Firms 1.1
Firms 1.1: the firm must not let personal views lead it to discriminate unfairly in its professional relationships or the service it gives.
Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.
- Applies to
- Firm
- Kinds of duty (provisional)
- none
- Edition
- In effect from 11 April 2025
Linked
For reference. The paragraph has its own page, with our summary, a link to the SRA's text and its authorities, but nothing on a matter raises it.
Where it would apply in Signal & Line
Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.
- No activity raises Firms 1.1 on its own
- Cited on its page beside Code 1.1, which sets the same duty for individuals
Why we apply it this way
Whether personal views led to unfair treatment is a judgment about motive and effect, and no recorded event can show it. The Code also reaches unfair treatment that the Equality Act does not (EA ss4, 29), so an automated check would mislabel matters. Legal Workflows gives the paragraph a page and leaves the judgment to a person.
How it works in Signal & Line
- As Code 1.1, for the firm.
Authorities
Codes link to the schedule of authorities.
SRA guidance
G7 (Complying with Principle 6 - encouraging equality, diversity and inclusion), S4 (Terminating a retainer)
Legislation
EQ1 (Equality Act 2010 s4 (protected characteristics)), EQ4 (EA 2010 s29 (provision of services))
What we are asking you
- Is it right that no event raises Firms 1.1, including when a retainer is ended or a prospective client is turned away (S4)?
- Should declining to act for someone prompt a short reasons note that the firm could review?
Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Firms 1.1.
Respond on Firms 1.1
Firms 1.2
Firms 1.2: the firm must not use its position to gain an unfair advantage over a client or anyone else.
Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.
- Applies to
- Firm
- Kinds of duty (provisional)
- none
- Edition
- In effect from 11 April 2025
Linked
For reference. The paragraph has its own page, with our summary, a link to the SRA's text and its authorities, but nothing on a matter raises it.
Where it would apply in Signal & Line
Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.
- No activity raises Firms 1.2 on its own
- Cited on its page beside Code 1.2, which sets the same duty for individuals
Why we apply it this way
Taking unfair advantage depends on the balance of power and the purpose of the conduct, for example in NDAs, SLAPPs and high-volume claims (C4, C6, C10). Those are judgments about a whole course of conduct, not one event. Legal Workflows therefore shows the paragraph as reference and does not flag it.
How it works in Signal & Line
- As Code 1.2, for the firm.
Authorities
Codes link to the schedule of authorities.
SRA guidance
C4 (Use of non disclosure agreements (NDAs)), C5 (Conduct in disputes), C6 (Strategic Lawsuits against Public Participation (SLAPPs)), C10 (High-volume financial service claims), C12 ('No win, no fee' and other fee arrangements in high-volume consumer claims), R1 (Referral fees LASPO and SRA Principles)
Legislation
EC2; CN6 (DMCC 2024 s225 (unfair commercial practices prohibited), s226 (misleading actions), s227 (misleading omissions), s229 (professional diligence), Sch 20 (practices always unfair: para 1 code of conduct signatory claims; para 4 false approval or authorisation claims; para 13 fake reviews; para 28 persistent unwanted solicitations))
What we are asking you
- Should uploading a settlement agreement or NDA to a matter link the C4 guidance, without raising an item?
- Are there high-volume claim patterns (C10, C12) where a firm-level review would help?
Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Firms 1.2.
Respond on Firms 1.2
Firms 1.3
Firms 1.3: the firm carries out its undertakings by the agreed date or otherwise within a reasonable time.
Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.
- Applies to
- Firm
- Kinds of duty (provisional)
- record
- Edition
- In effect from 11 April 2025
Integrated
When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.
Where it would apply in Signal & Line
Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.
- Recording an undertaking the firm gives on a matter, with its wording, recipient and due date (a new record this would add)
- An undertaking's due date passing with it still open
- Closing a matter while an undertaking on it is still open
- Discharging an undertaking, with evidence of performance attached
Why we apply it this way
An undertaking given by an LLP or company is outside the court's summary enforcement, so the regulatory duty does the work (Harcus, C1). That makes the firm's own record of what it promised, to whom and by when the main safeguard. Legal Workflows uses a record item that stays open until a person attaches evidence, and undertakings survive closure (M6), so closing a matter does not end them.
How it works in Signal & Line
- Record: the item is discharged only with evidence attached (a document version, a note or a decision). Evidence is append-only and audited, so it can be shown to the SRA under Code 7.2 and Firms 2.2.
- As Code 1.3, for the firm’s undertakings.
Authorities
Codes link to the schedule of authorities.
SRA guidance
C1 (Undertakings given by, or on behalf of, incorporated practices), M6 (Closing down your practice)
Courts cannot enforce an incorporated practice's undertakings, so the Code duty does the work. Undertakings survive closure.
Legislation
A19 (SA 1974 s50: solicitors are officers of the Senior Courts, and the courts keep their historic jurisdiction over solicitors) (SA s50)
As S1.3. For a recognised or licensed body, enforcement of a firm undertaking is through its solicitor managers and employees.
Civil courts
A12 Harcus
Undertakings given by an LLP or company are outside the court's summary enforcement, but the regulatory duty remains (Harcus [142]-[145]).
What we are asking you
- Should the record say whether an individual or the firm gave the undertaking, given the enforcement point in Harcus?
- Should an open undertaking stop a matter from closing, or only warn?
- Do firms keep undertakings registers today that the product should import rather than start afresh?
Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Firms 1.3.
Respond on Firms 1.3
Firms 1.4
Firms 1.4: the firm must not mislead or try to mislead anyone, and must not allow or join in others, its client included, doing so, by act or omission.
Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.
- Applies to
- Firm
- Kinds of duty (provisional)
- none
- Edition
- In effect from 11 April 2025
Linked
For reference. The paragraph has its own page, with our summary, a link to the SRA's text and its authorities, but nothing on a matter raises it.
Where it would apply in Signal & Line
Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.
- No activity raises Firms 1.4 on its own
- Listed as a candidate where an event engages another paragraph, as Code 1.4 is
Why we apply it this way
Misleading is judged on what was said or left out and its likely effect, which needs a person who knows the whole matter. Software can catch some causes, such as an unchecked citation (G1), but it cannot tell a misleading statement from a mistaken one. So Legal Workflows never raises Firms 1.4 alone, and lists it where an event already engages another paragraph.
How it works in Signal & Line
- As Code 1.4, for the firm.
Authorities
Codes link to the schedule of authorities.
SRA guidance
G1 (Misuse of AI), C6 (Strategic Lawsuits against Public Participation (SLAPPs)), G13 (Tax avoidance your duties)
Legislation
CR4 (Fraud Act 2006 s2 (false representation), s3 (failing to disclose information)); CN6 (DMCC 2024 s225 (unfair commercial practices prohibited), s226 (misleading actions), s227 (misleading omissions), s229 (professional diligence), Sch 20 (practices always unfair: para 1 code of conduct signatory claims; para 4 false approval or authorisation claims; para 13 fake reviews; para 28 persistent unwanted solicitations))
What we are asking you
- Is it right to list Firms 1.4 only beside other paragraphs, never on its own?
- Where the firm's systems produce something for a client, such as a bill or costs update, should it cite Firms 1.4 as well as Code 1.4?
Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Firms 1.4.
Respond on Firms 1.4
Firms 1.5
Firms 1.5: gather diversity data about the firm's workforce and report and publish it in the way the SRA sets.
Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.
- Applies to
- Firm
- Kinds of duty (provisional)
- report
- Edition
- In effect from 11 April 2025
Parallel (self-certified)
Legal Workflows does not monitor this duty. The organisation certifies, with evidence it chooses, that it monitors the duty outside the platform, and certifies again at an interval it sets.
Where it would apply in Signal & Line
Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.
- An admin or the COLP certifying that the firm collected, reported and published its workforce diversity data as the SRA sets
- Uploading the evidence the firm chooses, such as a submission confirmation or the published summary
- Being asked to certify again at the interval the organisation sets
Why we apply it this way
Workforce diversity data is mostly special category data, and collecting it needs its own legal condition and safeguards (art 9, DPA Sch 1 para 8). It is about staff, not clients or matters, so no matter event can raise it. Legal Workflows does not collect or monitor it, and the firm certifies, with evidence it chooses, that it reports and publishes as the SRA prescribes (F9).
How it works in Signal & Line
- Covered by certification that the firm collected, reported and published workforce diversity data as the SRA prescribes.
- The provisional types (report) describe the duty; because the organisation certifies this duty, no product event opens an item for it.
Authorities
Codes link to the schedule of authorities.
SRA guidance
F9 (Firm diversity data Q&A), G7 (Complying with Principle 6 - encouraging equality, diversity and inclusion)
Applies to all firms. Consultants on contracts of 3 months or more are included. Publish a summary unless people could be identified. Fixed penalty for not reporting.
Legislation
DP2 (UK GDPR art 9 (special category data)) (art 9); DP4 (Data Protection Act 2018 Sch 1 para 8 (equality of opportunity or treatment condition)) (DPA Sch 1 para 8); GPG; ER25 (Employment Rights Act 2025 s34 (provision of information about outsourced workers)) (prospective)
Diversity data is mostly special category data. Collecting it needs an art 9 condition, normally DPA Sch 1 para 8 (equality of opportunity monitoring), which has its own safeguards. Gender pay gap reporting is a separate statutory duty for larger employers. The product's "report" item must collect and store this data under those conditions.
What we are asking you
- Is self-certification the right approach, or would firms want the product to run the workforce survey itself?
- What evidence would a COLP expect to attach to show the data was reported and the summary published?
- Is 12 months a sensible default interval, given the SRA's own collection cycle?
Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Firms 1.5.
Respond on Firms 1.5
Firms 1.6
Firms 1.6: treat everyone who works for or with the firm fairly and with respect, do not bully, harass or discriminate unfairly against them, and require employees to meet the same standard.
Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.
- Applies to
- Firm
- Kinds of duty (provisional)
- supervise, record
- Edition
- In effect from 11 April 2025
Parallel (self-certified)
Legal Workflows does not monitor this duty. The organisation certifies, with evidence it chooses, that it monitors the duty outside the platform, and certifies again at an interval it sets.
Where it would apply in Signal & Line
Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.
- An admin or the COLP certifying that the firm has, applies and reviews a fair-treatment, bullying, harassment and discrimination policy
- Certifying that the firm takes all reasonable steps to prevent sexual harassment, with evidence it chooses
- Being asked to certify again when the interval ends or a cited policy is replaced
Why we apply it this way
The duty reaches everyone who works for or with the firm and turns on workplace conduct, which has no matter to hang on. Monitoring staff communications would be intrusive, and a policy proves the firm's systems, not any person's behaviour (C2, G7). So Legal Workflows does not monitor this duty, and the firm certifies, with evidence, how it meets it, including the duty to prevent sexual harassment (EA s40A).
