legal Workflows can apply to billing records (G1). So the Principle is shown above its Codes and raised only through them. The page says the 2025 Act's refund and compensation orders are not yet in force, so it does not present them as current (L19).

How it works in Signal & Line
  • No event raises Principle 9 on its own. It is listed beside Codes 9.1 to 9.7, which bind only fee-charging organizations.
  • An organization registered as non-fee-charging may not charge at all (Code 2.7).
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G11 (Fees and accounts), G12 (Invoicing customers), G29 (2025 Act factsheet)

Principle 9 applies only to fee-charging organizations.

The IAA's factsheet describes new powers in the 2025 Act; at November 10, 2026 they are not in force.

Legislation

L8 (IAA 1999 ss89 to 90), L13 (IAA 1999 ss92C to 92H, not yet in force), L19 (BSAIA 2025 Sch 1)

At present, repayment of unreasonable fees can be directed only on a disciplinary charge before the tribunal (s89(5)). Refund and compensation orders under the 2025 Act are not yet in force.

Courts and tribunals

D3 ([2024] UKFTT 901 (GRC), FT/IMS/2024/0002)

On an appeal against a registration decision the tribunal has no power to order a fee refund (D3 at [81]).

What we are asking you
  1. Is it right to show Principle 9 only in organizations recorded as fee-charging?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Principle 9.

Respond on Principle 9
Your view of Principle 9

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 9.1

Code 9.1: keep a fee scale and charge only reasonable fees tied directly to the work done.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Fee-charging organisations and their advisersOnly organisations that charge clients fees
Kinds of duty (provisional)
account, inform, record
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Recording the organization's fee scale, with its ranges (a record this would add)
  • Agreeing a fee on a matter above the scale or at a discount, which asks for the reason and the letter explaining it
  • A phase's recorded time reaching an estimate threshold, which alerts the matter admins
Why we apply it this way

The fee must be reasonable and tied to the work, and the scale is the benchmark (G1, G11). The tribunal accepts a fee above the scale if it was explained in writing at the time (D1). So Legal Workflows would record the scale, ask for the reason and the written explanation whenever a fee departs from it, and keep the existing estimate alerts.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Account: the organization's fee scale would be recorded, and a fee above it, or a discount, asks for the reason to be recorded and explained to the client in writing.
  • A range on the scale whose top is about twice its bottom asks for a recorded justification (G1).
  • Estimates against actuals already alert matter admins when recorded time reaches a threshold.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G11 (Fees and accounts), G13 (Model documents), G3 (IAA registration explained)

Share the fee scale with clients and the IAA; record discount reasons in the client care letter and notes; explain any departure in writing; justify a wide range.

The IAA publishes a model fee scale.

Legislation

L8 (IAA 1999 ss89 to 90)

Repayment of unreasonable fees can at present be directed only on a disciplinary charge (s89(5)).

Courts and tribunals

D1 ([2026] UKFTT 1305 (GRC), FT/IMS/2025/0015), D3 ([2024] UKFTT 901 (GRC), FT/IMS/2024/0002)

A fee above the published scale is not unreasonable in itself, but the uplift must be explained in writing at the time (D1 at [73]). Charging for work that could not help the client took advantage of them (D3).

What we are asking you
  1. Should the fee scale be recorded in Legal Workflows, or is a link to the published document enough?
  2. Should every discount need a reason, or only those above a set amount?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 9.1.

Respond on Code 9.1
Your view of Code 9.1

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 9.2

Code 9.2: invoice the client when payment is due and give proof of each payment taken.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Fee-charging organisations and their advisersOnly organisations that charge clients fees
Kinds of duty (provisional)
account
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Raising an invoice on a matter before payment is requested (billing this would add)
  • Recording a payment received, deposit or otherwise, which issues a receipt
  • Recording a payment received with no invoice raised, which opens an item
Why we apply it this way

Every payment needs an invoice first and proof of payment after (G1, G12), and the tribunal looks at substance rather than labels (D1). Billing in Legal Workflows is not yet live, so this item would arrive with it: an invoice before each request for payment, and a receipt for each payment.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Account: a request for payment is made by invoice, and every payment received, deposits included, produces a receipt (records this would add with billing).
  • An invoice that acknowledges payment can serve as the receipt (D1).
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G12 (Invoicing customers), G1 (Guidance Notes), G11 (Fees and accounts)

The invoicing note sets out good practice for invoices and receipts. Issue a formal invoice before payment, and a receipt for every payment, deposits included.

