Skip to main content

Consultation

Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs, RFLs and RSLs

This Code applies to solicitors, RELs, RFLs and RSLs, except 5.6, which applies to solicitors and RELs only. Paragraphs 8.1 to 8.11 apply only to services offered to the public or a section of it.

55 paragraphs. Each has our summary, a link to the SRA's text, where Signal & Line would apply it and why, the authorities behind that reading, and what we are asking you. Responses are anonymous, and due by 2 February 2027.

Code 1.1

Code 1.1: do not let personal views lead you to discriminate unfairly in your professional relationships or the service you give.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Linked

For reference. The paragraph has its own page, with our summary, a link to the SRA's text and its authorities, but nothing on a matter raises it.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • No activity raises Code 1.1 on its own
  • Cited alongside Code 3.4 when a client's needs or a reasonable adjustment is recorded

Why we apply it this way

Code 1.1 is about personal views leading to unfair treatment, which turns on why a person acted, not on anything the record shows (G7). The Equality Act sets the minimum but the Code reaches further (EQ1, EQ4), so a label drawn from an event would mislead either way. Legal Workflows records clients' needs and adjustments under Code 3.4 instead, and keeps this paragraph as reference.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Do not label every 1.1 matter as an Equality Act breach: the Code also catches unfair treatment the Act does not.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

G7 (Complying with Principle 6 - encouraging equality, diversity and inclusion), E6 (Topic guide: Social media offensive communications), G10 (Offensive communications), S4 (Terminating a retainer)

The paragraph is about unfair discrimination caused by letting personal views affect professional relationships or how services are delivered. It includes reasonable adjustments, and terminating a retainer for discriminatory reasons.

Legislation

EQ1 (Equality Act 2010 s4 (protected characteristics)), EQ2 (EA 2010 s20 (duty to make adjustments)), EQ4 (EA 2010 s29 (provision of services)) (EA s29 services)

Unlawful discrimination against clients is defined by the Equality Act, which sets the minimum. The Code also catches unfair treatment that the Act does not. Do not label every 1.1 item as an Equality Act breach.

Civil courts

A31 Husain (on P6)

Indirect only.

What we are asking you

  1. Should ending a retainer list Code 1.1 as a candidate, given the guidance on discriminatory termination (S4)?
  2. Is it right never to label an item as an Equality Act matter, since Code 1.1 reaches further than the Act?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 1.1.

Respond on Code 1.1
Your view of Code 1.1

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 1.2

Code 1.2: do not use your position to gain an unfair advantage over a client or anyone else.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Linked

For reference. The paragraph has its own page, with our summary, a link to the SRA's text and its authorities, but nothing on a matter raises it.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • No activity raises Code 1.2 on its own
  • Its page links the SLAPP provisions where a matter is reputation or defamation work with an economic-crime element

Why we apply it this way

Unfair advantage is an evaluative test of the power balance in context (Hurst [57]). A difference in job title does not establish it (SDT 12660), and the recipient's resources matter (SDT 12539), so no single event can show it. Legal Workflows keeps Code 1.2 as reference and links the statutory SLAPP rules (EC2) where the type of matter makes them relevant.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Where a matter is flagged as reputation or defamation work with an economic-crime element, the page links ECCTA 2023 ss194 and 195 (SLAPPs).

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

C4 (Use of non disclosure agreements (NDAs)), C5 (Conduct in disputes), C6 (Strategic Lawsuits against Public Participation (SLAPPs)), C8 (Supporting your client with interviews during external investigations), C10 (High-volume financial service claims), C11 (Claims management activity), C12 ('No win, no fee' and other fee arrangements in high-volume consumer claims), G12 (Investment schemes), G13 (Tax avoidance your duties), R1 (Referral fees LASPO and SRA Principles)

"Others" includes opponents, witnesses and unrepresented parties. Examples of unfair advantage:

  • oppressive deadlines
  • intimidating letters
  • unenforceable NDA clauses
  • unjustifiable success fees or charges
  • power imbalance in employee interviews

Legislation

EC2 (ECCTA ss194, 195); CN6 (DMCC 2024 s225 (unfair commercial practices prohibited), s226 (misleading actions), s227 (misleading omissions), s229 (professional diligence), Sch 20 (practices always unfair: para 1 code of conduct signatory claims; para 4 false approval or authorisation claims; para 13 fake reviews; para 28 persistent unwanted solicitations)) (DMCC s229 professional diligence; Sch 20 para 28); CO3 (Defamation Act 2013 s1 (serious harm)) (Defamation Act s1)

A SLAPP-style claim or threat is the main statutory example of taking unfair advantage of a non-client. When a matter is flagged as reputation or defamation work with an economic crime element, the product can link to ss194 and 195.

Civil courts

A28 Hurst; A3 Beckwith

Unfair advantage is a context-specific, evaluative test of a power imbalance, for example with an unrepresented journalist (Hurst [57]). Integrity includes not taking unfair advantage of others in a professional or personal capacity (Beckwith [36]).

Tribunal or SRA decision

Hurst v SRA (above), at [57]. Paragraphs found or considered: 1.2.

Abuse of position concerns the imbalance of power between the solicitor and the other person, and whether unfair advantage was taken. The test is context-specific and evaluative.

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12660 (above). Paragraphs found or considered: 1.2.

An associate and a paralegal in different teams, with no authority over each other and no practical power imbalance, were peers: 1.2 was not breached even though P2 and P5 were. For Legal Workflows: a difference in job title alone does not establish 1.2.

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12833 (SDT 12833-2025; hearing 7-8 May 2026; published 15 Jun 2026). Paragraphs found or considered: P1, P2, P5, 1.2.

A family solicitor repeatedly pressed a litigant in person for contact details she was entitled to withhold, then used a private investigator and passed her details to his client outside the court process. The Tribunal said a person can be firm and assertive and still be vulnerable, and that client instructions do not justify bypassing procedural protections. For Legal Workflows: treat contact with unrepresented opponents as a 1.2 risk point.

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12539 (SDT 12539-2024, 16 Sep 2024). Paragraphs found or considered: P2, P5, 1.2, 2.4.

Long, legalistic and aggressive letters before action to a GP practice (a lay recipient) threatening baseless claims breached 1.2 and 2.4. A similar letter to a government agency breached 2.4 and P2 but was not charged under 1.2. The Tribunal found the letters were a tactical device to draw the recipients into litigation for a campaign. For Legal Workflows: the recipient's resources matter for 1.2. Pre-action letters are "to others" for 2.4 (a SLAPP-type pattern).

What we are asking you

  1. Should adding an opponent with no firm acting for them list Code 1.2 as a candidate, as SDT 12833 suggests?
  2. Is linking the SLAPP provisions only on reputation or defamation work with an economic-crime element too narrow?
  3. Should a letter to a lay recipient sent from a matter be a review point for Code 1.2 (SDT 12539)?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 1.2.

Respond on Code 1.2
Your view of Code 1.2

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 1.3

Code 1.3: carry out an undertaking you give, by the agreed date or otherwise within a reasonable time.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL
Kinds of duty (provisional)
record
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Recording an undertaking on a matter, with its wording, who gave it, in what capacity and its due date (a new record this would add)
  • Exchanging under a standard formula that carries an implied undertaking (a prompt this would add)
  • An undertaking's due date passing while it is still open
  • Closing a matter, through the close checklist, with an undertaking still open (a check this would add)

Why we apply it this way

An undertaking binds whether or not a court can enforce it, and survives the firm closing (C1, M6, Harcus Sinclair). Lateness alone can engage the paragraph (SDT 12681), and implied undertakings count (SDT 12691). So Legal Workflows keeps a record item that holds the wording, giver, capacity and due date, and stays open until a person attaches evidence of discharge.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Record: the item is discharged only with evidence attached (a document version, a note or a decision). Evidence is append-only and audited, so it can be shown to the SRA under Code 7.2 and Firms 2.2.
  • When an undertaking is recorded on a matter, the item stores its wording and due date as evidence and keeps the item open until it is discharged. Undertakings are also enforceable by the court (Solicitors Act 1974 s50).