How it works in Signal & Line
- Covered by certification. Reaches everyone who works for or with the firm, and the Equality Act 2010 s40A duty to prevent sexual harassment.
- The provisional types (supervise, record) describe the duty; because the organisation certifies this duty, no product event opens an item for it.
Authorities
Codes link to the schedule of authorities.
SRA guidance
C2 (Workplace environment: risks of failing to protect and support colleagues), C3 (Workplace environment: risks of failing to protect and support colleagues - Case studies), G7 (Complying with Principle 6 - encouraging equality, diversity and inclusion), G9 (Sexual Misconduct), G10 (Offensive communications), E6 (Topic guide: Social media offensive communications)
Covers people who work "for and with" the firm, not only staff. Firms are expected to have policies, a confidential complaints route and recording (C2, G7).
Legislation
EQ3, EQ5, EQ6 (EA 2010 s40A (employer's duty to prevent sexual harassment)), EQ7 (ss44, 45, 109)
The firm is liable for employees' acts (s109). It owes a duty to take all reasonable steps to prevent sexual harassment (s40A, strengthened 30 October 2026) and, from 30 October 2026, must not permit third-party harassment (s40(1A)). Partners and LLP members are protected under ss44 and 45. See C13.
What we are asking you
- Is self-certification enough for Firms 1.6, given the strengthened duty to prevent sexual harassment from 30 October 2026?
- Should a new version of a cited policy prompt re-certification at once, or at the next interval?
- Should the certification name contractors and consultants explicitly, since the duty reaches those who work with the firm?
Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Firms 1.6.
Respond on Firms 1.6
Firms 2.1
Firms 2.1: have effective governance, systems and controls that keep the firm, its managers and staff compliant, stop others causing a breach, and let the compliance officers do their jobs.
Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.
- Applies to
- Firm
- Kinds of duty (provisional)
- supervise, record
- Edition
- In effect from 11 April 2025
Integrated (already live)
Legal Workflows already acts on this duty today. It will add the paragraph's own page, and cite the paragraph on what the product already does.
Where it would apply in Signal & Line
Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.
- Running a conflict search, kept as a snapshot that cannot be changed
- Recording a conflict decision, which is added to and never edited
- Granting or revoking a compliance role, such as COLP, COFA or MLRO, on the Compliance roles tab
- Accepting or rejecting an edit the assistant proposes to a document
Why we apply it this way
Firms 2.1 concerns the firm's systems as a whole, and statute expects prevention procedures for money laundering, bribery, tax evasion and fraud (MLR regs 18, 19 and 21, Bribery Act s7, CFA 2017 s45, ECCTA s199). Legal Workflows can show its own controls working: searches and decisions that cannot be rewritten, named compliance roles, and a person approving AI output (G1). It does not judge whether the firm's governance is effective, which is for its managers.
How it works in Signal & Line
- Existing product behaviour: Immutable conflict-search snapshots and append-only decisions.
- Supervise: the item is routed to the supervisor or manager responsible, and is discharged by their sign-off, not by the fee earner.
- Record: the item is discharged only with evidence attached (a document version, a note or a decision). Evidence is append-only and audited, so it can be shown to the SRA under Code 7.2 and Firms 2.2.
- The SRA’s Misuse of AI warning notice (17 August 2026) applies here. The paragraph's page links it, and the assistant verifies every quotation and keeps a person in the loop on every draft.
- Governance must cover AI, AML, sanctions and outsourcing.
Authorities
Codes link to the schedule of authorities.
SRA guidance
G1 (Misuse of AI), S3 (Effective supervision), F3–F8 (Complying with the UK Sanctions Regime), F10 (Compliance tips for solicitors regarding the use of AI and technology), F11 (Risk Outlook report: The use of artificial intelligence in the legal market), C2 (Workplace environment: risks of failing to protect and support colleagues), P8 (Marketing your services to members of the public), M2 (Improper use of client account as a banking facility)
Governance must cover AI, AML (regulation 19 policies, controls and procedures), sanctions, marketing via introducers, workplace culture and supervision.
Legislation
ML1 (Money Laundering, Terrorist Financing and Transfer of Funds (Information on the Payer) Regulations 2017: reg 7 (supervisors), 12 (independent legal professional), 18 (risk assessment), 19 (policies and controls), 21 (internal controls and nominated officer), 24 (training), 26 (approval of beneficial owners, officers and managers), 27 and 28 (customer due diligence), 40 (record-keeping)) (MLR regs 18, 19, 21, 24, 26); A8 (LSA 2007 s176: duty of regulated persons to comply with the regulator's arrangements) (LSA s176); A16 (LSA 2007 s90 (duties of non-authorised managers, employees and owners of licensed bodies), s91 (Head of Legal Practice), s92 (Head of Finance and Administration)) (LSA ss90 to 92); CR3 (Bribery Act 2010 s1 (bribing another person), s7 (failure of commercial organisations to prevent bribery)) (Bribery Act s7); EC3 (ECCTA 2023 s199 (failure to prevent fraud)) (ECCTA s199); CR5 (Criminal Finances Act 2017 s45 (failure to prevent facilitation of UK tax evasion)) (CFA 2017 s45)
Several statutes require prevention systems with a "reasonable or adequate procedures" defence: bribery, tax evasion facilitation and, for large organisations, fraud. Where the MLRs apply they require risk-based policies, a compliance officer, screening and audit. The "supervise, record" item for 2.1 should list these as separate control areas.
Civil courts
A34 Dentons; A33 Sa'id
Anti-money-laundering systems: the seriousness test applies (see S7.1).
Tribunal or SRA decision
SDT 12703 (above). Paragraphs found or considered: Firms 2.1(a), 4.4, 8.1.
The sole manager had no control of the bank accounts, did not know who worked under the firm's name, and lacked AML risk assessment and training.
Tribunal or SRA decision
SRA decision 508044 (above). Paragraphs found or considered: Firms 2.1(a), 2.2, 3.1.
Tribunal or SRA decision
SDT 12852 (above). Paragraphs found or considered: Firms 2.1(a)-(b), 3.2, 3.4.
What we are asking you
- Should AI, AML, sanctions and outsourcing be separate control areas on the 2.1 item, as the authorities suggest?
- Which of these controls would you show the SRA first, and is any important control missing?
- Is anything missing for a small firm with a single manager, the situation in SDT 12703?
Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Firms 2.1.
Respond on Firms 2.1
Firms 2.2
Firms 2.2: keep records that show the firm complies with the SRA's rules.
Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.
- Applies to
- Firm
- Kinds of duty (provisional)
- record
- Edition
- In effect from 11 April 2025
Integrated (already live)
Legal Workflows already acts on this duty today. It will add the paragraph's own page, and cite the paragraph on what the product already does.
Where it would apply in Signal & Line
Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.
- Running a conflict search and recording its decision, both kept unchanged as evidence
- Viewing or exporting the organisation's audit trail, as an org admin
- Exporting a project with an integrity manifest, so a recipient can check the files are unchanged
- Discharging a compliance item with evidence attached, which is then append-only
Why we apply it this way
Records under 2.2 must show compliance, and MLR reg 40 and UK GDPR art 5(2) add their own record duties. A record is only good evidence if it cannot be quietly changed, so Legal Workflows keeps searches, decisions and discharged items append-only and audited. The guidance also expects records of incidents, funding decisions, introducer checks and supervision (C2, M4, P8, S3), which the product does not yet hold in one place.
How it works in Signal & Line
- Existing product behaviour: Immutable conflict-search snapshots and append-only decisions.
- Record: the item is discharged only with evidence attached (a document version, a note or a decision). Evidence is append-only and audited, so it can be shown to the SRA under Code 7.2 and Firms 2.2.
- The append-only evidence on discharged items is part of the records 2.2 expects.
Authorities
Codes link to the schedule of authorities.
SRA guidance
F1 (Responsibilities of COLPs and COFAs), C2 (Workplace environment: risks of failing to protect and support colleagues), M4 (Using or arranging Third-Party Litigation Funding), P8 (Marketing your services to members of the public), S3 (Effective supervision)
Records expected include:
- all breaches (F1)
- incidents and challenges (C2)
- TPLF risk assessment and funder decisions (M4)
- introducer compliance checks (P8)
- supervision arrangements (S3)
Legislation
ML1 (Money Laundering, Terrorist Financing and Transfer of Funds (Information on the Payer) Regulations 2017: reg 7 (supervisors), 12 (independent legal professional), 18 (risk assessment), 19 (policies and controls), 21 (internal controls and nominated officer), 24 (training), 26 (approval of beneficial owners, officers and managers), 27 and 28 (customer due diligence), 40 (record-keeping)) (MLR reg 40); DP1 (UK GDPR art 5 (principles, including 5(1)(f) integrity and confidentiality, and 5(2) accountability)) (art 5(2))
Tribunal or SRA decision
SRA decision 508044 (above). Paragraphs found or considered: Firms 2.1(a), 2.2, 3.1.
What we are asking you
- Which of the records the guidance expects would you most want held in the product rather than elsewhere?
- Would the organisation audit trail export, in its current form, help when the SRA asks for records?
Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Firms 2.2.
Respond on Firms 2.2
Firms 2.3
Firms 2.3: the firm stays accountable for compliance where work is done through managers, staff or contractors.
Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.
- Applies to
- Firm
- Kinds of duty (provisional)
- supervise
- Edition
- In effect from 11 April 2025
Integrated
When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.
Where it would apply in Signal & Line
Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.
- Giving a contractor, agent or outside provider work on a matter (a record this would add)
- Using an assistant draft in work for a client, after a person has approved it
- Delegating litigation work to a member who is not authorised to conduct it (a member detail this would add)
Why we apply it this way
Accountability stays with the firm when work is done through staff, contractors or AI tools (G1, R6, S3), and the authorised person keeps responsibility for delegated litigation work (Mazur CA). Ayinde asks whether training and supervision were in place, so Legal Workflows routes the item to a supervisor for sign-off, not to the person who did the work. It does not raise an item on every task, which would bury the ones that matter.
How it works in Signal & Line
- Supervise: the item is routed to the supervisor or manager responsible, and is discharged by their sign-off, not by the fee earner.
- Outsourcing, contractors and AI do not move accountability.
Authorities
Codes link to the schedule of authorities.
SRA guidance
G1 (Misuse of AI), S3 (Effective supervision), R6 (Lawtech providers Q&A), C11 (Claims management activity)
Outsourcing, contractors and AI do not move accountability.