Legislation

L28 (CCR 2013)

For retainers made at a distance or off premises, consumer rules on payment and cooling-off apply as well.

Courts and tribunals

D1 ([2026] UKFTT 1305 (GRC), FT/IMS/2025/0015)

Substance counts over label: an invoice that acknowledges payment works as a receipt (D1 at [78]).

What we are asking you
  1. Should Legal Workflows issue receipts automatically, or should a person approve each one?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 9.2.

Respond on Code 9.2
Your view of Code 9.2

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 9.3

Code 9.3: where the client has authorized card payments in advance, take an invoiced fee only seven days after the client received the invoice.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Fee-charging organisations and their advisersOnly fee-charging organisations, where the client has authorised card payments in advance
Kinds of duty (provisional)
account, consent
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Recording a client's prior authorization for card payments (a new record this would add)
  • Recording when an invoice was provided to the client, which starts the seven-day period
  • Recording a card payment within seven days of the invoice, which opens an item
Why we apply it this way

The seven days give the client time to fund the account or dispute the invoice (G1). It is a fixed rule that runs from when the invoice was provided, so Legal Workflows can time it once billing records when an invoice reached the client. A payment taken early would open an item for a person to explain.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Consent: the client's prior authorization of card payments is recorded with the document that evidences it.
  • Account: a card payment against an invoice cannot be taken until seven days after the invoice was provided, and the item records when it was.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G12 (Invoicing customers)

The gap gives the client time to fund the account or dispute the invoice.

Legislation

L28 (CCR 2013)

Consumer rules on payment and cooling-off may also apply to retainers made at a distance or off premises.

What we are asking you
  1. Should the seven days run from the date the invoice was sent or the date it was likely received?
  2. Should Legal Workflows block an early card payment, or only record it?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 9.3.

Respond on Code 9.3
Your view of Code 9.3

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 9.4

Code 9.4: keep money taken in advance or held for a client in a separate client account, apart from the business account.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Fee-charging organisations and their advisersOnly where money is taken in advance or held for a client
Kinds of duty (provisional)
account
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Recording money received in advance or held for a client against the client account (a ledger this would add)
  • Recording a disbursement paid from money held for the client
  • Recording a fixed fee as earned on completion of the work, which moves it to the business
Why we apply it this way

Money taken before the work is done belongs to the client, so it must sit in a distinct account (G1, G11). The tribunal reads that plainly and expects the practice note to be followed, though an earned fixed fee may go to the business (D2, D1). So Legal Workflows would keep a client ledger for each matter once billing arrives.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Account: money taken in advance, payments on account and disbursements would be recorded against a distinct client account, never the business account.
  • A fixed fee already earned for completed work need not sit in the client account (D1).
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G11 (Fees and accounts), G1 (Guidance Notes), G13 (Model documents), G3 (IAA registration explained)

The fees and accounts note covers client accounts, disbursements, petty cash and fees, and options where a client account cannot be opened. Money for unfinished work does not belong to the business.

The IAA publishes a model client account procedure.

Legislation

L30 (MLR 2017 regs 8, 12), L31 (POCA 2002 ss333A, 342)

Immigration advice is not itself a regulated activity for money laundering purposes, but forming companies or providing other trust or company services for clients may be. Prejudicing an investigation is an offense for everyone (POCA s342); tipping off applies only in the regulated sector (s333A).