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

C1 (Undertakings given by, or on behalf of, incorporated practices), M6 (Closing down your practice)

An undertaking binds even where the court cannot enforce it, as with an incorporated practice. It survives firm closure. The SRA documents read here set no register requirement; that practice comes from Law Society guidance (not verified).

Legislation

A19 (SA 1974 s50: solicitors are officers of the Senior Courts, and the courts keep their historic jurisdiction over solicitors) (SA 1974 s50)

Undertakings are enforceable through the court's supervisory jurisdiction over its officers, separately from the SRA. The "record" item should keep the undertaking's wording and due date as evidence.

Civil courts

A12 Harcus Sinclair (and Udall via A12)

Breaching an undertaking is prima facie misconduct (via Udall). An undertaking need not be contractual or enforceable. Whether it is a "solicitor's undertaking" depends on the capacity in which it was given, and an LLP's undertaking is not currently enforceable through the court's summary jurisdiction (Harcus [101]-[105], [118]-[124], [142]-[145]). The product should record who gave the undertaking, in what capacity, for which client and matter, and the due date.

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12691 (SDT 12691-2024, 23 Jun 2025). Paragraphs found or considered: P2, P5, 1.3, 1.4, 7.5.

Exchanging under Law Society Formula B carries an implicit undertaking to send the deposit. A solicitor of integrity gives only undertakings he knows he can perform, and the client's failure to put him in funds was no defence. For Legal Workflows: undertakings include those implied by standard formulae; record them at exchange, not only the express ones.

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12681 (SDT 12681-2024, 30 May 2025). Paragraphs found or considered: P2, P5, 1.3, 7.3, 7.4.

A costs undertaking left undischarged for about a year was a breach without any lack of integrity. Undertakings were described as a solemn step and the basis of trust between solicitors. For Legal Workflows: the 1.3 "record" type should carry a due date and escalate on delay; lateness alone is a breach.

What we are asking you

  1. Should the product prompt for implied undertakings at exchange, or is recording express ones enough?
  2. Is the due date the right point to escalate, or should a reminder come earlier?
  3. Who should be able to mark an undertaking discharged: the person who gave it, their supervisor, or either?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 1.3.

Respond on Code 1.3
Your view of Code 1.3

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 1.4

Code 1.4: do not mislead or try to mislead anyone, including clients and the court, and do not allow or join in others, your client included, doing so, by act or omission.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Linked

For reference. The paragraph has its own page, with our summary, a link to the SRA's text and its authorities, but nothing on a matter raises it.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • No activity raises Code 1.4 on its own
  • Listed as a candidate on another paragraph's item, for example a Code 3.5 item on an assistant draft

Why we apply it this way

Whether someone misled needs a person's assessment: Hurst [58] looks for a culpable state of mind, while SDT 12822 found misleading by omission without intent. Because the authorities pull apart, Legal Workflows lists Code 1.4 as a candidate and decides nothing. It keeps 1.4 apart from supervision under 3.5, because complicity and supervision are separate allegations needing separate evidence (SDT 12679).

How it works in Signal & Line

  • No single event raises 1.4, but it is listed as a candidate wherever an event may engage it alongside another paragraph (for example 3.5).
  • The SRA’s Misuse of AI warning notice (17 August 2026) applies here. The paragraph's page links it, and the assistant verifies every quotation and keeps a person in the loop on every draft.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

G1 (Misuse of AI), G4 (Acting with honesty), C5 (Conduct in disputes), C6 (Strategic Lawsuits against Public Participation (SLAPPs)), C9 (Immigration work), G13 (Tax avoidance your duties), A4 (Internal investigations)

Includes being complicit in a client's misleading act. Misleading correspondence labels (C6) are caught. Unverified AI output put before others is caught (G1).

Legislation

CR4 (Fraud Act 2006 s2 (false representation), s3 (failing to disclose information)) (Fraud Act ss2, 3); CN6 (DMCC 2024 s225 (unfair commercial practices prohibited), s226 (misleading actions), s227 (misleading omissions), s229 (professional diligence), Sch 20 (practices always unfair: para 1 code of conduct signatory claims; para 4 false approval or authorisation claims; para 13 fake reviews; para 28 persistent unwanted solicitations)) (DMCC s226, s227)

A misleading statement or omission to a consumer can also be an unfair commercial practice, and a dishonest one can be fraud. These are overlaps only; 1.4 covers more.

Civil courts

A10 Ayinde/Al-Haroun; A11 Brett; A29 Grunhut; A32 Mariaddan; A28 Hurst

1.4 also covers misleading through the client's material: a lawyer may not rely on a lay client's research (Al-Haroun [79], [81]). It covers the solicitor's own employer, insurer and opponents, not only the court (Grunhut; Mariaddan). It needs some culpable state of mind (Hurst [58]). Recklessness is enough (Brett [76]).

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12822 (above). Paragraphs found or considered: 1.4.

Answers to the court that were literally true but left out a material relationship misled the court by omission. Dishonesty and recklessness were both rejected, yet 1.4 was breached. For Legal Workflows: 1.4 covers omissions and does not need intent in SDT practice (but see the Hurst tension below).

Tribunal or SRA decision

Hurst v SRA (above), at [58]. Paragraphs found or considered: 1.4.

The court said misleading requires an inaccuracy and some culpable state of mind about producing a false understanding. This sits uneasily with SDT 12822 and SDT 12904. For Legal Workflows: treat 1.4 as needing a person's assessment, not an automatic outcome.

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12552 (above). Paragraphs found or considered: 1.4.

Attempting to mislead a client through a junior colleague breached 1.4 although the email was never sent.

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12679 (SDT 12679-2024, 17 Dec 2025; second respondent's appeal pending). Paragraphs found or considered: P2, P4, P5, 1.4.

A paralegal who sent misleading emails said she acted on her supervisor's direction. That did not stop the order against her. The supervising solicitor admitted serious failings in supervision and document checking, but she was acquitted because the case was pleaded as her causing or allowing the email, and the evidence did not prove it. For Legal Workflows: a supervisor's instruction does not protect the person who sends a misleading message. Supervision failure (3.5) and complicity (1.4) are separate allegations and need separate evidence. Unadmitted staff are reached by section 43 orders, not by the Code.

Tribunal or SRA decision

Grunhut (above); SDT 12814 (SDT 12814-2025, 29 Jan 2026). Paragraphs found or considered: 1.4.

1.4 "others" covered one's own employer (Grunhut) and, in SDT 12814, the Chief Coroner's Office: a solicitor serving as a senior coroner minimised police allegations against him. For Legal Workflows: 1.4 applies in non-client relationships and in non-practising roles.

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12579 (above). Paragraphs found or considered: 1.4.

Not passing adverse counsel's opinion to the ATE insurer was charged as misleading by omission.

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12884 (above). Paragraphs found or considered: 1.4, 2.4.

Non-existent cases and incorrect propositions from generative AI breached 1.4. Citing real cases for propositions they do not support breached 2.4. Typographical errors in citations were not misconduct. The issue is the lawyer's duty to verify, whatever the source: AI, a search engine, or a colleague's draft. For Legal Workflows: citation-verification events map to 1.4 and 2.4 (and P1, P2, P5), not mainly 2.7.

What we are asking you

  1. Is listing Code 1.4 as a candidate on supervision items the right approach, or does it risk implying a finding?
  2. Have we read the tension between Hurst [58] and SDT 12822 correctly for a product that never decides the point?
  3. Should statements to a person's own firm, insurer or employer be in scope for the candidate list (Grunhut)?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 1.4.