Legislation
A8 (LSA 2007 s176: duty of regulated persons to comply with the regulator's arrangements) (LSA s176(2)(b)); A16 (LSA 2007 s90 (duties of non-authorised managers, employees and owners of licensed bodies), s91 (Head of Legal Practice), s92 (Head of Finance and Administration)) (LSA s90); EQ7 (s109); A15 (SA 1974 s35 and Sch 1 (intervention), s43 (control of non-solicitor employees and consultants)) (SA s43)
Statute extends duties to non-authorised managers and employees, and the SRA can control who a firm employs (s43).
Civil courts
A35 Mazur CA; A10 Ayinde
The authorised individual keeps responsibility for delegated litigation work. Ayinde asks whether leadership measures such as training and supervision were in place (Ayinde [9]).
What we are asking you
- Which delegations should raise a supervise item: outside providers, unauthorised staff on litigation, AI drafts, or all three?
- Should the supervisor sign off once per matter, or for each delegated task?
- How do in-house teams and high-volume practices evidence supervision without an item on every task?
Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Firms 2.3.
Respond on Firms 2.3
Firms 2.4
Firms 2.4: watch the firm's financial stability and viability, and wind down in an orderly way once it knows it will close.
Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.
- Applies to
- Firm
- Kinds of duty (provisional)
- review
- Edition
- In effect from 11 April 2025
Integrated
When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.
Where it would apply in Signal & Line
Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.
- No product event is confirmed for this item yet, and its sources are still being decided
- A firm-level review of financial stability at an interval the organisation sets (a new check this would add)
- Recording a decision to close the firm, which would open a wind-down review (a new record this would add)
Why we apply it this way
Managers and compliance officers share the duty to watch viability, and an orderly wind-down with the SRA avoids intervention (F2, M6, SA Sch 1). The product does not hold the firm's accounts, so it cannot see financial difficulty and should not guess at it. Legal Workflows therefore proposes a firm-level review that a person completes, and asks which events, if any, should open it.
How it works in Signal & Line
- Review: the item opens a review task on the matter (for example of service, timeliness or risk). It is discharged by a person recording the review and its outcome.
- A firm-level review item. Event sources to be confirmed.
Authorities
Codes link to the schedule of authorities.
SRA guidance
F2 (Firm closures due to financial difficulties), M6 (Closing down your practice), M4 (Using or arranging Third-Party Litigation Funding), K8 (Mergers, acquisitions and sales of law firms)
Managers and compliance officers monitor viability. Orderly wind-down with SRA engagement avoids intervention.
Legislation
IN1 (Insolvency Act 1986 s123 (inability to pay debts), s214 (wrongful trading)) (IA ss123, 214); A15 (SA 1974 s35 and Sch 1 (intervention), s43 (control of non-solicitor employees and consultants)) (SA Sch 1)
Directors of companies face wrongful trading liability once insolvent liquidation cannot reasonably be avoided. Inability to pay debts has a statutory test. Insolvency and suspected dishonesty are intervention grounds. Whether IA s214 applies to LLP members was not verified.
What we are asking you
- What should open a 2.4 review: a set interval, a decision to close, or signals such as aged unbilled work?
- Is a firm-level review in the product useful to a COFA, or does this duty belong outside it?
- On a decision to close, should the review list open matters and open undertakings?
Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Firms 2.4.
Respond on Firms 2.4
Firms 2.5
Firms 2.5: identify, monitor and manage material risks to the business, including those from connected practices.
Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.
- Applies to
- Firm
- Kinds of duty (provisional)
- review, record
- Edition
- In effect from 11 April 2025
Integrated
When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.
Where it would apply in Signal & Line
Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.
- Uploading the firm-wide risk assessment as evidence for the review item
- Being asked to review the assessment again at an interval the organisation sets
- Recording third-party litigation funding on a matter (a new record this would add)
Why we apply it this way
The MLR firm-wide risk assessment is a statutory part of the material risks 2.5 covers, and the guidance expects written assessments of funding, sanctions, technology and cyber risk too (F3 to F6, M4, F8, K9). These are assessments of the business, so Legal Workflows opens a review item and keeps the written assessment as append-only evidence. It does not score the firm's risk, which is the firm's own judgment.
How it works in Signal & Line
- Review: the item opens a review task on the matter (for example of service, timeliness or risk). It is discharged by a person recording the review and its outcome.
- Record: the item is discharged only with evidence attached (a document version, a note or a decision). Evidence is append-only and audited, so it can be shown to the SRA under Code 7.2 and Firms 2.2.
- Firm-wide risk assessment evidence is attached as the record.
Authorities
Codes link to the schedule of authorities.
SRA guidance
M4 (Using or arranging Third-Party Litigation Funding), F3–F6 (Firm-wide risk assessments), F8 (Complying with the UK Sanctions Regime), F10 (Compliance tips for solicitors regarding the use of AI and technology), F11 (Risk Outlook report: The use of artificial intelligence in the legal market), K9 (Information security and cybercrime - Case studies), P8 (Marketing your services to members of the public)
Includes TPLF, AML firm-wide risk, sanctions, technology and AI, and cyber risk, with written assessments expected.
Legislation
ML1 (Money Laundering, Terrorist Financing and Transfer of Funds (Information on the Payer) Regulations 2017: reg 7 (supervisors), 12 (independent legal professional), 18 (risk assessment), 19 (policies and controls), 21 (internal controls and nominated officer), 24 (training), 26 (approval of beneficial owners, officers and managers), 27 and 28 (customer due diligence), 40 (record-keeping)) (MLR reg 18, firm-wide risk assessment); EC3 (ECCTA 2023 s199 (failure to prevent fraud)) (ECCTA s199)
The MLR risk assessment is a statutory subset of the material risks 2.5 covers.
Civil courts
A34 Dentons; A33 Sa'id
Anti-money-laundering systems: the seriousness test applies (see S7.1).
What we are asking you
- Should matter-level signals, such as a high-risk due diligence record, feed the firm-wide review or stay on the matter?
- How often should the review open, and should a new version of the assessment reopen it?
- How could a firm record risk from connected practices here?
Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Firms 2.5.
Respond on Firms 2.5
Firms 3.1
Firms 3.1: know, and comply with, the current legal and regulatory requirements on the firm.
Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.
- Applies to
- Firm
- Kinds of duty (provisional)
- none
- Edition
- In effect from 11 April 2025
Linked
For reference. The paragraph has its own page, with our summary, a link to the SRA's text and its authorities, but nothing on a matter raises it.
Where it would apply in Signal & Line
Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.
- No activity raises Firms 3.1 on its own
- Shown as reference on its own page, which says that other SRA rules, such as the Accounts Rules, are not yet in the product
- Specific legal duties, such as client due diligence, stay on their own records and paragraphs
Why we apply it this way
Firms 3.1 brings general law and the SRA's other rules into the code, so one item per statute would only repeat the specific paragraphs. A failure to follow the law becomes a conduct matter only when it is serious enough (Dentons), and that is a judgment for a person. SRA decision 508044 is why the specific records matter: a check that was not recorded cannot be shown.
How it works in Signal & Line
- As Code 7.1: other SRA instruments are not yet in the product, and the page says so.
Authorities
Codes link to the schedule of authorities.
SRA guidance
E7 (Topic guide: Anti-money laundering), F3–F8 (Complying with the UK Sanctions Regime)
Tribunal or SRA decision
SRA decision 508044 (above). Paragraphs found or considered: Firms 2.1(a), 2.2, 3.1.
What we are asking you
- Is it right that no event raises Firms 3.1, even where a client due diligence or sanctions check is missing?
- Does the page say clearly enough which SRA rules and other laws the product does not yet cover?
Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Firms 3.1.
Respond on Firms 3.1
Firms 3.2
Firms 3.2: work with the SRA and with other regulators, ombudsmen and oversight bodies for legal services.
Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.
- Applies to
- Firm
- Kinds of duty (provisional)
- report
- Edition
- In effect from 11 April 2025
Integrated
When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.
Where it would apply in Signal & Line
Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.
- Recording a request from the SRA, the Legal Ombudsman or another oversight body about a matter (a new record this would add)
- Setting the reply date as a key date, with its task
- Issuing the reply as a letter from the matter's correspondence register, which keeps the version sent
- Recording the decision on what to share, including any privileged material
Why we apply it this way
Cooperation shows in prompt, complete replies, so Legal Workflows records each request, its deadline and what was sent (A6). It never replies for the firm: what to share, and whether privileged material needs the client's consent first, is a decision for a person (K6). SDT 12852 shows how slow follow-through with the regulator can engage this paragraph.
How it works in Signal & Line
- Report: the item prompts a recorded decision on whether to notify the SRA (or another body), and records the notification if one is made. The product never sends a report itself.
- Any cooperation or reporting draft for this paragraph says that the SRA cannot compel production of a client’s privileged material without that client’s consent.
Authorities
Codes link to the schedule of authorities.
SRA guidance
A5 (On-site investigations (inspections)), A6 (How we gather evidence in our regulatory and disciplinary investigations), K6 (Confidentiality of client information), C4 (Use of non disclosure agreements (NDAs))
Tribunal or SRA decision
SDT 12852 (above). Paragraphs found or considered: Firms 2.1(a)-(b), 3.2, 3.4.
What we are asking you
- Should a Legal Ombudsman request open an item on the matter, or sit with the firm's complaint records instead?
- Is a key date with a task the right way to hold a regulator's reply deadline?
Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Firms 3.2.
Respond on Firms 3.2
Firms 3.3
Firms 3.3: answer the SRA promptly and fully, and make relevant information, including information held by critical outsourced providers, available for inspection.
Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.
- Applies to
- Firm
- Kinds of duty (provisional)
- report, record
- Edition
- In effect from 11 April 2025
Integrated
When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.
Where it would apply in Signal & Line
Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.
- Recording an SRA notice or information request, with the power it cites and its deadline (a new record this would add)
- Exporting a matter's documents with an integrity manifest for inspection
- Recording what a critical outsourced provider holds and how it would be produced (a new record this would add)
- Recording what was produced, and any privileged material held back for want of the client's consent
Why we apply it this way
The SRA expects firms to find and produce relevant information quickly, including what outsourced providers hold (A5, A6). Legal Workflows records the request and attaches what was produced as evidence, so the reply can be shown later. It does not decide what to produce, because the SRA cannot compel a client's privileged material without that client's consent (Carter-Ruck, under appeal).
How it works in Signal & Line
- Report: the item prompts a recorded decision on whether to notify the SRA (or another body), and records the notification if one is made. The product never sends a report itself.
- Record: the item is discharged only with evidence attached (a document version, a note or a decision). Evidence is append-only and audited, so it can be shown to the SRA under Code 7.2 and Firms 2.2.
- Includes information held by critical outsourced providers.
- Any cooperation or reporting draft for this paragraph says that the SRA cannot compel production of a client’s privileged material without that client’s consent.
Authorities
Codes link to the schedule of authorities.