Courts and tribunals

D2 ([2025] UKFTT 290 (GRC)), D1 ([2026] UKFTT 1305 (GRC), FT/IMS/2025/0015)

A distinct client account has its ordinary meaning, the practice note binds in practice, and payments on account and disbursements belong in it (D2 at [93]). An earned fixed fee need not (D1 at [81], [89]).

What we are asking you
  1. Do you hold client money often enough that a client ledger in Legal Workflows would be useful?
  2. Should forming companies or other services for business-route clients prompt a money laundering scope check?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 9.4.

Respond on Code 9.4
Your view of Code 9.4

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 9.5

Code 9.5: return any balance in the client account promptly when the case ends, the client ends instructions or the organization stops acting.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Fee-charging organisations and their advisersOnly organisations that charge clients fees
Kinds of duty (provisional)
account
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Closing a matter with a balance in the client account, which opens an item (a close checklist item this would add)
  • Recording the balance returned, with any interest, and when
  • Recording a balance paid to charity because the client cannot be traced, with the steps taken
Why we apply it this way

The balance must go back promptly when the case ends, whoever ends it (G1). Closing a matter is the moment Legal Workflows can see that, and the close checklist already holds items that block a close. So a client account balance would join the checklist, and the item closes when the return is recorded.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Account: closing a matter with money in the client account would open an item until the balance, with any interest, is returned and recorded.
  • Money for a client who cannot be traced, or who has died, may go to charity but never to the business.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G11 (Fees and accounts)

Return interest too. Money for untraceable or deceased clients may go to charity, never to the business.

What we are asking you
  1. Should a client account balance block the close, or open an item that stays after it?
  2. What steps to trace a client would you expect before money goes to charity?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 9.5.

Respond on Code 9.5
Your view of Code 9.5

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 9.6

Code 9.6: pass on to the client promptly any refund received for a disbursement.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Fee-charging organisations and their advisersOnly organisations that charge clients fees
Kinds of duty (provisional)
account
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Recording a refund received for a disbursement, such as a returned Home Office fee (a new record this would add)
  • Recording the refund passed to the client, which closes the item
Why we apply it this way

The Guidance Notes set three working days for passing on a disbursement refund (G1). It is a fixed clock that starts when the refund arrives, so Legal Workflows can time it once the refund is recorded against the expense it reverses, and keep the item open until the client is paid.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Account: recording a refund received for a disbursement sets a key date three working days ahead to pass it to the client.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G11 (Fees and accounts)

Pass the refund on within three working days.

What we are asking you
  1. Is three working days workable where the refund arrives by cheque or needs to clear?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 9.6.

Respond on Code 9.6
Your view of Code 9.6

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 9.7

Code 9.7: repay a client promptly when a refund has been agreed or the client is entitled to one.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the IAA's text.

Applies to
Fee-charging organisations and their advisersOnly organisations that charge clients fees
Kinds of duty (provisional)
account, record, inform
Edition
In effect from 1 September 2024

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Recording a client's request for a refund, with a key date for the decision (a new record this would add)
  • Recording the decision and its reasons, and the letter telling the client
  • Recording the refund paid, which closes the item
Why we apply it this way

The Code requires prompt repayment once a refund is agreed or due, and the Guidance Notes ask for a record of requests, payments and reasons for saying no (G1). At present the IAA has no direct power to order refunds, as the 2025 Act's power is not in force (L16, L19). So Legal Workflows records the request, the decision and the payment.

How it works in Signal & Line
  • Record: a client's request for a refund is recorded, with the decision and its reasons.
  • Inform: a decision not to refund is explained to the client in writing, and an agreed refund is paid and recorded promptly.
  • Refund and compensation orders in the 2025 Act are not yet in force, and the page does not present them as current.
Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities at the foot of this page.

IAA guidance

G1 (Guidance Notes), G7 (Investigating client's complaints), G29 (2025 Act factsheet)

Record refund requests and payments, record the reasons for not refunding, and tell the client why.

Legislation

L8 (IAA 1999 ss89 to 90), L16 (IAA 1999 Sch 5), L19 (BSAIA 2025 Sch 1)

Repayment of unreasonable fees can be directed on a disciplinary charge (s89(5)). The power in Sch 5 para 9(1)(f) to order refunds and compensation is not yet in force.