Respond on Code 1.4
Your view of Code 1.4

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 1.5

Code 1.5: treat colleagues fairly and with respect, and if you manage people, act on bullying, harassment or discrimination.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL
Kinds of duty (provisional)
supervise
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Parallel (self-certified)

Legal Workflows does not monitor this duty. The organisation certifies, with evidence it chooses, that it monitors the duty outside the platform, and certifies again at an interval it sets.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • An admin or the COLP certifying, with evidence it chooses, the organisation's fair-treatment, bullying and harassment policy (a certification this would add)
  • Certifying that the organisation takes all reasonable steps to prevent sexual harassment (Equality Act 2010 s40A)
  • Certifying again at the interval the organisation sets, or when the evidence it cited is replaced

Why we apply it this way

Treating colleagues fairly has no matter to hang on, and the incidents it covers belong in the firm's own process, not in a matter record (C2). Monitoring staff behaviour from inside the product would be intrusive. So the organisation certifies its policy and its steps to prevent sexual harassment, and no product event opens an item, even though the duty would otherwise be a supervise type.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Covered by the organisation’s certification of its fair-treatment, bullying, harassment and discrimination policy, including the Equality Act 2010 s40A duty to take all reasonable steps to prevent sexual harassment.
  • The provisional types (supervise) describe the duty; because the organisation certifies this duty, no product event opens an item for it.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

C2 (Workplace environment: risks of failing to protect and support colleagues), C3 (Workplace environment: risks of failing to protect and support colleagues - Case studies), G7 (Complying with Principle 6 - encouraging equality, diversity and inclusion), G9 (Sexual Misconduct), G10 (Offensive communications), E6 (Topic guide: Social media offensive communications), A4 (Internal investigations)

"Colleagues" is wide. Managers must challenge poor behaviour, informally or formally. The incident and the response should be recorded. Persistent behaviour or behaviour by senior staff may need reporting under 7.7.

Legislation

EQ3, EQ5, EQ6 (EA 2010 s40A (employer's duty to prevent sexual harassment)), EQ7

Employers have statutory duties on harassment. From 30 October 2026 these include all reasonable steps to prevent sexual harassment (s40A) and liability for third-party harassment (s40(1A) to (1C)). A "supervise" item for a manager should point to the firm's s40A prevention measures.

Civil courts

A3 Beckwith

Conduct towards a junior colleague engages the regulator only if, for example, seniority is abused (Beckwith [36]-[38], [44]-[45]).

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12731 (above). Paragraphs found or considered: 1.5.

Sexual advances towards junior colleagues were pleaded as failing to treat colleagues fairly and with respect, and as harassment.

What we are asking you

  1. Is self-certification right for Code 1.5, or would managers want a private place to record an incident and their response?
  2. Should the certification ask separately about third-party harassment, which employers are liable for from 30 October 2026?
  3. Should a manager's duty to act be certified once for the organisation, or for each team?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 1.5.

Respond on Code 1.5
Your view of Code 1.5

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 2.1

Code 2.1: do not misuse or interfere with evidence, or try to.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Linked

For reference. The paragraph has its own page, with our summary, a link to the SRA's text and its authorities, but nothing on a matter raises it.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • No activity raises Code 2.1 on its own
  • Shown as reference on its own page, which links the Misuse of AI warning notice

Why we apply it this way

Interfering with evidence is conduct the record cannot see: Legal Workflows records document versions, but it cannot tell a proper edit from an improper one. Tampering can also be a crime (CR1, PC1), which is a matter for a person and not an automatic label. So the paragraph stays as reference, with the duty to verify AI output linked (G1).

How it works in Signal & Line

  • The SRA’s Misuse of AI warning notice (17 August 2026) applies here. The paragraph's page links it, and the assistant verifies every quotation and keeps a person in the loop on every draft.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

C5 (Conduct in disputes), C9 (Immigration work), C11 (Claims management activity), G1 (Misuse of AI), E3 (A guide to the application of Principle 1)

Do not coach or fabricate (immigration, claims). Do not offer witnesses benefits that depend on their evidence. Do not alter experts' reports (C5).

Legislation

CR1 (Perjury Act 1911 s1 (perjury), s7 (aiders, abettors, suborners)) (Perjury Act s7); PC1 (Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 s328 (arrangements), s330 (failure to disclose: regulated sector), s333A (tipping off: regulated sector), s333D (permitted disclosures), s337 (protected disclosures), s342 (prejudicing an investigation)) (POCA s342, falsifying or destroying documents relevant to a money laundering investigation)

Tampering with evidence can be a crime. Perverting the course of justice is a common law offence and is not on legislation.gov.uk. No event-level item.

Civil courts

A13 Momodou)

Witness training or coaching about the evidence is not allowed. Familiarisation with the process is allowed, preferably supervised by lawyers and documented, with no material resembling the issues (Momodou [61]-[64]). There is no civil-court authority on 2.3 in this set.

What we are asking you

  1. Should replacing an expert's report with a new version list Code 2.1 as a candidate, given the guidance on altering reports (C5)?
  2. Is a reference page enough for this paragraph, or would litigators want a prompt at some point in the matter?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 2.1.

Respond on Code 2.1
Your view of Code 2.1

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 2.2

Code 2.2: do not try to shape what evidence says, including by creating false evidence or pressing a witness.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Linked

For reference. The paragraph has its own page, with our summary, a link to the SRA's text and its authorities, but nothing on a matter raises it.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • No activity raises Code 2.2 on its own
  • Shown as reference on its own page, which links the Misuse of AI warning notice

Why we apply it this way

The line between permitted familiarisation and coaching on the evidence depends on what is said in a session (Momodou), which the product does not see. Pressing a witness can be an offence, but CJPOA s51 covers only criminal proceedings and investigations (CR2), so Legal Workflows does not cite it on civil matters. The paragraph stays as reference rather than a flag on adding a witness to a matter.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • The SRA’s Misuse of AI warning notice (17 August 2026) applies here. The paragraph's page links it, and the assistant verifies every quotation and keeps a person in the loop on every draft.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

C5 (Conduct in disputes), C9 (Immigration work), C11 (Claims management activity), G1 (Misuse of AI), E3 (A guide to the application of Principle 1)

Do not coach or fabricate (immigration, claims). Do not offer witnesses benefits that depend on their evidence. Do not alter experts' reports (C5).

Legislation

CR1 (Perjury Act 1911 s1 (perjury), s7 (aiders, abettors, suborners)) (Perjury Act ss1, 7); CR2 (Criminal Justice and Public Order Act 1994 s51 (intimidation of witnesses, jurors and others)) (CJPOA s51)

Procuring false evidence (subornation) and intimidating witnesses are offences. CJPOA s51 covers only witnesses in proceedings for an offence or in a criminal investigation, so do not cite it for civil-only matters.

Civil courts

A13 Momodou)

Witness training or coaching about the evidence is not allowed. Familiarisation with the process is allowed, preferably supervised by lawyers and documented, with no material resembling the issues (Momodou [61]-[64]). There is no civil-court authority on 2.3 in this set.

What we are asking you

  1. Would firms want to record that a witness familiarisation session was supervised and documented, as Momodou suggests?
  2. Is it right not to cite CJPOA s51 on civil-only matters?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 2.2.

Respond on Code 2.2
Your view of Code 2.2

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 2.3

Code 2.3: offer a witness nothing that depends on what they say or how the case ends.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Linked

For reference. The paragraph has its own page, with our summary, a link to the SRA's text and its authorities, but nothing on a matter raises it.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • No activity raises Code 2.3 on its own
  • Shown as reference on its own page, which says no civil-court authority was found on benefits to witnesses

Why we apply it this way

Paying ordinary witness expenses is allowed, so a payment on its own cannot show a benefit that depends on the evidence or the outcome. No civil-court authority was found, and the Bribery Act is a doubtful fit without legal review (CR3). So Legal Workflows keeps the paragraph as reference and does not flag payments.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • The SRA’s Misuse of AI warning notice (17 August 2026) applies here. The paragraph's page links it, and the assistant verifies every quotation and keeps a person in the loop on every draft.
  • No civil-court authority was found on benefits to witnesses; the page says so.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

C5 (Conduct in disputes), C9 (Immigration work), C11 (Claims management activity), G1 (Misuse of AI), E3 (A guide to the application of Principle 1)

Do not coach or fabricate (immigration, claims). Do not offer witnesses benefits that depend on their evidence. Do not alter experts' reports (C5).

Legislation

No specific legislation verified. CR3 (Bribery Act 2010 s1 (bribing another person), s7 (failure of commercial organisations to prevent bribery)) (Bribery Act s1) is a doubtful fit.