SRA guidance
A5 (On-site investigations (inspections)), A6 (How we gather evidence in our regulatory and disciplinary investigations), A1 (Reporting and notification obligations)
As Code 7.4, including the Carter-Ruck privilege limit. Fixed penalties apply for not responding (G7).
What we are asking you
- Would an export with an integrity manifest help in an SRA inspection, or does the SRA expect information in another form?
- Should firms list Legal Workflows itself as a critical outsourced provider, and what should it produce on request?
Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Firms 3.3.
Respond on Firms 3.3
Firms 3.4
Firms 3.4: carry out remedial action the SRA asks for promptly.
Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.
- Applies to
- Firm
- Kinds of duty (provisional)
- report
- Edition
- In effect from 11 April 2025
Integrated
When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.
Where it would apply in Signal & Line
Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.
- Recording remedial action the SRA asks for, with its deadline (a new record this would add)
- Setting each remedial step as a task with an owner and a due date
- A remedial task passing its due date while still open
- Recording that the action is complete, with evidence, and the decision whether to tell the SRA
Why we apply it this way
The SRA may agree a compliance plan for putting things right (E1), and SDT 12852 shows that remediation left undone for a long time engages Firms 3.4. So Legal Workflows tracks each step to completion and shows delay, but leaves the adequacy of the work, and any report to the SRA, to a person.
How it works in Signal & Line
- Report: the item prompts a recorded decision on whether to notify the SRA (or another body), and records the notification if one is made. The product never sends a report itself.
Authorities
Codes link to the schedule of authorities.
SRA guidance
E1 (SRA enforcement strategy)
Tribunal or SRA decision
SDT 12852 (above). Paragraphs found or considered: Firms 2.1(a)-(b), 3.2, 3.4.
What we are asking you
- Should remedial action under a compliance plan be one item, or one item for each step?
- When a remedial step goes overdue, who should be told: the COLP, the managers, or both?
Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Firms 3.4.
Respond on Firms 3.4
Firms 3.5
Firms 3.5: be open with clients when something goes wrong, put it right where possible, explain promptly, and if the SRA asks, investigate possible claims, report, and tell those affected.
Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.
- Applies to
- Firm
- Kinds of duty (provisional)
- inform, report
- Edition
- In effect from 11 April 2025
Integrated
When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.
Where it would apply in Signal & Line
Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.
- Recording on the matter that something went wrong and the client may have suffered loss or harm (a new record this would add)
- A key date passing with its task still open
- Issuing a letter to the client explaining what happened, from the correspondence register
- Recording an SRA request to investigate possible claims, and the reports and notices that follow
Why we apply it this way
Openness is shown by telling the client promptly and keeping a record of it (K3), so the item is discharged by recording what was sent, when and how. Legal Workflows does not decide fault or whether a claim exists. Where personal data is involved, separate statutory clocks run (DP3), so the item reminds the person of them rather than replacing them.
How it works in Signal & Line
- Inform: the item asks for the client to be told something, and is discharged by recording what was sent, when and how. The assistant can prepare the communication as a draft for a person to approve.
- Report: the item prompts a recorded decision on whether to notify the SRA (or another body), and records the notification if one is made. The product never sends a report itself.
- No civil-court authority was found on candour; the page says so.
Authorities
Codes link to the schedule of authorities.
SRA guidance
K3 (Putting matters right when things go wrong, and own interest conflicts), M1 (Money missing from client account), E4 (Topic guide: Competence and Standard of Service)
What we are asking you
- Should a missed key date open a candour item by itself, or only once a person records that the client lost out?
- Is a letter from the correspondence register enough evidence of openness, or should a note of a call also count?
Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Firms 3.5.
Respond on Firms 3.5
Firms 3.6
Firms 3.6: notify the SRA promptly of serious financial difficulty, an insolvency event, an intention or expectation to stop operating, or a change to the firm's register entry.
Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.
- Applies to
- Firm
- Kinds of duty (provisional)
- report
- Edition
- In effect from 11 April 2025
Integrated
When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.
Where it would apply in Signal & Line
Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.
- Recording serious financial difficulty, an insolvency event or a plan to stop operating (a new record this would add)
- Adding or retiring an office in Offices and venues, which may change the firm's register entry
- Recording the decision whether to notify the SRA, and the notice given
Why we apply it this way
Legal Workflows holds no firm accounts, so it cannot detect financial difficulty, and there is no statutory test for it (IA 1986 s123 is narrower than the duty). A person records the facts, and the item asks for a decision on notifying the SRA, with notice before any closure (F2, M6). It is a firm-level item, because the duty attaches to no single matter.
How it works in Signal & Line
- Report: the item prompts a recorded decision on whether to notify the SRA (or another body), and records the notification if one is made. The product never sends a report itself.
Authorities
Codes link to the schedule of authorities.
SRA guidance
F2 (Firm closures due to financial difficulties), M6 (Closing down your practice), M4 (Using or arranging Third-Party Litigation Funding), A1 (Reporting and notification obligations)
Covers serious financial difficulty, including funding stress (M4), and notice before closure (M6).
Legislation
IN1 (Insolvency Act 1986 s123 (inability to pay debts), s214 (wrongful trading)); Glossary "relevant insolvency event"; A15 (SA 1974 s35 and Sch 1 (intervention), s43 (control of non-solicitor employees and consultants)) (SA Sch 1)
"Relevant insolvency event" is defined by reference to IA 1986 events. "Indicators of serious financial difficulty" has no statutory definition. IA s123 (inability to pay debts) is a useful indicator but is narrower than the duty.
What we are asking you
- For law centres and other funded organisations, should a funder contract ending with no replacement prompt this item?
- Are there other signals the product holds that should prompt a person to consider serious financial difficulty?
Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Firms 3.6.
Respond on Firms 3.6
Firms 3.7
Firms 3.7: give the SRA an information report each year, or as it otherwise specifies.
Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.
- Applies to
- Firm
- Kinds of duty (provisional)
- report
- Edition
- In effect from 11 April 2025
Integrated
When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.
Where it would apply in Signal & Line
Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.
- The annual information report falling due, raised as a periodic reminder (a reminder this would add)
- Recording that the report was submitted, when and by whom
Why we apply it this way
The duty turns on a date the SRA sets, not on anything that happens on a matter, so a periodic reminder fits it better than monitoring. No guidance was found, and the duty is not statutory beyond the enabling powers. Legal Workflows never submits the report itself, and it records only that a person did.
How it works in Signal & Line
- Report: the item prompts a recorded decision on whether to notify the SRA (or another body), and records the notification if one is made. The product never sends a report itself.
- A periodic reminder for the annual information report.
Authorities
Codes link to the schedule of authorities.
Legislation
No specific legislation
Not statutory, beyond the enabling powers.
What we are asking you
- Who should receive the reminder: the COLP, the COFA or an org admin?
- How far ahead of the SRA's deadline should the reminder open?
Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Firms 3.7.
Respond on Firms 3.7
Firms 3.8
Firms 3.8: notify the SRA promptly of a material change to information the firm gave it, or information that may be inaccurate.
Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.
- Applies to
- Firm
- Kinds of duty (provisional)
- report
- Edition
- In effect from 11 April 2025
Integrated
When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.
Where it would apply in Signal & Line
Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.
- Granting or revoking the COLP, COFA or MLRO compliance role
- Recording a change of manager, owner or beneficial owner (a new record this would add)
- Recording that information given to the SRA may be inaccurate, and the decision whether to correct it
Why we apply it this way
A1 lists the changes the SRA expects to hear about, including a new MLRO or beneficial owner. Role grants in Legal Workflows are already audited, so they are a useful prompt, but a role in the product is not SRA approval. The item therefore asks a person to decide whether the change is material and needs a notice.
How it works in Signal & Line
- Report: the item prompts a recorded decision on whether to notify the SRA (or another body), and records the notification if one is made. The product never sends a report itself.
Authorities
Codes link to the schedule of authorities.
SRA guidance
A1 (Reporting and notification obligations)
Schedule 1 of A1, including MLR notifications about changes of MLRO, MLCO or beneficial owner.
What we are asking you
- Is a change to a compliance role in the product a reliable prompt, given firms may grant roles for internal reasons?
- Which other changes recorded in the product should prompt a check under Firms 3.8?
Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Firms 3.8.
Respond on Firms 3.8
Firms 3.9
Firms 3.9: report promptly facts the firm reasonably believes could be a serious breach by anyone the SRA regulates, including the firm itself, and investigate if the SRA asks.
Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.
- Applies to
- Firm
- Kinds of duty (provisional)
- report, record
- Edition
- In effect from 11 April 2025
Integrated
When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.
Where it would apply in Signal & Line
Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.
- Recording a concern that someone the SRA regulates, including the firm, may have seriously failed to meet its rules (a new record this would add)
- A wasted costs order or judicial criticism recorded on a matter (a new record this would add)
- Recording the decision whether to report, with reasons, including a decision not to
- Recording an internal investigation the SRA asks for, and its outcome
Why we apply it this way
Whether facts could be serious enough to report is a judgment for a person, so Legal Workflows records the decision and its reasons and grades nothing (A1, A4). Loyalty to a colleague is no reason to hold back (James). For licensed bodies the Head of Legal Practice has a statutory duty as well (LSA s91), and the item notes it.
How it works in Signal & Line
- Report: the item prompts a recorded decision on whether to notify the SRA (or another body), and records the notification if one is made. The product never sends a report itself.
- Record: the item is discharged only with evidence attached (a document version, a note or a decision). Evidence is append-only and audited, so it can be shown to the SRA under Code 7.2 and Firms 2.2.
- Includes reporting the firm itself; the decision whether to report is recorded.
- Any cooperation or reporting draft for this paragraph says that the SRA cannot compel production of a client’s privileged material without that client’s consent.
Authorities
Codes link to the schedule of authorities.
SRA guidance
A1 (Reporting and notification obligations), A4 (Internal investigations), E1 (SRA enforcement strategy), M1 (Money missing from client account), C4 (Use of non disclosure agreements (NDAs))
As Code 7.7. Investigate if the SRA asks.
Legislation
WB1 (Employment Rights Act 1996 s43B (qualifying disclosures), s43F (disclosure to a prescribed person), s43J (confidentiality clauses void), s47B (detriment), s103A (dismissal)), WB2 (Public Interest Disclosure (Prescribed Persons) Order 2014, Schedule (Law Society, including the SRA)); CO1 (Senior Courts Act 1981 s51(6), (7) and (7A) (wasted costs)) (SCA s51(7A)); A16 (LSA 2007 s90 (duties of non-authorised managers, employees and owners of licensed bodies), s91 (Head of Legal Practice), s92 (Head of Finance and Administration)) (LSA s91)
As S7.7. For licensed bodies, the HOLP's statutory reporting duty also applies (s91).