Courts and tribunals

D3 ([2024] UKFTT 901 (GRC), FT/IMS/2024/0002)

A fee refund cannot be ordered on an appeal against a registration decision (D3 at [81]).

What we are asking you
  1. Should every refund request be recorded, even one settled at once?
  2. Should a decision not to refund need a second person to agree?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 9.7.

Respond on Code 9.7
Your view of Code 9.7

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Schedule of authorities

Every source the reviews cite, in one place. Each code in a review links to its entry here.

IAA guidance

The IAA's Guidance Notes, practice notes and other guidance. Linked as sources: the reviews summarise them in our own words.

  1. G1

    Code of Standards 2024: Guidance Notes

    Statutory guidance · July 30, 2024 · Applies to All

  2. G2

    Guidance on competence

    Statutory guidance · Seventh edition in force July 1, 2021; IAA edition October 14, 2026 · Applies to Code 3.3, Code 3.4, Principle 4, Code 4.2, Code 4.3

  3. G3

    IAA registration explained

    Guidance · First published July 14, 2026, updated October 5, 2026 · Applies to Code 2.2, Code 2.7, Code 3.1, Code 3.2, Code 3.3, Code 3.6, Code 4.4, Code 5.3, Code 6.6, Code 6.7, Code 8.1, Code 8.2, Code 8.4, Code 9.1, Code 9.4

  4. G4

    Regulations immigration advisers must follow: summary

    Guidance · Updated October 25, 2024 · Applies to Code 3.5, Code 3.6, Code 5.3, Code 5.4, Code 8.2

  5. G5

    IAA complaints scheme

    Statutory guidance · 2020 scheme; IAA edition November 2026 · Applies to Principle 3, Code 3.5, Code 8.6

  6. G6

    Complaints redirection scheme for regulated organizations

    Statutory guidance · April 1, 2016 · Applies to Code 3.5

  7. G7

    Investigating client's complaints: practice note

    Practice note · June 5, 2025 · Applies to Code 3.5, Code 9.7

  8. G8

    Continuing Professional Development Scheme (CPD Practice Note 2025)

    Guidance · May 21, 2025 · Applies to Code 3.6, Code 4.1, Code 4.3, Code 4.4

  9. G9

    Supervision of trainee immigration advisers: guidance note

    Guidance · June 6, 2025 · Applies to Code 3.3, Code 5.5

  10. G10

    Cover in the absence of an adviser: practice note

    Practice note · June 5, 2025 · Applies to Code 3.3, Code 3.6, Code 5.6

  11. G11

    Fees and accounts: practice note

    Practice note · June 6, 2025 · Applies to Code 8.3, Principle 9, Code 9.1, Code 9.2, Code 9.4, Code 9.5, Code 9.6

  12. G12

    Invoicing customers: practice note

    Practice note · May 21, 2025 · Applies to Principle 9, Code 9.2, Code 9.3

  13. G13

    IAA model documents

    Guidance · March 3, 2026 · Applies to Code 3.5, Code 5.3, Code 5.4, Code 5.8, Code 9.1, Code 9.4

  14. G14

    Promotional material: practice note

    Practice note · May 21, 2025 · Applies to Code 1.1, Code 2.6, Principle 6, Code 6.1, Code 6.2, Code 6.3, Code 6.4, Code 6.5, Code 6.6, Code 6.7, Code 8.1

  15. G15

    Signposting and referrals: practice note

    Practice note · June 5, 2025 · Applies to Code 2.5, Code 2.6, Code 2.8, Code 3.4, Code 5.1, Code 5.10, Code 8.5

  16. G16

    Meeting the needs of vulnerable clients: practice note

    Practice note · June 5, 2025 · Applies to Code 4.2, Principle 7, Code 7.1, Code 7.2