The brief suggested the Bribery Act and Perjury Act. The Bribery Act turns on "improper performance of a relevant function", and I did not confirm that giving evidence is such a function, so the product should not cite it here without legal review. Paying ordinary witness expenses is not prohibited.

Civil courts

A13 Momodou)

Witness training or coaching about the evidence is not allowed. Familiarisation with the process is allowed, preferably supervised by lawyers and documented, with no material resembling the issues (Momodou [61]-[64]). There is no civil-court authority on 2.3 in this set.

What we are asking you

  1. Should recording a payment to a witness as a matter expense list Code 2.3 as a candidate, given that ordinary expenses are allowed?
  2. Are you aware of authority on benefits to witnesses that the page should cite?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 2.3.

Respond on Code 2.3
Your view of Code 2.3

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 2.4

Code 2.4: make only assertions, statements and submissions, to a court or to anyone else, that are properly arguable.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Linked

For reference. The paragraph has its own page, with our summary, a link to the SRA's text and its authorities, but nothing on a matter raises it.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • No activity raises Code 2.4 on its own
  • Listed beside Code 1.4 as a candidate where an assistant draft cites authority for a court or another recipient

Why we apply it this way

Properly arguable is a low bar: weak points are allowed and only unrecognisable ones fail (Hurst [59]). So a flag needs a review of the legal basis, not a keyword match, and Legal Workflows cannot make that call. It lists 2.4 beside 1.4 where citations are in issue, because fake authorities fail the test (Ayinde) and SDT 12884 pleaded the two together.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Covers assertions to anyone, not only the court. The page links the SLAPPs warning notice.
  • The SRA’s Misuse of AI warning notice (17 August 2026) applies here. The paragraph's page links it, and the assistant verifies every quotation and keeps a person in the loop on every draft.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

C5 (Conduct in disputes), C6 (Strategic Lawsuits against Public Participation (SLAPPs)), G1 (Misuse of AI), S4 (Terminating a retainer), C11 (Claims management activity)

Applies to submissions to "the court or others", so it covers pre-action letters, letters to journalists and opponents (SLAPPs). Every cited authority must be genuine and verifiable (AI). A client's insistence on an unarguable point can justify terminating the retainer.

Legislation

CO1 (Senior Courts Act 1981 s51(6), (7) and (7A) (wasted costs)) (SCA s51(6), (7)); EC2 (ECCTA ss194, 195); CO3 (Defamation Act 2013 s1 (serious harm)) (Defamation Act s1)

Advancing an unarguable case can lead to a wasted costs order. In SLAPP claims the court may strike out early. Defamation claims must meet the s1 serious harm threshold. These are useful context for an "is this claim properly arguable" check.

Civil courts

A28 Hurst; A30 Halborg; A10 Ayinde

2.4 applies to statements "to the court or others", including pre-action letters (Hurst [59]). "Properly arguable" is a low bar: weak but legally recognisable points are allowed, unrecognisable propositions are not (Hurst [59]). Fake authorities fail it (Ayinde [22], [29]). So does a pattern of meritless applications (Halborg).

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12539 (SDT 12539-2024, 16 Sep 2024). Paragraphs found or considered: P2, P5, 1.2, 2.4.

Long, legalistic and aggressive letters before action to a GP practice (a lay recipient) threatening baseless claims breached 1.2 and 2.4. A similar letter to a government agency breached 2.4 and P2 but was not charged under 1.2. The Tribunal found the letters were a tactical device to draw the recipients into litigation for a campaign. For Legal Workflows: the recipient's resources matter for 1.2. Pre-action letters are "to others" for 2.4 (a SLAPP-type pattern).

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12884 (above). Paragraphs found or considered: 1.4, 2.4.

Non-existent cases and incorrect propositions from generative AI breached 1.4. Citing real cases for propositions they do not support breached 2.4. Typographical errors in citations were not misconduct. The issue is the lawyer's duty to verify, whatever the source: AI, a search engine, or a colleague's draft. For Legal Workflows: citation-verification events map to 1.4 and 2.4 (and P1, P2, P5), not mainly 2.7.

Tribunal or SRA decision

Hurst v SRA (above), at [59] and [117]. Paragraphs found or considered: 2.4.

"Properly arguable" is a low threshold. Factual assertions need some evidential grounding. Legal propositions must be more than barely stateable, but need not be likely to win, and weak cases may properly be advanced, especially in pre-action correspondence. A "without prejudice" and confidentiality assertion with a recognisable legal basis was arguable, so not misconduct. The SDT had treated labelling a defamation email as a SLAPP-type abuse. For Legal Workflows: a 2.4 flag on pre-action or media correspondence needs a legal-basis review, not a keyword match on "without prejudice" or "not for publication".

Tribunal or SRA decision

Halborg (above). Paragraphs found or considered: 2.4, 2.6 (adm.).

Repeated applications certified totally without merit, leading to civil restraint orders, were inconsistent with 2.4. For Legal Workflows: a civil restraint order or a "totally without merit" certification is a strong 2.4 and 2.6 signal.

What we are asking you

  1. Should a civil restraint order or a totally-without-merit certification recorded on a matter list Code 2.4 and 2.6 as candidates (Halborg)?
  2. Should pre-action and media letters sent from a matter be in scope, since the paragraph reaches statements to others (Hurst [59])?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 2.4.

Respond on Code 2.4
Your view of Code 2.4

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 2.5

Code 2.5: do not put yourself in contempt of court, and obey court orders that bind you.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Linked

For reference. The paragraph has its own page, with our summary, a link to the SRA's text and its authorities, but nothing on a matter raises it.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • No activity raises Code 2.5 on its own
  • Cited alongside Code 3.2 when a key date for a court order passes with its task still open

Why we apply it this way

Contempt needs knowledge, and negligence is not enough (Ayinde [26]), so a missed date cannot show it. Whether an order binds a person and was disobeyed is a legal judgment. Legal Workflows therefore picks up missed court-order dates as a service review under Code 3.2, and keeps 2.5 as reference.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • The SRA’s Misuse of AI warning notice (17 August 2026) applies here. The paragraph's page links it, and the assistant verifies every quotation and keeps a person in the loop on every draft.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

G1 (Misuse of AI), E3 (A guide to the application of Principle 1)

Putting false material before the court can amount to contempt.

Legislation

CT1 (Contempt of Court Act 1981 s1 (strict liability rule), s2 (scope), s14 (committal limits)) (Contempt of Court Act ss1, 2, 14); A19 (SA 1974 s50: solicitors are officers of the Senior Courts, and the courts keep their historic jurisdiction over solicitors) (SA s50)

The Act covers strict-liability contempt by publication and committal limits. Disobeying an order is civil contempt under common law and rules of court. Because CCA s2 is about publications, a product item about press or social media statements on active proceedings can cite ss1 and 2.

Civil courts

A10 Ayinde

Knowingly putting false material before a court may be contempt. Negligence is not enough for contempt (Ayinde [26]).

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12822 (above). Paragraphs found or considered: 2.5, 2.6.

For Legal Workflows: court-order deadlines on a matter should feed 2.5 (and 3.5) items for the supervisor as well as the fee earner.

What we are asking you

  1. Should a court-order key date passing open a Code 2.5 item for the supervisor as well as the fee earner, as SDT 12822 suggests?
  2. Should public statements about active proceedings link the strict-liability rule (CT1)?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 2.5.

Respond on Code 2.5
Your view of Code 2.5

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 2.6

Code 2.6: do not waste the court's time.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Linked

For reference. The paragraph has its own page, with our summary, a link to the SRA's text and its authorities, but nothing on a matter raises it.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • No activity raises Code 2.6 on its own
  • Cited on its page beside Code 2.4, with which it is pleaded where applications are repeatedly without merit

Why we apply it this way

Wasting the court's time is evaluative, for example late and unparticularised urgent applications (Hamid). Legal Workflows cannot judge that from a record. Where the court makes a wasted costs order it must tell the regulator (CO1), so that event belongs to a reporting review rather than to this paragraph.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • The SRA’s Misuse of AI warning notice (17 August 2026) applies here. The paragraph's page links it, and the assistant verifies every quotation and keeps a person in the loop on every draft.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

G1 (Misuse of AI), C9 (Immigration work), C11 (Claims management activity)

False AI citations and dubious claims waste court time.