Civil courts
A6 James (MacGregor)
Loyalty and concern for a colleague's health are no excuse (James [115], [119]-[120]).
What we are asking you
- Should a decision not to report be visible to the COLP by default?
- Should a wasted costs order on a matter always raise this item, or only prompt a person to consider it?
Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Firms 3.9.
Respond on Firms 3.9
Firms 3.10
Firms 3.10: tell the SRA promptly about anything the firm reasonably believes it should consider investigating.
Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.
- Applies to
- Firm
- Kinds of duty (provisional)
- report
- Edition
- In effect from 11 April 2025
Integrated
When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.
Where it would apply in Signal & Line
Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.
- Recording a cyber attack or near miss affecting the firm or client data (a new record this would add)
- Recording any other concern the SRA may want to investigate
- Recording the decision whether to tell the SRA, with reasons
Why we apply it this way
This duty reaches beyond serious failures to anything the SRA may want to look into, such as novel or significant cyber attacks and near misses (E1). Legal Workflows cannot judge that from events, so it records the facts and the decision. It never tells the SRA itself.
How it works in Signal & Line
- Report: the item prompts a recorded decision on whether to notify the SRA (or another body), and records the notification if one is made. The product never sends a report itself.
Authorities
Codes link to the schedule of authorities.
SRA guidance
A1 (Reporting and notification obligations), E1 (SRA enforcement strategy)
Legislation
WB1 (Employment Rights Act 1996 s43B (qualifying disclosures), s43F (disclosure to a prescribed person), s43J (confidentiality clauses void), s47B (detriment), s103A (dismissal)), WB2 (Public Interest Disclosure (Prescribed Persons) Order 2014, Schedule (Law Society, including the SRA))
What we are asking you
- Should a cyber attack or near miss raise this item, and who in the firm should decide whether it is significant?
- Many such events touch no client matter. Is a firm-level item the right home for them?
Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Firms 3.10.
Respond on Firms 3.10
Firms 3.11
Firms 3.11: do not stop anyone, including through a settlement or non-disclosure agreement, from giving information to the SRA or any other regulator, supervisor, investigator or prosecutor.
Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.
- Applies to
- Firm
- Kinds of duty (provisional)
- none
- Edition
- In effect from 11 April 2025
Linked
For reference. The paragraph has its own page, with our summary, a link to the SRA's text and its authorities, but nothing on a matter raises it.
Where it would apply in Signal & Line
Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.
- No activity raises Firms 3.11 on its own
- Shown as reference on its own page beside Code 7.5, with the law on terms that cannot stop a disclosure
Why we apply it this way
Whether a settlement or non-disclosure term stops someone reporting depends on its wording and on the law that makes such terms void (ERA s43J, VPA s17). No stored event shows that, so Legal Workflows does not monitor the duty and leaves the drafting judgment to a person (C4).
How it works in Signal & Line
- Reference only, as Code 7.5.
Authorities
Codes link to the schedule of authorities.
SRA guidance
C4 (Use of non disclosure agreements (NDAs)), A1 (Reporting and notification obligations)
Legislation
WB1 (Employment Rights Act 1996 s43B (qualifying disclosures), s43F (disclosure to a prescribed person), s43J (confidentiality clauses void), s47B (detriment), s103A (dismissal)) (s43J); WB3 (Victims and Prisoners Act 2024 s17 (agreements cannot stop victims making certain disclosures)) (VPA s17)
What we are asking you
- Should drafting a settlement agreement or NDA in the product prompt a check against Firms 3.11?
- Is a reference page enough for firms that draft settlement agreements in volume, such as employment practices?
Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Firms 3.11.
Respond on Firms 3.11
Firms 3.12
Firms 3.12: do not subject anyone to detriment for reporting, or proposing to report, on the basis of a reasonably held belief, whether or not any action follows.
Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.
- Applies to
- Firm
- Kinds of duty (provisional)
- none
- Edition
- In effect from 11 April 2025
Linked
For reference. The paragraph has its own page, with our summary, a link to the SRA's text and its authorities, but nothing on a matter raises it.
Where it would apply in Signal & Line
Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.
- No activity raises Firms 3.12 on its own
- Shown as reference on its own page beside Code 7.9, as no matter records how someone who reports is treated
Why we apply it this way
Detriment happens in how people are treated at work, which has no matter to hang on, and watching staff from inside the product would be intrusive. The statutory protection is also narrower than 3.12 (ERA ss43B, 47B), so a person must judge each case. Legal Workflows therefore cites the paragraph and does not monitor it.
How it works in Signal & Line
- Reference only, as Code 7.9.
Authorities
Codes link to the schedule of authorities.
SRA guidance
A1 (Reporting and notification obligations), G7 (Complying with Principle 6 - encouraging equality, diversity and inclusion)
Legislation
WB1 (Employment Rights Act 1996 s43B (qualifying disclosures), s43F (disclosure to a prescribed person), s43J (confidentiality clauses void), s47B (detriment), s103A (dismissal)) (ss43B, 47B, 103A); WB2 (Public Interest Disclosure (Prescribed Persons) Order 2014, Schedule (Law Society, including the SRA))
As S7.9, including correction C8.
What we are asking you
- Should Firms 3.12 join the duties firms self-certify, such as Firms 1.6, rather than stay as reference only?
- Is it right that the product records nothing about how a person who reports is treated?
Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Firms 3.12.
Respond on Firms 3.12
Firms 4.1
Firms 4.1: act only on instructions from the client or someone authorised for them, check doubtful instructions, and protect the client's interests when instructions cannot be had.
Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.
- Applies to
- Firm
- Kinds of duty (provisional)
- identify
- Edition
- In effect from 11 April 2025
Integrated
When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.
Where it would apply in Signal & Line
Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.
- Choosing the matter's client from the client register when the matter is opened
- Adding a representative to the client's record as an appointee, deputy or attorney
- Changing a matter's client, with the reason recorded
- Recording the authority relied on, and any check of doubtful instructions (a new record this would add)
Why we apply it this way
Firms 4.1 needs systems that make sure the person instructing is the client or has authority, so the item links what the product already holds: the register entry and any representative. Capacity is presumed (MCA s1), so a vulnerable flag never counts as lack of capacity. S1 and C10 explain why instructions through third parties and introducers need a recorded check.
How it works in Signal & Line
- Identify: the item asks the person acting to confirm who the client is, or who is authorised to instruct, and links the evidence already held (the client register entry, the instructing party on the matter).
- As Code 3.1, for the firm.
Authorities
Codes link to the schedule of authorities.
SRA guidance
S1 (Accepting instructions from vulnerable clients or third parties acting on their behalf), C10 (High-volume financial service claims), R1 (Referral fees LASPO and SRA Principles)
Legislation
MC1 (Mental Capacity Act 2005 s1 (principles), s2 (lack of capacity), s9 (lasting powers of attorney)); ML1 (Money Laundering, Terrorist Financing and Transfer of Funds (Information on the Payer) Regulations 2017: reg 7 (supervisors), 12 (independent legal professional), 18 (risk assessment), 19 (policies and controls), 21 (internal controls and nominated officer), 24 (training), 26 (approval of beneficial owners, officers and managers), 27 and 28 (customer due diligence), 40 (record-keeping)) (regs 27, 28)
What we are asking you
- Is the representative's type enough, or should the item also ask for the document that gives the authority?
- In high-volume claims work, should instructions that come through an introducer always raise this item?
Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Firms 4.1.
Respond on Firms 4.1
Firms 4.2
Firms 4.2: give a competent, timely service that takes account of the client's needs and circumstances.
Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.
- Applies to
- Firm
- Kinds of duty (provisional)
- review
- Edition
- In effect from 11 April 2025
Integrated
When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.
Where it would apply in Signal & Line
Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.
- A key date passing with its task still open
- A matter with no activity for the number of days an automation rule sets
- Setting a vulnerable flag on a client who has open matters
- Closing a matter, through the close checklist
Why we apply it this way
Firms 4.2 joins competence and timeliness with the client's needs (E4, EQ2), and statute implies a reasonable time for consumers (CN1). A single genuine slip is not a conduct matter, so Legal Workflows opens a review item for a person to look at the service, not a finding of failure. Vulnerability prompts a review of the service, never a judgment about capacity.
How it works in Signal & Line
- Review: the item opens a review task on the matter (for example of service, timeliness or risk). It is discharged by a person recording the review and its outcome.
- As Code 3.2 and 3.4 together, for the firm.
Authorities
Codes link to the schedule of authorities.
SRA guidance
E4 (Topic guide: Competence and Standard of Service), G1 (Misuse of AI), S6 (Failure to provide a proper standard of service or quality, particularly for vulnerable consumers- Case study), S8 (Advising on leasehold provisions including ground rent clauses), G13 (Tax avoidance your duties)
Combines Code 3.2 and 3.4.
Legislation
CN1 (Consumer Rights Act 2015 s49 (reasonable care and skill), s50 (information binding), s52 (reasonable time)) (CRA ss49, 52); EQ2 (EA 2010 s20 (duty to make adjustments)), EQ4 (EA 2010 s29 (provision of services))
As S3.2 and S3.4 combined.
What we are asking you
- Should a vulnerable flag raise a service review on each open matter for that client, or only on new matters?
- At firm level, should review items also sample matters at random, not only follow these events?
Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Firms 4.2.
Respond on Firms 4.2
Firms 4.3
Firms 4.3: make sure managers and staff are competent and keep their knowledge current.
Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.
- Applies to
- Firm
- Kinds of duty (provisional)
- supervise, record
- Edition
- In effect from 11 April 2025
Integrated
When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.
Where it would apply in Signal & Line
Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.
- Adding a member to the organisation, singly or by bulk invitation
- Attaching a member's training or competence record as evidence (a record this would add)
- A periodic competence review of managers and staff, signed off by a manager (a review this would add)
Why we apply it this way
Firms need systems that keep staff competent and current, including on AML training and AI use (S12, MLR reg 24, G1). Legal Workflows cannot judge competence, so it routes the item to a manager and keeps the evidence they attach. Ayinde asks whether training and supervision were in place, and these records answer that question.
How it works in Signal & Line
- Supervise: the item is routed to the supervisor or manager responsible, and is discharged by their sign-off, not by the fee earner.
- Record: the item is discharged only with evidence attached (a document version, a note or a decision). Evidence is append-only and audited, so it can be shown to the SRA under Code 7.2 and Firms 2.2.
- Competence records for managers and staff are attached as evidence.
Authorities
Codes link to the schedule of authorities.
SRA guidance
S12 (The law firms role in making sure solicitors meet their continuing competence obligations), G1 (Misuse of AI), F4 (Money laundering and terrorist financing suspicious activity reports), S7 (Drafting and preparation of wills)
Firms need systems for staff competence. The SRA may request a competence declaration (E4).