  17. G17

    Interpreters and translators: practice note

    Practice note · July 22, 2026 · Applies to Code 4.2, Code 5.2

  18. G18

    Data protection: practice note

    Practice note · February 7, 2025 · Applies to Code 4.5, Code 5.10, Code 8.6

  19. G19

    Whistleblowing policy for regulated organizations and advisers

    Guidance · February 7, 2025 · Applies to Code 2.3, Code 2.4

  20. G20

    Fitness of immigration services: assessing advisers and assessing owners

    Guidance · June 5, 2025 · Applies to Principle 2, Code 2.1, Code 3.6, Code 3.7, Code 4.1

  21. G21

    Premises audit: practice note

    Practice note · September 26, 2025 · Applies to Code 4.5, Principle 8, Code 8.1, Code 8.4, Code 8.5, Code 8.6

  22. G22

    Licensed access scheme: practice note

    Practice note · June 5, 2025 · Applies to Code 3.3, Code 3.4

  23. G23

    Judicial Review Case Management: practice note

    Practice note · November 27, 2025 · Applies to Code 1.3, Code 3.3, Code 4.2, Code 5.1, Code 7.2, Code 8.4, Code 8.5, Code 8.6, Code 8.7

  24. G24

    Clarification of the IAA's jurisdiction

    Guidance · May 20, 2025 · Applies to Code 3.2, Code 3.3

  25. G25

    Regulation and solicitors; When barristers need IAA regulation

    Guidance · December 15, 2021; June 12, 2017 · Applies to Code 3.2

  26. G26

    EU Settlement Scheme: guidance for immigration advisers

    Guidance · July 29, 2025 · Applies to Code 3.3

  27. G27

    Position statement on VPRS and VCRS

    Guidance · March 23, 2018 · Applies to Code 3.2, Code 3.3

  28. G28

    Criminal enforcement policy

    Guidance · August 25, 2023 · Applies to Principle 1, Code 1.1

  29. G29

    Border Security, Asylum and Immigration Act 2025: IAA factsheet

    Guidance · December 4, 2025 · Applies to Principle 9, Code 9.7

Legislation

The Immigration and Asylum Act 1999 and the other legislation beside the Code, linked to legislation.gov.uk.

  1. L1

  2. L2

  3. L3

  4. L4

  5. L5

  6. L6

  7. L7

  8. L8

  9. L9

  10. L10

  11. L11

  12. L12

  13. L13

  14. L14

  15. L15

  16. L16

  17. L17

  18. L18

  19. L19

  20. L20

  21. L21

  22. L22

  23. L23

  24. L24

  25. L25

  26. L26

  27. L27

  28. L28

  29. L29

  30. L30

  31. L31

  32. L32

Court and Upper Tribunal judgments

Judgments that bear on the Code, each summarised in our own words and linked to the judgment.

  1. C1

    Dhall v R [2013] EWCA Crim 1610

    Bears on Principle 1, Code 1.1, Code 1.2, Code 1.3, Code 2.1

    Sending the Home Office applications supported by false payslips can be the criminal offense of assisting unlawful immigration under Immigration Act 1971 s25 ([7] to [8], [18] to [20]). A conviction under s25 also disqualifies a person from registration (Sch 6 para 4), so document fraud is a criminal and registration risk as well as a conduct one.

  2. C2

    Visa Joy Ltd v Office of the Immigration Services Commissioner [2017] EWCA Civ 1473

    Bears on All

    An appeal under s87 is a full appeal on the merits. The tribunal decides for itself whether the adviser is fit and competent at the date of the hearing, on all admissible evidence, including matters the regulator did not rely on ([42] to [44]), and may revisit earlier complaint findings ([45], [47]). Fitness is assessed overall, not as a narrow test of particular charges ([40]), so a failure under the Code is evidence about fitness rather than an automatic result.

  3. C3

    R v K [2008] EWCA Crim 1900

    Bears on Code 3.1, Code 3.2, and who the Code covers

    A barrister who was not subject to the Bar's regulation was not authorized to practise for the purposes of s84(2)(b), and so was not a qualified person ([21] to [23]). What counts is being regulated for the work, not holding a professional title.