Legislation

CO1 (Senior Courts Act 1981 s51(6), (7) and (7A) (wasted costs)) (SCA s51(6), (7), (7A))

Wasted costs is the statutory consequence. s51(7A) requires the court to tell the approved regulator when it uses the power, so a wasted costs order should prompt a 7.7 or 7.8 reporting review (and Firms 3.9 or 3.10).

Civil courts

A9 Hamid; A30 Halborg; A10 Ayinde

Late, unparticularised urgent applications waste court time and lead to Hamid referrals (Hamid [7]-[10]).

Tribunal or SRA decision

Halborg (above). Paragraphs found or considered: 2.4, 2.6 (adm.).

Repeated applications certified totally without merit, leading to civil restraint orders, were inconsistent with 2.4. For Legal Workflows: a civil restraint order or a "totally without merit" certification is a strong 2.4 and 2.6 signal.

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12822 (above). Paragraphs found or considered: 2.5, 2.6.

For Legal Workflows: court-order deadlines on a matter should feed 2.5 (and 3.5) items for the supervisor as well as the fee earner.

What we are asking you

  1. Should recording a wasted costs order on a matter (a record this would add) open a reporting review under Code 7.7 or 7.8?
  2. Is a recorded civil restraint order a fair signal for Code 2.6 as well as 2.4 (Halborg)?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 2.6.

Respond on Code 2.6
Your view of Code 2.6

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 2.7

Code 2.7: tell the court about relevant authorities and procedural irregularities you know of that are likely to affect the outcome materially.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Linked

For reference. The paragraph has its own page, with our summary, a link to the SRA's text and its authorities, but nothing on a matter raises it.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • No activity raises Code 2.7 on its own
  • Shown as reference on its own page, with citation risk from AI routed to Code 1.4 and 2.4 instead

Why we apply it this way

The duty turns on what the lawyer knows and what is likely to affect the outcome materially, which the record cannot show. SDT 12884 pleaded false AI citations under 1.4 and 2.4, not 2.7, so Legal Workflows does not route that risk here. The page notes that a lawyer in doubt should seek senior or independent advice (Brett).

How it works in Signal & Line

  • The SRA’s Misuse of AI warning notice (17 August 2026) applies here. The paragraph's page links it, and the assistant verifies every quotation and keeps a person in the loop on every draft.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

C5 (Conduct in disputes), G1 (Misuse of AI)

Draw the court's attention to material authorities and irregularities. G1 reads this alongside the duty to verify citations.

Legislation

No specific legislation

Not statutory.

Civil courts

A9 Hamid; A10 Ayinde; A11 Brett

On without-notice applications the advocate must raise adverse matters as well as authority (Hamid [4]). A lawyer who doubts how to meet the duty to the court should seek senior or independent advice (Brett, Lord Thomas CJ [110], [113]).

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12884 (above). Paragraphs found or considered: (2.7 not pleaded).

Fictitious-citation conduct was pleaded under P1, P2, P5, 1.4 and 2.4, not 2.7. Ayinde v Haringey [2025] EWHC 1383 (Admin) was applied. For Legal Workflows: do not route AI-citation risk only to 2.7.

What we are asking you

  1. Should a without-notice application prompt a reminder of the duty to raise adverse matters (Hamid [4])?
  2. Is it right to route AI-citation risk to Code 1.4 and 2.4 rather than 2.7?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 2.7.

Respond on Code 2.7
Your view of Code 2.7

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 3.1

Code 3.1: act only on instructions from the client or someone authorised for them, check instructions you doubt, and protect the client's interests when you cannot get instructions.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL
Kinds of duty (provisional)
identify
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Opening a matter for a client chosen from the client register
  • Adding an instructing solicitor or professional client to a matter
  • Recording an attorney, deputy or appointee as a client's representative
  • Changing the client on an existing matter

Why we apply it this way

The duty is about who may instruct, so the item asks a person to confirm that and links what Legal Workflows already holds. Authority must be checked for third parties and attorneys (S1, MC1), and capacity is presumed, so the item records the authority relied on and never treats a vulnerability flag as incapacity. An identify item fits because the answer is a fact to confirm, while acting without instructions (SDT 12509) stays a judgment for a person.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Identify: the item asks the person acting to confirm who the client is, or who is authorised to instruct, and links the evidence already held (the client register entry, the instructing party on the matter).
  • Ties to the instructing party recorded on the matter. Where instructions are doubted, the item asks for the check to be recorded.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

S1 (Accepting instructions from vulnerable clients or third parties acting on their behalf), S2 (Access to and disclosure of an incapacitated person's will), C10 (High-volume financial service claims), C11 (Claims management activity), R1 (Referral fees LASPO and SRA Principles), R4 (Offering inducements to potential clients or clients)

Get signed authority for third-party instructions, check the scope of any LPA or deputyship, consider whether a litigation friend is needed, and do not let introducers drive instructions.

Legislation

MC1 (Mental Capacity Act 2005 s1 (principles), s2 (lack of capacity), s9 (lasting powers of attorney)) (MCA ss1, 2, 9); ML1 (Money Laundering, Terrorist Financing and Transfer of Funds (Information on the Payer) Regulations 2017: reg 7 (supervisors), 12 (independent legal professional), 18 (risk assessment), 19 (policies and controls), 21 (internal controls and nominated officer), 24 (training), 26 (approval of beneficial owners, officers and managers), 27 and 28 (customer due diligence), 40 (record-keeping)) (MLR regs 27, 28, where in scope)

MCA defines when a client lacks capacity and who has legal authority to give instructions instead (an LPA attorney or a deputy). Capacity is presumed (s1(2)), so the product must not treat a vulnerability flag as lack of capacity. The "identify" item should record the authority relied on.

Civil courts

A14 Minkin; A36 Aina Khan; A38 PGMBM

The retainer defines the task. Limits should be agreed and recorded in writing (Minkin [38]-[39]). Capacity is issue-specific and time-specific (Aina Khan [46]). Authority to instruct or dismiss a firm in group litigation depends on the terms actually conferred (PGMBM).

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12509 (SDT 12509-2023, 30 May 2025). Paragraphs found or considered: P2, P5, 3.1, 3.2, 7.11.

Failing to register an LPA breached 3.2. Altering the LPA and the client's cheque date without instructions breached 3.1.

What we are asking you

  1. Are these the right triggers, or should the item also open whenever instructions come from someone other than the client?
  2. Should the item ask for the scope of an LPA or deputyship, not only that one exists?
  3. In group or high-volume claims, is one confirmation per matter workable (PGMBM)?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 3.1.

Respond on Code 3.1
Your view of Code 3.1

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 3.2

Code 3.2: give a competent service and deliver it on time.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL
Kinds of duty (provisional)
review
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • A key date passing with its task still open
  • A matter going quiet for a period the organisation sets, the trigger its automation rules already use
  • Closing a matter, through the close checklist

Why we apply it this way

A one-off genuine error is not a conduct matter, but delay and unchecked work are (E4, Wingate). The duty is about service over the life of a matter, as the six-year estate in SRA decision 266676 shows. So Legal Workflows opens a review item for a person to look at timeliness rather than flagging single events as failures.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Review: the item opens a review task on the matter (for example of service, timeliness or risk). It is discharged by a person recording the review and its outcome.
  • A review item for service and timeliness. Event sources are to be confirmed in the list of events.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

E4 (Topic guide: Competence and Standard of Service), G1 (Misuse of AI), S3 (Effective supervision), S4 (Terminating a retainer), S6 (Failure to provide a proper standard of service or quality, particularly for vulnerable consumers- Case study), S8 (Advising on leasehold provisions including ground rent clauses), K4 (Dealing with conflicts of interest, independence and confidentiality for in-house solicitors), C9 (Immigration work), C10 (High-volume financial service claims)

A one-off genuine error is not actionable. Knowingly acting outside competence, unchecked AI output and time-pressured review are.