Legislation
ML1 (Money Laundering, Terrorist Financing and Transfer of Funds (Information on the Payer) Regulations 2017: reg 7 (supervisors), 12 (independent legal professional), 18 (risk assessment), 19 (policies and controls), 21 (internal controls and nominated officer), 24 (training), 26 (approval of beneficial owners, officers and managers), 27 and 28 (customer due diligence), 40 (record-keeping)) (MLR reg 24)
Civil courts
A35 Mazur CA; A10 Ayinde
The authorised individual keeps responsibility for delegated litigation work. Ayinde asks whether leadership measures such as training and supervision were in place (Ayinde [9]).
What we are asking you
- Is a member joining the right point to ask for competence evidence, or should it be a set interval?
- Which records would you expect to attach: training logs, AML training, AI training, or something else?
Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Firms 4.3.
Respond on Firms 4.3
Firms 4.4
Firms 4.4: run an effective system for supervising client matters.
Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.
- Applies to
- Firm
- Kinds of duty (provisional)
- supervise, review, record
- Edition
- In effect from 11 April 2025
Integrated
When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.
Where it would apply in Signal & Line
Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.
- A key date awaiting a second person's check, where the organisation requires one
- Running a workflow on a matter, kept in its run history for a supervisor to review
- Making a member the responsible person on a matter
- A supervisor recording a file review on the matter (a record this would add)
Why we apply it this way
Supervision must be risk-based and evidenced, and it covers AI output (S3, G1). The authorised person keeps responsibility for work they delegate (Mazur CA), and SDT 12703 concerned unadmitted staff left unsupervised on high-risk work. So items go to the supervisor for sign-off with the evidence, and the product does not decide how much supervision is enough.
How it works in Signal & Line
- Supervise: the item is routed to the supervisor or manager responsible, and is discharged by their sign-off, not by the fee earner.
- Review: the item opens a review task on the matter (for example of service, timeliness or risk). It is discharged by a person recording the review and its outcome.
- Record: the item is discharged only with evidence attached (a document version, a note or a decision). Evidence is append-only and audited, so it can be shown to the SRA under Code 7.2 and Firms 2.2.
- Supervision should be evidenced and risk-based, including review of AI output.
- The SRA’s Misuse of AI warning notice (17 August 2026) applies here. The paragraph's page links it, and the assistant verifies every quotation and keeps a person in the loop on every draft.
Authorities
Codes link to the schedule of authorities.
SRA guidance
S3 (Effective supervision), G1 (Misuse of AI), S7 (Drafting and preparation of wills), E4 (Topic guide: Competence and Standard of Service)
Supervision should be evidenced and risk-based. It includes AI output review and delegation schemes.
Civil courts
A35 Mazur CA; A10 Ayinde
The authorised individual keeps responsibility for delegated litigation work. Ayinde asks whether leadership measures such as training and supervision were in place (Ayinde [9]).
Tribunal or SRA decision
SDT 12703 (above). Paragraphs found or considered: Firms 2.1(a), 4.4, 8.1.
Unadmitted fee earners on high-risk conveyancing were unsupervised; staff were taken on without CVs or ID; a person subject to a section 43 order worked without SRA permission.
Tribunal or SRA decision
SDT 12703 (above). Paragraphs found or considered: Firms 2.1(a), 4.4, 8.1.
The sole manager had no control of the bank accounts, did not know who worked under the firm's name, and lacked AML risk assessment and training.
What we are asking you
- Should giving a high-risk matter to an unadmitted fee earner always open a supervise item?
- Is a workflow's run history enough evidence that AI output was supervised, or should a supervisor sign off each run?
Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Firms 4.4.
Respond on Firms 4.4
Firms 5.1
Firms 5.1: account to the client for any financial benefit the firm gets through their instructions, unless the client, told the material facts including the amount, agrees otherwise.
Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.
- Applies to
- Firm
- Kinds of duty (provisional)
- account, consent, record
- Edition
- In effect from 11 April 2025
Integrated
When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.
Where it would apply in Signal & Line
Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.
- Recording a commission, referral payment or other benefit received through a client's instructions (a new record this would add)
- Recording what the client was told, including the amount, before they agree (a new record this would add)
- Uploading the client's signed agreement to the matter and linking it as evidence
Why we apply it this way
A secret commission belongs to the client (FHR), and consent counts only after the client knows the material facts, including the amount (Hopcraft). So Legal Workflows records the disclosure first, then the consent and its evidence. Keeping a commission without accounting for it can also take a firm outside the FSMA s327 exemption.
How it works in Signal & Line
- Account: the item is tied to billing and client-money events (benefits received, shortages, client money held). Finance items are routed to the COFA where the firm has one.
- Consent: the item records the client’s informed consent before the work goes ahead: who gave it, when, in what form, and the document version that evidences it.
- Record: the item is discharged only with evidence attached (a document version, a note or a decision). Evidence is append-only and audited, so it can be shown to the SRA under Code 7.2 and Firms 2.2.
- As Code 4.1: disclosure of the material facts, including the amount, comes before consent (Hopcraft).
Authorities
Codes link to the schedule of authorities.
SRA guidance
M5 (SRA consumer credit), M6 (Closing down your practice), M4 (Using or arranging Third-Party Litigation Funding)
Legislation
FS1 (Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 s21 (financial promotion), s327 (exemption for professional firms)) (FSMA s327(3))
What we are asking you
- Which benefits arise most often in practice, such as commissions, panel payments or interest, and should each raise an item?
- Is it right to refuse a consent until a disclosure that states the amount is on record?
Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Firms 5.1.
Respond on Firms 5.1
Firms 5.2
Firms 5.2: keep safe any money or assets entrusted to the firm.
Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.
- Applies to
- Firm
- Kinds of duty (provisional)
- account, report
- Edition
- In effect from 11 April 2025
Integrated
When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.
Where it would apply in Signal & Line
Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.
- Recording a client-money shortage on a matter (a new record this would add, as the Accounts Rules are not yet in the product)
- Completing client due diligence before the firm holds money for the client
- Recording the decision whether to report a shortage to the SRA
Why we apply it this way
A shortage must be put right and is also a reporting event (M1), so the item asks for both. Client account must not be used as a banking facility (M2, Fuglers), and SDT 12703 shows that weak identity checks can let fraudsters take client money. Legal Workflows records these events and decisions, but it holds no client account itself.
How it works in Signal & Line
- Account: the item is tied to billing and client-money events (benefits received, shortages, client money held). Finance items are routed to the COFA where the firm has one.
- Report: the item prompts a recorded decision on whether to notify the SRA (or another body), and records the notification if one is made. The product never sends a report itself.
- As Code 4.2: a shortage is also a reporting event.
Authorities
Codes link to the schedule of authorities.
SRA guidance
M1 (Money missing from client account), M2 (Improper use of client account as a banking facility), M3 (Do I need to operate a client account?), M7 (Taking money for your firm's costs), C7 (Sham litigation)
Legislation
A2 (SA 1974 s2 (training regulations), s13 (practising certificate appeals), s28 (regulations on admission, the roll and practising certificates), s32 (accounts rules), s33A (inspection of practice bank accounts), s34 (accountants' reports), s37 (indemnity rules)) (SA ss32, 33A, 34); SA4 (SA 1974 s85 (bank accounts held under the accounts rules)) (s85); PC1 (Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 s328 (arrangements), s330 (failure to disclose: regulated sector), s333A (tipping off: regulated sector), s333D (permitted disclosures), s337 (protected disclosures), s342 (prejudicing an investigation)) (POCA s328)
Tribunal or SRA decision
SDT 12703 (above). Paragraphs found or considered: 4.2, Firms 5.2, Accounts Rules.
ID-check failures that let fraudsters take client money breached the safeguarding duty without any lack of integrity.
What we are asking you
- Until the Accounts Rules are in the product, should a person record shortages on the matter, or should this wait?
- Should money passing through with no legal work behind it be its own trigger?
Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Firms 5.2.
Respond on Firms 5.2
Firms 6.1
Firms 6.1: do not act where the firm's own interests conflict, or are at significant risk of conflicting, with the client's.
Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.
- Applies to
- Firm
- Kinds of duty (provisional)
- conflict
- Edition
- In effect from 11 April 2025
Integrated (already live)
Legal Workflows already acts on this duty today. It will add the paragraph's own page, and cite the paragraph on what the product already does.
Where it would apply in Signal & Line
Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.
- Running a conflict check when a matter is opened, or when its client changes
- Deciding a check with an own-interest hit, where only Decline or Refer is offered
- Recording the firm's own interests so checks can find them (a register this would add)
Why we apply it this way
Firms 6.1 has no exception, so no consent can cure an own-interest conflict. Legal Workflows offers only Decline or Refer on such a hit, and a conflicts reviewer judges whether the risk is significant. Funding arrangements can create an interest of the firm's own (M4), which the register would need to hold.
How it works in Signal & Line
- Existing product behaviour: Own-interest hit cannot be waived (ConflictDecisionForm.tsx).
- Conflict: the item is tied to the conflict search and its recorded decision. The decision outcome (for example acting under an exception) is the evidence, and an own-interest conflict cannot be waived.
Authorities
Codes link to the schedule of authorities.
SRA guidance
K1–K9 (Information security and cybercrime - Case studies), M4 (Using or arranging Third-Party Litigation Funding)
As Code 6.1–6.5. Note that Firms 6.4 binds "any individual who is acting for a client".
Civil courts
As S6.1-S6.5
The same authorities apply.
What we are asking you
- Which own interests should the register hold: relationships, financial interests, funding or referral arrangements?
- Is Refer the right route when a reviewer is unsure whether a risk is significant?
Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Firms 6.1.
Respond on Firms 6.1
Firms 6.2
Firms 6.2: do not act for two or more clients whose interests conflict, or are at significant risk of conflicting, unless one of the two exceptions applies with the conditions it sets.
Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.
- Applies to
- Firm
- Kinds of duty (provisional)
- conflict, consent
- Edition
- In effect from 11 April 2025
Integrated (already live)
Legal Workflows already acts on this duty today. It will add the paragraph's own page, and cite the paragraph on what the product already does.
Where it would apply in Signal & Line
Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.
- Running a conflict check on the new-matter form before the matter is opened
- Recording the outcome "Act under an exception", naming 6.2(a) or (b), with each client's consent document and the safeguards
- Confirming it is reasonable to act for all the clients, by a reviewer other than the person who ran the check
Why we apply it this way
Each exception carries conditions: the clients' informed consent, safeguards, and a judgment that acting for all of them is reasonable. Legal Workflows records each condition before a check clears, and the decision is the evidence. A second person confirms reasonableness, so the person who found the conflict does not also approve it.