  4. C4

    Clarke v R [2008] EWCA Crim 651

    Bears on Code 3.1, Code 3.2, Code 8.2

    Once it is shown that someone gave immigration advice or services, they bear the legal burden of proving they were qualified ([26] to [31]). Having once worked for a registered body does not qualify someone later, and the qualified person must be both principal and supervisor for the advice actually given ([35] to [36]). The absence of insurance cover was noted as a harm to clients ([49]).

  5. C5

    R (Kaikai) v Immigration Services Commissioner [2003] EWCA Civ 860

    Bears on Principle 8, Code 8.2

    Professional indemnity insurance can be treated as a threshold matter when the tribunal decides whether to stay a registration decision pending appeal, because a poorly run practice does not protect its clients ([3] to [4]). This was a single judge's decision on permission, so its weight is limited.

  6. C6

    Dean v Bar Standards Board [2025] EWHC 1860 (Admin)

    Bears on Principle 2, Principle 3, Code 2.1, Code 3.2

    A professional's supervision of immigration advisers under s84(2)(e) cannot be used to carry on the work of an organization that is no longer registered, and telling the Bar Standards Board and the IAA that such supervision had stopped when it had not is a question of honesty ([3], [8] to [9]).

  7. C7

    Kingsley v Office of the Immigration Services Commissioner [2015] EWCA Civ 602

    Bears on Code 2.1, Code 4.1, Code 6.8

    The regulator's published description of an unregistered adviser's claimed academic title had a strong defence of qualified privilege, given the regulator's statutory role ([36] to [41]). Of limited value in reading the Code itself.

  8. UT1

    UK and R (Munir) v Secretary of State for the Home Department (AI hallucinations; supervision; Hamid) [2026] UKUT 81 (IAC)

    Bears on Code 1.2, Code 3.2, Code 4.2, Code 4.5, Code 8.1

    A supervisor stays responsible for work they delegate and should warn staff about general-purpose AI tools (headnote 2, [18]). Uploading confidential client documents to an open AI tool is inconsistent with confidentiality, waives privilege and should be referred to the Information Commissioner (headnote 4). Judicial review claim forms now carry a statement of truth about the authorities cited (headnote 3). The representative concerned was an IAA-registered adviser.

  9. UT2

    R (Hoxha) v Secretary of State for the Home Department (representatives: professional duties) [2019] UKUT 124 (IAC)

    Bears on Code 1.2, Code 1.3, Code 3.3, Code 4.2

    Judicial review case management needs Level 3 and the separate judicial review category, with counsel authorized to litigate (headnote 1). A client's distress does not justify going beyond what the adviser is authorized to do (headnote 2). A representative who relies on an expert report must check it is accurate, including how its information was obtained (headnote 3), and failures may be referred to the regulator (headnote 4).

  10. UT3

    Mansur (immigration adviser's failings: Article 8) [2018] UKUT 274 (IAC)

    Bears on Principle 5, Code 4.2, Code 5.1

    Poor advice from an adviser does not usually reduce the public interest in immigration control, so the client normally bears the consequences. A blatant failure to follow instructions, found by the regulator, which spoilt an application likely to succeed, can be a rare exception.

  11. UT4

    Akhtar (Designated Qualifying Regulator: s 84(3A)(b) restrictions) [2022] UKUT 38 (IAC)

    Bears on Who the Code covers

    The England and Wales limit on representatives authorized by a designated qualifying regulator applies only where the representative is outside England and Wales. It bears on who is outside the IAA scheme, not on the Code itself.

First-tier Tribunal decisions

Decisions of the First-tier Tribunal (Immigration Services), cited by neutral citation and case reference only, for the legal point each supports. We do not name advisers or publish outcomes.