Legislation

CN1 (Consumer Rights Act 2015 s49 (reasonable care and skill), s50 (information binding), s52 (reasonable time)) (CRA ss49, 52); A7 (LSA 2007 s1: regulatory objectives (s1(1)) and professional principles (s1(3))) (LSA s1(3)(b))

For consumer clients, terms requiring reasonable care and skill and performance within a reasonable time are implied by statute, so delay or poor work also gives the client contractual remedies. Context only.

Civil courts

A14 Minkin; A15 Spire; A37 Iqbal; A2 Wingate

The duty covers advice "reasonably incidental" to the instructions, scaled to the client's sophistication (Minkin [38]; Spire [57]). Manifest incompetence is a conduct matter, ordinary negligence is not (Wingate [106]; Day [143]).

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12509 (SDT 12509-2023, 30 May 2025). Paragraphs found or considered: P2, P5, 3.1, 3.2, 7.11.

Failing to register an LPA breached 3.2. Altering the LPA and the client's cheque date without instructions breached 3.1.

Tribunal or SRA decision

SRA decision 266676 (SRA decision 266676, 29 Sep 2025; SDT refused her appeal 30 Jul 2026). Paragraphs found or considered: 3.2.

Six years to part-distribute an estate breached 3.2.

What we are asking you

  1. Are missed key dates and long inactivity the right signals for a service review?
  2. Should a review item open at a set interval on long matters, as well as on these events?
  3. Should the review record the agreed scope of the retainer, given that the duty covers advice reasonably incidental to it (Minkin)?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 3.2.

Respond on Code 3.2
Your view of Code 3.2

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 3.3

Code 3.3: keep your knowledge and skills current.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL
Kinds of duty (provisional)
record
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Attaching a training or CPD record as evidence when the item is discharged (a new record this would add)
  • Taking on work of a case type the organisation marks as needing current training (a new check this would add)

Why we apply it this way

Continuing competence runs as a cycle of reflecting, planning, recording and evaluating, and a record of learning is expected (S10, S11). Outside AML training under MLR reg 24 it is not statutory (ML1), so Legal Workflows asks for evidence rather than setting a standard of its own. A record item fits because the duty is shown by what the person kept, not by a review of the matter.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Record: the item is discharged only with evidence attached (a document version, a note or a decision). Evidence is append-only and audited, so it can be shown to the SRA under Code 7.2 and Firms 2.2.
  • Evidence of continuing competence (training or CPD record) is attached as the discharge. Changed from none to record by the authorities research.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

S10 (Understanding your continuing competence requirements), S11 (FAQs about continuing competence), E4 (Topic guide: Competence and Standard of Service), C9 (Immigration work), F4 (Money laundering and terrorist financing suspicious activity reports)

Continuing competence follows the cycle reflect, identify, plan, record, evaluate. A record of learning and development is expected, alongside the practising-certificate declaration.

Legislation

ML1 (Money Laundering, Terrorist Financing and Transfer of Funds (Information on the Payer) Regulations 2017: reg 7 (supervisors), 12 (independent legal professional), 18 (risk assessment), 19 (policies and controls), 21 (internal controls and nominated officer), 24 (training), 26 (approval of beneficial owners, officers and managers), 27 and 28 (customer due diligence), 40 (record-keeping)) (MLR reg 24, training, for in-scope firms)

Not statutory for most work. Where the MLRs apply, AML training is a legal duty of the firm.

Civil courts

A10 Ayinde

Lawyers using AI must check output against authoritative sources (Ayinde [7]-[8]).

What we are asking you

  1. Does Code 3.3 belong on a matter at all, or should it attach to the person, alongside the practising-certificate declaration?
  2. Would a learning record attached at discharge be useful, or would it duplicate what firms already keep?
  3. Should research with the assistant prompt a reminder to check output against authoritative sources (Ayinde)?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 3.3.

Respond on Code 3.3
Your view of Code 3.3

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 3.4

Code 3.4: take account of each client's attributes, needs and circumstances, including vulnerability and any doubt about capacity.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL
Kinds of duty (provisional)
identify
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Setting a vulnerable or safeguarding flag on a client
  • Recording a client's interpreter language or accessibility needs
  • Recording an attorney or deputy for a client
  • Recording a doubt about a client's capacity (a new record this would add)

Why we apply it this way

Vulnerability and incapacity are different, and capacity is specific to the issue and the time (Aina Khan). Capacity is presumed and a person must be helped to decide first (MC1), while adjustments for disabled clients are a legal duty (EQ2). So the item asks the person acting to record the client's needs and any doubt, and Legal Workflows never reads a flag as a finding about capacity.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Identify: the item asks the person acting to confirm who the client is, or who is authorised to instruct, and links the evidence already held (the client register entry, the instructing party on the matter).
  • Prompts the person acting to record client attributes, vulnerability and any doubt about capacity (R (Aina Khan Law) v Legal Ombudsman; Mental Capacity Act 2005).

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

S1 (Accepting instructions from vulnerable clients or third parties acting on their behalf), S4 (Terminating a retainer), S7 (Drafting and preparation of wills), R4 (Offering inducements to potential clients or clients), G13 (Tax avoidance your duties), G7 (Complying with Principle 6 - encouraging equality, diversity and inclusion)

Covers vulnerability, capacity and reasonable adjustments. Several older guidance pages cite this duty as "3.5" (S7, R4), so map those citations to 3.4.

Legislation

EQ2 (EA 2010 s20 (duty to make adjustments)), EQ4 (EA 2010 s29 (provision of services)) (reasonable adjustments in services); MC1 (Mental Capacity Act 2005 s1 (principles), s2 (lack of capacity), s9 (lasting powers of attorney)) (MCA s1(3), help to decide)

Reasonable adjustments for disabled clients are a legal duty, not only good practice. MCA s1(3) requires practicable steps to help a person decide before treating them as unable to.

Civil courts

A36 Aina Khan

The Code text quoted is "attributes, needs and circumstances" (Aina Khan [42]). Where there is doubt, the solicitor must satisfy themselves about capacity; vulnerability and incapacity are different things (Aina Khan [45]-[46]).

What we are asking you

  1. Should a vulnerability flag open the item, or only a recorded doubt about capacity?
  2. Since capacity is issue-specific, should a doubt be recorded on the matter rather than on the client record?
  3. Is anything missing for high-volume practice, where many clients need the same adjustments?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 3.4.

Respond on Code 3.4
Your view of Code 3.4

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 3.5

Code 3.5: when others work under your supervision or management, including on delegated or AI-assisted work, you stay accountable for that work and must supervise it effectively.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL
Kinds of duty (provisional)
supervise, record
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Saving an assistant-drafted note or letter to a matter
  • Running a workflow on a matter, which records the version that ran
  • Assigning a litigation task to a colleague who is not an authorised person (a status this would add)
  • A supervisor recording a review or spot check of delegated work (a new record this would add)

Why we apply it this way

The supervisor stays accountable for delegated and AI-assisted work and must direct and control it (Mazur, S3, G1). With no records, a hands-off style reads as abdication (SDT 12716), and deleting review evidence is itself a risk (SDT 12617). So the item goes to the supervisor, closes only on their sign-off with evidence attached, and keeps that evidence append-only.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Supervise: the item is routed to the supervisor or manager responsible, and is discharged by their sign-off, not by the fee earner.
  • Record: the item is discharged only with evidence attached (a document version, a note or a decision). Evidence is append-only and audited, so it can be shown to the SRA under Code 7.2 and Firms 2.2.
  • Delegated and AI-assisted work is supervised work. Assistant drafts and AI output need a supervisor’s recorded review (Mazur v CILEx; Effective supervision guidance, 12 June 2026; SDT 12716 treats missing supervision records as abdication).
  • The SRA’s Misuse of AI warning notice (17 August 2026) applies here. The paragraph's page links it, and the assistant verifies every quotation and keeps a person in the loop on every draft.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

S3 (Effective supervision), G1 (Misuse of AI), E4 (Topic guide: Competence and Standard of Service), C9 (Immigration work), S7 (Drafting and preparation of wills)

The supervisor stays accountable, including for delegated litigation tasks (March 2026 Court of Appeal) and for AI-assisted work. Supervision arrangements should be evidenced.