How it works in Signal & Line
- Conflict: the item is tied to the conflict search and its recorded decision. The decision outcome (for example acting under an exception) is the evidence, and an own-interest conflict cannot be waived.
- Consent: the item records the client’s informed consent before the work goes ahead: who gave it, when, in what form, and the document version that evidences it.
Authorities
Codes link to the schedule of authorities.
SRA guidance
K1–K9 (Information security and cybercrime - Case studies), M4 (Using or arranging Third-Party Litigation Funding)
As Code 6.1–6.5. Note that Firms 6.4 binds "any individual who is acting for a client".
Civil courts
As S6.1-S6.5
The same authorities apply.
What we are asking you
- Is it right that the reviewer who confirms reasonableness cannot be the person who ran the check, even in a small firm?
- Should there be an audited urgent override, or must a check always clear before a matter opens?
Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Firms 6.2.
Respond on Firms 6.2
Firms 6.3
Firms 6.3: keep current and former clients' affairs confidential, and do not misuse them, unless the law requires or permits disclosure or the client agrees.
Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.
- Applies to
- Firm
- Kinds of duty (provisional)
- confidentiality
- Edition
- In effect from 11 April 2025
Integrated (already live)
Legal Workflows already acts on this duty today. It will add the paragraph's own page, and cite the paragraph on what the product already does.
Where it would apply in Signal & Line
Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.
- Adding a member or a team to a matter, which decides who can open it
- Screening a member from a matter with an information barrier
- Running a conflict check, where the requester sees hits on other matters only as counts
Why we apply it this way
Confidentiality is built into access rather than raised by events: a person sees a matter only through membership or a grant, and a barrier always wins. Conflict checks must read across matters, so only conflicts reviewers see hit details. K1 to K9 show how weak information security exposes client affairs, which is why the boundary does not wait for a review.
How it works in Signal & Line
- Existing product behaviour: Matter membership is the confidentiality boundary; cross-matter conflict reads (parties.shared.ts, conflicts.decisions.ts).
- Confidentiality: matter membership and information barriers enforce the boundary. The item records the barrier, or the consent, that allows the work to continue.
Authorities
Codes link to the schedule of authorities.
SRA guidance
K1–K9 (Information security and cybercrime - Case studies), M4 (Using or arranging Third-Party Litigation Funding)
As Code 6.1–6.5. Note that Firms 6.4 binds "any individual who is acting for a client".
Civil courts
As S6.1-S6.5
The same authorities apply.
What we are asking you
- Firms can let every member view unrestricted matters. Is that consistent with Firms 6.3, or should restricted be the default?
- Should any use of client information across matters, other than conflict checks, raise an item?
Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Firms 6.3.
Respond on Firms 6.3
Firms 6.4
Firms 6.4: anyone acting for a client on a matter tells the client all material information they know of, unless the law forbids it (for example tipping off), the client has agreed in writing, it risks serious injury, or it comes from a privileged document disclosed by mistake.
Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.
- Applies to
- The individual acting for the client: solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL
- Kinds of duty (provisional)
- inform
- Edition
- In effect from 11 April 2025
Integrated
When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.
Where it would apply in Signal & Line
Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.
- Issuing a letter to the client from the correspondence register, which records what went, when and how
- Recording that the client agreed in writing not to be told, or that telling them risks serious injury (a new record this would add)
- A suspicion report recorded on the matter, after which no tell-the-client prompt or draft appears (a new record this would add)
- Recording a privileged document disclosed by mistake, so no client disclosure is drafted from it (a new record this would add)
Why we apply it this way
Firms 6.4 binds whoever is acting for the client, so items go to that person, not the firm. Where the law forbids telling the client, as with tipping off (POCA s333A, TA s21D), the product must stay silent for each person on that matter. Legal Workflows records what was told and any exception relied on, and does not judge what is material.
How it works in Signal & Line
- Inform: the item asks for the client to be told something, and is discharged by recording what was sent, when and how. The assistant can prepare the communication as a draft for a person to approve.
- Binds the individual acting for the client, not the firm. The same tipping-off silence applies as for Code 6.4.
Authorities
Codes link to the schedule of authorities.
SRA guidance
K1–K9 (Information security and cybercrime - Case studies), M4 (Using or arranging Third-Party Litigation Funding)
As Code 6.1–6.5. Note that Firms 6.4 binds "any individual who is acting for a client".
Legislation
PC1 (Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 s328 (arrangements), s330 (failure to disclose: regulated sector), s333A (tipping off: regulated sector), s333D (permitted disclosures), s337 (protected disclosures), s342 (prejudicing an investigation)) (ss333A, 333D, 342); TA1 (Terrorism Act 2000 s21A (failure to disclose: regulated sector), s21B (protected disclosures), s21D (tipping off: regulated sector)) (s21D); CO2 (Civil Procedure Rules 1998 r31.20 (privileged document inspected by mistake)) (CPR 31.20)
As S6.4. The Firms text applies the duty to "any individual who is acting for a client", so the tipping-off suppression must work per individual and per matter.
Civil courts
As S6.1-S6.5
The same authorities apply.
What we are asking you
- Should the product ever prompt a disclosure to the client, or only record what was told and any exception relied on?
- After a suspicion report, is hiding the prompt from everyone on the matter workable when they may not know why?
Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Firms 6.4.
Respond on Firms 6.4
Firms 6.5
Firms 6.5: do not act against a current or former client while the firm holds their material confidential information, unless effective measures leave no real risk of disclosure or that client gives informed consent, in writing or evidenced in writing, to the firm acting and to the measures.
Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.
- Applies to
- Firm
- Kinds of duty (provisional)
- confidentiality, conflict, consent
- Edition
- In effect from 11 April 2025
Integrated (already live)
Legal Workflows already acts on this duty today. It will add the paragraph's own page, and cite the paragraph on what the product already does.
Where it would apply in Signal & Line
Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.
- A conflict check finding a current or former client on the other side
- Recording the outcome "Act with consent and measures", with the measures and the client's consent
- Setting up an information barrier, acknowledging its caution, and screening members
- Reviewing a barrier on its review date, or ending it with a reason
Why we apply it this way
Firms 6.5 lets the firm act against a client whose confidential information it holds only with effective measures, or that client's informed consent given or evidenced in writing. Legal Workflows records both on the decision, and a barrier keeps screened members out of the matter. The caution and review date reflect that measures fail when they are not kept up.
How it works in Signal & Line
- Existing product behaviour: consent_6_5 outcome and information barriers (lib/matters/barriers.ts).
- Confidentiality: matter membership and information barriers enforce the boundary. The item records the barrier, or the consent, that allows the work to continue.
- Conflict: the item is tied to the conflict search and its recorded decision. The decision outcome (for example acting under an exception) is the evidence, and an own-interest conflict cannot be waived.
- Consent: the item records the client’s informed consent before the work goes ahead: who gave it, when, in what form, and the document version that evidences it.
Authorities
Codes link to the schedule of authorities.
SRA guidance
K1–K9 (Information security and cybercrime - Case studies), M4 (Using or arranging Third-Party Litigation Funding)
As Code 6.1–6.5. Note that Firms 6.4 binds "any individual who is acting for a client".
Civil courts
As S6.1-S6.5
The same authorities apply.
What we are asking you
- The outcome asks for measures and a client's consent together, though Firms 6.5 allows either. Is that stricter rule right?
- How often should a barrier be reviewed, and by whom?
Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Firms 6.5.
Respond on Firms 6.5
Firms 7.1
Firms 7.1: solicitors' code 2.1 to 2.7, 5.1 to 5.3 and 8.1 to 8.11 apply to the firm as they apply to an individual.
Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.
- Applies to
- Firm
- Kinds of duty (provisional)
- none
- Edition
- In effect from 11 April 2025
Linked (applies other paragraphs)
Firms 7.1 applies parts of the solicitors' code to the firm. A compliance item cites both paragraphs.
Where it would apply in Signal & Line
Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.
- No activity raises Firms 7.1 on its own
- An item under Code 2.1 to 2.7, 5.1 to 5.3 or 8.1 to 8.11 on a firm's matter also cites the matching limb of 7.1
- A phase reaching its estimate threshold engages Code 8.7, so the item cites Firms 7.1(c) as well
Why we apply it this way
Firms 7.1 applies these individual duties to the firm, so a separate firm item would only repeat them. Citing both paragraphs on one item shows that the firm, not only the fee earner, answers for it. The SRA's guidance on unsolicited approaches confirms that 7.1(c) reaches the firm (P9).
How it works in Signal & Line
- 7.1(a) applies Code 2.1 to 2.7, 7.1(b) applies 5.1 to 5.3, and 7.1(c) applies 8.1 to 8.11. A firm-layer item cites both, for example “Code for Firms 7.1(c), applying Code for Solicitors 8.7”.
Authorities
Codes link to the schedule of authorities.
SRA guidance
P1 (Identifying your client), P8 (Marketing your services to members of the public), P9 (Unsolicited approaches (advertising) to members of the public), R1–R5 (Separate Business), C5 (Conduct in disputes), C6 (Strategic Lawsuits against Public Participation (SLAPPs))
Unsolicited approaches guidance confirms 7.1(c) applies 8.9 to firms. Identifying-client guidance points firms to firm-level controls.
Legislation
Via S2.1 to S2.7, S5.1 to S5.3 and S8.1 to S8.11
Inherits the legislation mapped to those rows, including LASPO s56, DMCC ss291 and 308, PECR and the MLRs.
What we are asking you
- Is one item citing both paragraphs clearer than a separate item for the firm?
- Does citing Firms 7.1 add anything for a sole practitioner, where the firm and the individual are in practice one?
Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Firms 7.1.
Respond on Firms 7.1
Firms 8.1
Firms 8.1: managers are responsible for the firm's compliance, jointly and severally where they share management.
Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.
- Applies to
- Firm manager
- Kinds of duty (provisional)
- supervise
- Edition
- In effect from 11 April 2025
Integrated
When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.
Where it would apply in Signal & Line
Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.
- Granting the manager compliance role on the Compliance roles tab
- A firm-level supervise item routed to the managers for sign-off
- Waiving a close-checklist item, which only a manager or an org admin may do
Why we apply it this way
Managers answer for the firm's compliance where they had responsibility, or should have known and stepped in. SDT 12703 concerned a sole manager who did not know who worked under the firm's name. So firm-level items go to managers for sign-off, and the product records who signed, not how responsibility is shared between them.
How it works in Signal & Line
- Supervise: the item is routed to the supervisor or manager responsible, and is discharged by their sign-off, not by the fee earner.
- Managers are responsible jointly and severally where they share management; supervise items for the firm route to them.
Authorities
Codes link to the schedule of authorities.
SRA guidance
G1 (Misuse of AI), E7 (Topic guide: Anti-money laundering), M1 (Money missing from client account), K8 (Mergers, acquisitions and sales of law firms)
Managers are liable where they had responsibility or should have known and intervened.