  1. D1

    [2026] UKFTT 1305 (GRC), FT/IMS/2025/0015

    Bears on Principle 4, Code 4.5, Code 5.3, Code 5.4, Code 5.5, Code 5.7, Code 5.8, Code 5.9, Code 8.5, Code 9.1, Code 9.2, Code 9.4

    Each allegation is judged by the code in force when the conduct happened ([22]), and a failure under the code is not the end of the analysis: the question is present fitness ([69], [247]). Delay in transferring a file runs from the signed authority, and its seriousness turns on actual prejudice ([133] to [138]). A fee above the published scale is not unreasonable in itself if the uplift was explained in writing at the time ([73]). An invoice that acknowledges payment works as a receipt ([78]), and an earned fixed fee need not sit in a client account ([81], [89]). Confidentiality and data protection are separate questions, and UK GDPR consent is only one lawful basis ([120] to [121]). Poor records do not by themselves prove fabrication. Under the 2016 code the closure letter rule was read not to cover a client moving firms ([195]).

  2. D2

    [2025] UKFTT 290 (GRC), No case reference shown

    Bears on Code 1.2, Code 2.2, Code 3.2, Code 3.4, Code 3.5, Code 4.2, Code 5.2, Code 5.3, Code 7.2, Code 8.4, Code 8.5, Code 9.4

    Decided under the 2016 code. Advice from unregistered staff falls under the rule on unauthorised persons; administrative staff may send invoices and receipts but not advise, and emails signed as under a registered adviser's supervision showed the sender was advising ([28], [46]). Negligent advice could mislead under the 2016 wording ([54]). Using a company under common control raises a potential conflict without proof of benefit, and disclosure must be in writing with consent given beforehand ([60]). The client care letter is due at the latest when the adviser invoices or asks for payment ([67]), and should include a complaints procedure ([75]); naming a third-party provider is not required ([80]). The gist of records made in another language should be in English ([84]). A distinct client account has its ordinary meaning, and payments on account and disbursements belong in it ([93]). Vulnerability was not read across from other tribunals' definitions ([51]).

  3. D3

    [2024] UKFTT 901 (GRC), FT/IMS/2024/0002

    Bears on Principle 9, Code 2.2, Code 2.8, Code 3.2, Code 3.3, Code 4.2, Code 5.1, Code 9.1

    Decided under the 2016 code. Taking detailed asylum instructions and drafting a witness statement is Level 2 work ([50]). Letting an unauthorised person sit in on consultations risks the client thinking that person advises ([72]). An adviser who cannot help must say so promptly and point the client elsewhere, and charging for work that could not help took advantage of the client's lack of knowledge ([74] to [75]). On an appeal against a registration decision the tribunal has no power to order a fee refund; that power arises only on a disciplinary charge ([81]).

  4. D4

    [2026] UKFTT 1284 (GRC), FT/IMS/2025/0013

    Bears on Principle 2, Principle 3, Code 2.1, Code 3.6, Code 4.1

    An applicant is expected to disclose candidly the allegations of gross misconduct behind leaving an earlier job when the regulator asks. One wrong answer on a form would not alone show unfitness ([89]). Competence and fitness are separate, and a competent adviser who lacks candour can fall short on fitness ([103]). The scheme depends on self-reporting and full disclosure ([107]).

  5. D5

    [2026] UKFTT 146 (GRC), FT/IMS/2025/0007

    Bears on Principle 2, Code 2.1, Code 3.6, Code 4.1

    Another regulator's investigation and findings are relevant to fitness under the IAA scheme, and an applicant is expected to declare them. The IAA may rely on its published fitness guidance, which looks for a history of honesty and of keeping the law.

  6. D6

    [2026] UKFTT 135 (GRC), FT/IMS/2025/0006

    Bears on Code 3.7, Code 4.1

    Under the IAA's guidance on ex-offenders, convictions for dishonesty are of particular concern to fitness even when spent. Conviction history goes to fitness as well as to the duty to notify the IAA.