Legislation

A8 (LSA 2007 s176: duty of regulated persons to comply with the regulator's arrangements) (LSA s176(2)); EQ7 (s109)

No duty-specific statute. LSA s176 brings non-authorised staff within the duty to comply.

Civil courts

A35 Mazur (HC and CA); A10 Ayinde; A29 Grunhut

Unauthorised staff may carry out tasks within the conduct of litigation on behalf of an authorised individual, who keeps responsibility and must direct, supervise and control them (Mazur CA [25]-[27], [187]). Inadequate supervision does not excuse dishonesty (Grunhut [37], [57]).

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12716 (above). Paragraphs found or considered: 3.5.

Checklists, appraisals and documented reviews are not strictly mandatory, but they are evidence of objective standards. With no records, no spot checks and no billing review, a "hands-off" style amounted to abdication, not delegation, and was inconsistent with the COLP and COFA roles. For Legal Workflows: a supervision record (reviews, spot checks) is the evidence the Tribunal looks for. Absence of records will be read as absence of supervision.

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12617 (SDT 12617-2024, 19 May 2025). Paragraphs found or considered: P2, P4, P5, 3.5(a).

Deleting emails that showed her own review of a junior's drafting, after a client complained, breached 3.5(a): she did not remain accountable for work done through the junior. For Legal Workflows: supervision and review records should be immutable. Deletion from the matter record is itself a risk event.

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12703 (above). Paragraphs found or considered: Firms 2.1(a), 4.4, 8.1.

Unadmitted fee earners on high-risk conveyancing were unsupervised; staff were taken on without CVs or ID; a person subject to a section 43 order worked without SRA permission.

What we are asking you

  1. Should every saved assistant draft open a supervision item, or only drafts that leave the organisation?
  2. Would a sampling rate the organisation sets be workable for high-volume practice?
  3. Should the supervisor's sign-off record what was checked, such as citations and quotations?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 3.5.

Respond on Code 3.5
Your view of Code 3.5

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 3.6

Code 3.6: make sure the people you manage are competent and keep their knowledge current.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL
Kinds of duty (provisional)
supervise
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Adding a member to a matter team, which routes the item to the manager responsible for them
  • Assigning a task in a case type the organisation marks as needing current training (a new check this would add)
  • A managed member's training record falling out of date (a new record this would add)

Why we apply it this way

The duty sits with the manager, not the person managed, so the item goes to the manager and closes on their sign-off (S3, S12). Competence includes ethical and regulatory duties and, for in-scope work, AML training (ML1). Legal Workflows ties the item to points where someone takes on work on a matter, rather than auditing staff in general.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Supervise: the item is routed to the supervisor or manager responsible, and is discharged by their sign-off, not by the fee earner.
  • Routed to the manager responsible for the people concerned.
  • The SRA’s Misuse of AI warning notice (17 August 2026) applies here. The paragraph's page links it, and the assistant verifies every quotation and keeps a person in the loop on every draft.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

S3 (Effective supervision), G1 (Misuse of AI), S12 (The law firms role in making sure solicitors meet their continuing competence obligations), F4 (Money laundering and terrorist financing suspicious activity reports)

Make sure managed staff are competent and kept up to date, including on their ethical and regulatory duties.

Legislation

ML1 (Money Laundering, Terrorist Financing and Transfer of Funds (Information on the Payer) Regulations 2017: reg 7 (supervisors), 12 (independent legal professional), 18 (risk assessment), 19 (policies and controls), 21 (internal controls and nominated officer), 24 (training), 26 (approval of beneficial owners, officers and managers), 27 and 28 (customer due diligence), 40 (record-keeping)) (MLR reg 24)

As 3.3.

Civil courts

A35 Mazur (HC and CA); A10 Ayinde; A29 Grunhut

Unauthorised staff may carry out tasks within the conduct of litigation on behalf of an authorised individual, who keeps responsibility and must direct, supervise and control them (Mazur CA [25]-[27], [187]). Inadequate supervision does not excuse dishonesty (Grunhut [37], [57]).

What we are asking you

  1. Is joining a matter team the right point to ask a manager about competence, or would it come too often?
  2. Should AML training for in-scope work be its own prompt under MLR reg 24?
  3. For in-house teams, who should receive these items where there is no practising manager?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 3.6.

Respond on Code 3.6
Your view of Code 3.6

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 4.1

Code 4.1: account to the client for any financial benefit you get through their instructions, unless the client, told the material facts including the amount, agrees otherwise.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL
Kinds of duty (provisional)
account, consent, record
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Recording a commission or other benefit the firm receives through a client's matter, for example from a lender, broker or insurer (a new record this would add)
  • Recording what the client was told about the benefit, including the amount, and then their consent to the firm keeping it
  • Attaching the document that evidences the disclosure and the consent before the item can be closed

Why we apply it this way

A secret commission belongs to the client (FHR), and consent counts only after full disclosure of the material facts, usually including the amount (Hopcraft). So Legal Workflows asks for the disclosure first and the consent second, each with evidence, and routes the item to the COFA. Where the firm relies on the FSMA s327 exemption, keeping a commission without accounting also takes it outside that exemption, so the item says so.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Account: the item is tied to billing and client-money events (benefits received, shortages, client money held). Finance items are routed to the COFA where the firm has one.
  • Consent: the item records the client’s informed consent before the work goes ahead: who gave it, when, in what form, and the document version that evidences it.
  • Record: the item is discharged only with evidence attached (a document version, a note or a decision). Evidence is append-only and audited, so it can be shown to the SRA under Code 7.2 and Firms 2.2.
  • Consent counts only after the client has been told the material facts, including the amount (Hopcraft v Close Brothers [2025] UKSC 33). The item records the disclosure first, then the consent.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

M5 (SRA consumer credit), M6 (Closing down your practice), C11 (Claims management activity), R1 (Referral fees LASPO and SRA Principles), M4 (Using or arranging Third-Party Litigation Funding)

Account for third-party benefits such as commissions and credit-broker payments. Keep evidence of client consent to any retention.

Legislation

FS1 (Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 s21 (financial promotion), s327 (exemption for professional firms)) (FSMA s327(3))

Where the firm relies on the professional-firms exemption for incidental financial services, keeping any commission or reward from a third party without accounting to the client takes it outside the exemption. The "account" item for commissions should flag the FSMA consequence.

Civil courts

A17 FHR; A19 Hopcraft; A16 Hurstanger (superseded); A18 Wood (qualified); A27 Belsner

A secret commission is held on constructive trust for the principal (FHR). Partial disclosure never defeats the conflict: full disclosure of the material facts is needed for consent (Hopcraft [225]-[226], disapproving Hurstanger).

What we are asking you

  1. Is recording the disclosure and then the consent, as two steps in that order, how your firm handles commissions in practice?
  2. Should the item note the FSMA s327 consequence on every commission, or only where the firm relies on the exemption?
  3. Which third-party benefits arise in your practice that a record of commissions would miss?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 4.1.

Respond on Code 4.1
Your view of Code 4.1

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 4.2

Code 4.2: keep safe any money or assets entrusted to you.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL
Kinds of duty (provisional)
account, report
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Recording a shortage on money held for a client (a new record this would add, as the Accounts Rules are not yet in the product)
  • Recording the decision whether to tell the client and the SRA about the shortage, and any notification made
  • Recording a money laundering suspicion on a matter that holds client money, which pauses any automated money action (a new record this would add)

Why we apply it this way

Missing money must be replaced at once, and the client and the SRA told (M1). A shortage is therefore both an account event and a reporting event, and Legal Workflows asks for a recorded reporting decision rather than sending anything itself. Holding or moving money where criminal property is suspected risks the POCA s328 offence, so a recorded suspicion stops the product acting on the money.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Account: the item is tied to billing and client-money events (benefits received, shortages, client money held). Finance items are routed to the COFA where the firm has one.
  • Report: the item prompts a recorded decision on whether to notify the SRA (or another body), and records the notification if one is made. The product never sends a report itself.
  • A client-money shortage is also a reporting event, so the item asks for the reporting decision as well. The Accounts Rules themselves are not yet in the product (see Code 7.1).