Legislation
A8 (LSA 2007 s176: duty of regulated persons to comply with the regulator's arrangements) (LSA s176); A16 (LSA 2007 s90 (duties of non-authorised managers, employees and owners of licensed bodies), s91 (Head of Legal Practice), s92 (Head of Finance and Administration)) (LSA s90); ML1 (Money Laundering, Terrorist Financing and Transfer of Funds (Information on the Payer) Regulations 2017: reg 7 (supervisors), 12 (independent legal professional), 18 (risk assessment), 19 (policies and controls), 21 (internal controls and nominated officer), 24 (training), 26 (approval of beneficial owners, officers and managers), 27 and 28 (customer due diligence), 40 (record-keeping)) (MLR reg 26)
Managers of licensed bodies have statutory duties (s90 for non-authorised managers). Under MLR reg 26, beneficial owners, officers and managers of in-scope firms must be approved by the supervisor.
Civil courts
A6 James; A7 Fuglers
Managers and compliance officers are personally answerable.
Tribunal or SRA decision
SDT 12703 (above). Paragraphs found or considered: Firms 2.1(a), 4.4, 8.1.
The sole manager had no control of the bank accounts, did not know who worked under the firm's name, and lacked AML risk assessment and training.
What we are asking you
- The product's manager role runs review and sign-off. Is it a fair stand-in for the firm's managers, or should each manager be recorded?
- Where managers share responsibility, should every manager see firm-level items, or only the one assigned?
Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Firms 8.1.
Respond on Firms 8.1
Firms 9.1
Firms 9.1: the COLP takes all reasonable steps to secure compliance with the terms of the firm's authorisation and the SRA's rules by the firm, its managers, staff and interest holders, to stop others causing a breach, and to make sure serious breaches and matters for investigation reach the SRA promptly.
Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.
- Applies to
- COLP (whoever performs the role in practice)
- Kinds of duty (provisional)
- supervise, report, record
- Edition
- In effect from 11 April 2025
Integrated
When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.
Where it would apply in Signal & Line
Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.
- Granting the COLP compliance role to whoever does the job, including before SRA approval
- A report item on a matter routed to the COLP for the decision whether to report
- Recording the firm's authorisation status and conditions for the COLP to track (a new record this would add)
Why we apply it this way
The COLP answers for compliance systems, including when new technology and AI are used, and should keep a record of all failures (F1, G1). SDT 12703 tied the role to whoever did it in practice, and SRA decision 528838 and SDT 12852 make authorisation status and conditions COLP items. For licensed bodies LSA s91 reaches every failure, not only serious ones, and the item notes it.
How it works in Signal & Line
- Supervise: the item is routed to the supervisor or manager responsible, and is discharged by their sign-off, not by the fee earner.
- Report: the item prompts a recorded decision on whether to notify the SRA (or another body), and records the notification if one is made. The product never sends a report itself.
- Record: the item is discharged only with evidence attached (a document version, a note or a decision). Evidence is append-only and audited, so it can be shown to the SRA under Code 7.2 and Firms 2.2.
- COLP items route to whoever performs the role in practice, including before SRA approval (SDT 12703). For licensed bodies, LSA 2007 s91 adds a wider duty that is not limited to serious breaches; the item notes it.
- The SRA’s Misuse of AI warning notice (17 August 2026) applies here. The paragraph's page links it, and the assistant verifies every quotation and keeps a person in the loop on every draft.
Authorities
Codes link to the schedule of authorities.
SRA guidance
F1 (Responsibilities of COLPs and COFAs), G1 (Misuse of AI), F10 (Compliance tips for solicitors regarding the use of AI and technology), E7 (Topic guide: Anti-money laundering), S3 (Effective supervision), A1 (Reporting and notification obligations)
Keep a record of all breaches. The COLP is responsible for compliance when new technology is introduced and for AI supervision. Clear reporting lines are needed.
Legislation
A3 (Administration of Justice Act 1985 s9: rules for recognised bodies and sole practices) (AJA s9(2)(fc)); A16 (LSA 2007 s90 (duties of non-authorised managers, employees and owners of licensed bodies), s91 (Head of Legal Practice), s92 (Head of Finance and Administration)) (LSA s91); ML1 (Money Laundering, Terrorist Financing and Transfer of Funds (Information on the Payer) Regulations 2017: reg 7 (supervisors), 12 (independent legal professional), 18 (risk assessment), 19 (policies and controls), 21 (internal controls and nominated officer), 24 (training), 26 (approval of beneficial owners, officers and managers), 27 and 28 (customer due diligence), 40 (record-keeping)) (reg 21(1)(a), the MLR compliance officer, a separate role)
The COLP role comes from AJA s9 rules for recognised bodies and from LSA s91 (HOLP) for licensed bodies. The HOLP must report "any failure" to comply with the licence terms (s91(1)(b)), not only serious ones (see C11). The MLR compliance officer and the MLRO are separate statutory roles that may or may not be the same person as the COLP.
Civil courts
A6 James (MacGregor)
Loyalty and concern for a colleague's health are no excuse (James [115], [119]-[120]).
Tribunal or SRA decision
SDT 12852 (above). Paragraphs found or considered: 7.10, Firms 9.1(a)-(b), 2.1(a)-(b), 3.2, 3.4.
The firm failed for two years to bring its websites into line with the Transparency Rules (prices, complaints information, SRA number and badge) and with conditions an adjudicator had imposed. Breaches were charged to the firm under Firms 2.1, 3.2 and 3.4, and to the COLP under Firms 9.1 and Code 7.10. The Tribunal applied the Dentons seriousness test and found it met. For Legal Workflows: website price publication is a Transparency Rules duty reached through Firms 2.1, not Code 8.8. A COLP item should exist for any authorisation conditions.
Tribunal or SRA decision
SDT 12703 (above). Paragraphs found or considered: Firms 9.2(a) alleged.
The respondent had applied for COLP and COFA approval, but the SRA had not decided it. The Tribunal found he acted as COLP and COFA "in practical and functional terms" and used that role in its governance findings (Firms 2.1(a), 4.4, 8.1). For Legal Workflows: compliance-officer items should attach to whoever performs the role, including a sole manager awaiting approval, not only to a person the SRA has approved.
Tribunal or SRA decision
SRA decision 528838 (SRA decision 528838, 4 Jun 2026). Paragraphs found or considered: Firms 2.1(a), 9.1(a), 5.2, P2.
A manager and COLP let the firm lose its authorisation and keep practising. For Legal Workflows: authorisation status is a COLP item.
Tribunal or SRA decision
SDT 12852 (above). Paragraphs found or considered: Firms 9.1(a)-(b).
What we are asking you
- Should the COLP see every report decision in the firm, or only those referred to them?
- Is authorisation status best kept as a firm record the COLP confirms at intervals, or raised only when it changes?
Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Firms 9.1.
Respond on Firms 9.1
Firms 9.2
Firms 9.2: the COFA takes all reasonable steps to keep the firm, its managers and staff compliant with the Accounts Rules, and to make sure serious breaches of those rules and matters for investigation reach the SRA promptly.
Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.
- Applies to
- COFA (whoever performs the role in practice)
- Kinds of duty (provisional)
- account, report, record
- Edition
- In effect from 11 April 2025
Integrated
When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.
Where it would apply in Signal & Line
Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.
- Granting the COFA compliance role to whoever does the job
- A client-money shortage or missed reconciliation recorded, routed to the COFA (a new record this would add)
- Recording the COFA's decision whether to report, with the evidence
Why we apply it this way
The COFA is the named role on client-account shortages and should keep a record of all failures (F1, M1). SDT 12716 makes missed reconciliations and unreplaced shortages COFA items as well as Accounts Rules items. For licensed bodies LSA s92 requires every failure to follow the accounts rules to be reported, and the item notes it.
How it works in Signal & Line
- Account: the item is tied to billing and client-money events (benefits received, shortages, client money held). Finance items are routed to the COFA where the firm has one.
- Report: the item prompts a recorded decision on whether to notify the SRA (or another body), and records the notification if one is made. The product never sends a report itself.
- Record: the item is discharged only with evidence attached (a document version, a note or a decision). Evidence is append-only and audited, so it can be shown to the SRA under Code 7.2 and Firms 2.2.
- COFA items route to whoever performs the role in practice. For licensed bodies, LSA 2007 s92 requires any accounts-rules breach to be reported; the item notes it.
Authorities
Codes link to the schedule of authorities.
SRA guidance
F1 (Responsibilities of COLPs and COFAs), M1 (Money missing from client account)
Keep a record of all breaches. The COFA is the named role on client-account shortages.
Legislation
A3 (Administration of Justice Act 1985 s9: rules for recognised bodies and sole practices); A16 (LSA 2007 s90 (duties of non-authorised managers, employees and owners of licensed bodies), s91 (Head of Legal Practice), s92 (Head of Finance and Administration)) (LSA s92); A2 (SA 1974 s2 (training regulations), s13 (practising certificate appeals), s28 (regulations on admission, the roll and practising certificates), s32 (accounts rules), s33A (inspection of practice bank accounts), s34 (accountants' reports), s37 (indemnity rules)) (SA ss32, 34)
The COFA comes from AJA s9 rules, and the HOFA from LSA s92. LSA s92(2) requires a report of any breach of the accounts rules to the licensing authority, not only a serious breach (see C11).
Civil courts
A6 James; A7 Fuglers
Managers and compliance officers are personally answerable.
Tribunal or SRA decision
SDT 12716 (above). Paragraphs found or considered: Firms 9.2, Code 4.2, P2, P5, P7, Accounts Rules 6.1, 8.1, 8.3.
As sole practitioner and COFA, he failed to take reasonable steps to make staff comply with the Accounts Rules: a client account shortage, no five-weekly reconciliations, no cash book. That was found to breach 9.2 and, with the other failures, P5. For Legal Workflows: missed reconciliations and unreplaced shortages are COFA (9.2) items as well as Accounts Rules items.
Tribunal or SRA decision
SDT 12703 (above). Paragraphs found or considered: Firms 9.2(a) alleged.
The respondent had applied for COLP and COFA approval, but the SRA had not decided it. The Tribunal found he acted as COLP and COFA "in practical and functional terms" and used that role in its governance findings (Firms 2.1(a), 4.4, 8.1). For Legal Workflows: compliance-officer items should attach to whoever performs the role, including a sole manager awaiting approval, not only to a person the SRA has approved.
What we are asking you
- Until the Accounts Rules are in the product, should a missed reconciliation sit on a matter or with the firm?
- Is routing every finance item to the COFA right where the COFA is also the only manager?
Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Firms 9.2.
Respond on Firms 9.2