  7. D7

    No neutral citation, FT/IMS/2025/0005

    Bears on Code 3.7, Code 5.6, Code 5.9

    The tribunal's power under Sch 6 para 4B to act on a registration once an adviser is charged with certain offenses is discretionary ([36]). It weighs the risk to the public, public confidence, the effect on the adviser and on clients, and proportionality ([38]). A company's registration is separate from its director's, as they are different legal persons ([17]). When an adviser stops work, clients need a suitably registered adviser at the right level.

  8. D8

    [2026] UKFTT 335 (GRC), FT/IMS/2025/0014

    Bears on Code 3.6, Code 4.1, Code 6.7

    An adviser registering a new company makes a fresh application, which must meet the requirements in force at the time, including any period of leave to remain the IAA requires ([18]). Whether such a requirement is lawful is a question for judicial review, not for the tribunal ([19]).

  9. D9

    [2026] UKFTT 726 (GRC); [2026] UKFTT 488 (GRC), FT/IMS/2026/0001; FT/IMS/2025/0012

    Bears on Code 3.6, Code 4.1, Code 6.7

    The IAA may set the evidence needed for registration under Sch 6 para 1. A pending or future immigration application does not meet a requirement for a period of existing leave to remain.

  10. D10

    [2024] UKFTT 1084 (GRC), FT/IMS/2024/0003

    Bears on Code 3.3, Code 4.1, Code 4.3

    Competence at a level is shown by passing the assessment for that level, and without a pass it is not shown. The tribunal suggested re-marking and feedback as prudent practice ([37] to [40]).

  11. D11

    [2025] UKFTT 809 (GRC), FT/IMS/2024/0007

    Bears on Code 3.3, Code 4.3

    After a lapse in registration, long experience does not replace a current assessment where the last assessment and audit were years old ([226], [237]).

  12. D12

    [2025] UKFTT 454 (GRC), IMS/2023/0006

    Bears on Code 3.3, Code 4.3

    Moving up a level needs the competence assessment unless a published exemption applies. Earlier permission to work above level under a supervision plan was exceptional, limited in time and gave no entitlement.

  13. D13

    [2025] UKFTT 1136 (GRC), FT/IMS/2024/0006

    Bears on Code 4.1, and who the Code covers

    Qualification as a solicitor, and exemptions the SRA grants, do not oblige the IAA to exempt an applicant from its own assessment: the two routes to being qualified to advise are separate ([37]).

  14. D14

    [2025] UKFTT 959 (GRC); [2024] UKFTT 897 (GRC); [2024] UKFTT 147 (GRC), FT/IMS/2025/0003; FT/IMS/2024/0005; IMS.2023.0005

    Bears on Code 4.1, Code 4.3

    The tribunal asks whether the person is competent, not whether the marking process was lawful ([2025] UKFTT 959 (GRC) at [13]). Both sections of the assessment must be passed ([2024] UKFTT 147 (GRC)).

  15. D15

    Immigration Services Tribunal (legacy database), IMS/2020/0009(DIS), IMS/2020/0010(DIS), IMS/2020/0011

    Bears on Principle 6, Code 2.1, Code 4.1

    Dishonesty towards another regulator, such as sending it a false qualification, goes to fitness under the IAA scheme even though it is outside immigration casework. Allegations are decided on the balance of probabilities, but serious ones need strong evidence ([112]).

A general response

For a point that is not about one paragraph: the approach as a whole, something missing, or how an organization or adviser would use it.

Your view of General

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

About this consultation

  • The summaries are Signal & Line's own words, not the IAA's. These pages do not reproduce the Code of Standards: each paragraph links to the IAA's published code.
  • First-tier Tribunal decisions are cited by neutral citation and case reference, for the legal point they support. We do not name advisers or publish outcomes.
  • None of this is in Signal & Line yet. It is not legal advice. The IAA has not reviewed or endorsed it, and nothing here suggests that it has.
  • Legal Workflows is now Signal & Line. The consultation papers keep the name they were published under, and responses already sent still count.
  • Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0 (license). Contains information licensed under the Open Justice Licence v2.0 (license). See Copyright and credits.
  • We may publish a summary of the responses. The privacy notice explains how responses are handled. There is also an open consultation on the SRA Standards.