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

M1 (Money missing from client account), M2 (Improper use of client account as a banking facility), M3 (Do I need to operate a client account?), M7 (Taking money for your firm's costs), K9 (Information security and cybercrime - Case studies), C7 (Sham litigation), G12 (Investment schemes)

Replace missing money at once and tell the client and the SRA. Do not provide a banking facility. Treat litigation-related money flows as a laundering risk.

Legislation

A2 (SA 1974 s2 (training regulations), s13 (practising certificate appeals), s28 (regulations on admission, the roll and practising certificates), s32 (accounts rules), s33A (inspection of practice bank accounts), s34 (accountants' reports), s37 (indemnity rules)) (SA ss32, 33A, 34); SA4 (SA 1974 s85 (bank accounts held under the accounts rules)) (s85); PC1 (Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 s328 (arrangements), s330 (failure to disclose: regulated sector), s333A (tipping off: regulated sector), s333D (permitted disclosures), s337 (protected disclosures), s342 (prejudicing an investigation)) (POCA s328)

Accounts rules and accountants' reports rest on statute. Holding or moving money where criminal property is suspected risks the s328 arrangements offence, so a money laundering suspicion on a matter with client money should suspend any automated "account" action.

Civil courts

A7 Fuglers; A20 Bellis; Twinsectra (via A20)

Using client account as a banking facility is objectionable in itself, even without a laundering purpose (Fuglers [36]). Whose money it is, and on what terms it is held, is decided objectively from words and conduct (Bellis [57]-[59]).

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12703 (above). Paragraphs found or considered: 4.2, Firms 5.2, Accounts Rules.

ID-check failures that let fraudsters take client money breached the safeguarding duty without any lack of integrity.

What we are asking you

  1. Is a recorded shortage the right trigger, or should a payment out to changed bank details also open a 4.2 item?
  2. Should a money laundering suspicion pause every money action on the matter, or only those a person has not yet approved?
  3. Until the Accounts Rules are in the product, would a 4.2 item without a client ledger be useful to your COFA?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 4.2.

Respond on Code 4.2
Your view of Code 4.2

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 4.3

Code 4.3: do not hold client money yourself, except where the rules permit or you work in an authorised or prescribed body.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL
Kinds of duty (provisional)
account
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Recording that a solicitor, rather than the organisation, holds money received for a client (a new record this would add)
  • Recording the rule the person relies on to hold it, for the COFA or another person to check

Why we apply it this way

Code 4.3 matters mainly where a solicitor works in-house or for an unregulated employer (M3, P10). Its exception turns on the SRA Authorisation of Individuals Regulations and the Accounts Rules, which are not yet in the product. So Legal Workflows raises the item only when someone records that an individual holds client money, and leaves whether the exception applies to a person.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Account: the item is tied to billing and client-money events (benefits received, shortages, client money held). Finance items are routed to the COFA where the firm has one.
  • Raised where the product records client money held by an individual. The Accounts Rules are out of scope for this edition.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

M3 (Do I need to operate a client account?), P10 (Unregulated organisations giving information to clients)

Relevant to in-house and unregulated-employer contexts. Mostly governed by the Authorisation of Individuals Regulations and the Accounts Rules.

Legislation

A2 (SA 1974 s2 (training regulations), s13 (practising certificate appeals), s28 (regulations on admission, the roll and practising certificates), s32 (accounts rules), s33A (inspection of practice bank accounts), s34 (accountants' reports), s37 (indemnity rules)) (SA s32)

The Code's own exception points to reg 10.2(b)(vii) of the SRA Authorisation of Individuals Regulations. That is SRA regulation, not legislation.

Civil courts

A7 Fuglers; A20 Bellis; Twinsectra (via A20)

Using client account as a banking facility is objectionable in itself, even without a laundering purpose (Fuglers [36]). Whose money it is, and on what terms it is held, is decided objectively from words and conduct (Bellis [57]-[59]).

What we are asking you

  1. Would your organisation ever record in a case management system that an individual holds client money, or is this handled elsewhere?
  2. For in-house and unregulated-employer practice, is an account item the right response, or should 4.3 be a reference page only?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 4.3.

Respond on Code 4.3
Your view of Code 4.3

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 5.1

Code 5.1: when clients are referred to or from you, or you share fees, tell clients about the interests and fee sharing involved, put fee sharing in writing, make no referral payments for clients in criminal proceedings, and take no client an introducer obtained improperly.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL
Kinds of duty (provisional)
inform, record
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Recording that a client was referred to or by another business, or that fees are shared on the matter (a new record this would add)
  • Issuing the client letter that sets out the referral interest and any fee, from the correspondence register
  • Attaching the written fee-sharing agreement and evidence of how the introducer obtained the client
  • Opening a personal injury or death claim with a referral recorded, which also raises the LASPO s56 ban

Why we apply it this way

Code 5.1 requires disclosure, not a ban, and disclosure means the material facts, usually including the amount (Hopcraft). The SRA expects a firm to be able to show that an introducer did not cold call (R1, C11). So Legal Workflows asks for the client to be told and the evidence kept, and raises the separate LASPO s56 ban only where the matter is a personal injury or death claim.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Inform: the item asks for the client to be told something, and is discharged by recording what was sent, when and how. The assistant can prepare the communication as a draft for a person to approve.
  • Record: the item is discharged only with evidence attached (a document version, a note or a decision). Evidence is append-only and audited, so it can be shown to the SRA under Code 7.2 and Firms 2.2.
  • On personal injury and death claims, LASPO 2012 s56 (no referral fees) is raised beside 5.1.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

R1 (Referral fees LASPO and SRA Principles), R2 (Q&As on the ban of personal injury referral fees), R3 (The Prohibition of referral fees in LASPO 56 60), R6 (Lawtech providers Q&A), P8 (Marketing your services to members of the public), C11 (Claims management activity), C12 ('No win, no fee' and other fee arrangements in high-volume consumer claims)

Fee-sharing and referral interests must be disclosed. You must be able to show that an introducer did not cold call. All deductions in claims work, including referrer fees, must be disclosed.

Legislation

RF1 (LASPO 2012 s56 (referral fee ban), s57 (regulators' rules and presumption), s58 (FCA), s59 (regulators and regulated persons), s60 (regulations)) (LASPO ss56, 59)

5.1 requires disclosure, not a ban. Separately, LASPO s56 bans paying or receiving referral fees for prescribed legal business (personal injury and death claims), and the SRA says it enforces the ban directly (Code introduction). The product should raise a separate ban item when a matter is personal injury or death (see C3).

Civil courts

A4 Day; A19 Hopcraft

Fee sharing and referral arrangements were tested under the 2007 rules 8 and 9 (Day). Disclosing a payment means disclosing the material facts, usually including the amount (Hopcraft; Wood [134]).

What we are asking you

  1. Is matter opening the right point to record a referral, or do referral and fee-sharing terms often change later in the matter?
  2. Should evidence about an introducer's methods be held once per introducer rather than on every matter it refers?
  3. In high-volume claims work, should the client letter also list every deduction, including referrer fees?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 5.1.

Respond on Code 5.1
Your view of Code 5.1

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 5.2

Code 5.2: where the SRA considers a payment may be a referral fee in the LASPO 2012 sense (personal injury and death claims), it is treated as one unless you show otherwise.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL
Kinds of duty (provisional)
record
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Recording a payment to or from a referrer on a personal injury or death claim (a new record this would add)
  • Attaching the evidence that a payment is not a referral fee, for example a genuine marketing or hospitality arrangement

Why we apply it this way

Code 5.2 is the rule made under LASPO s57(8), and referral fee has its s57(7) meaning, so the presumption reaches only payments linked to personal injury and death claims. The SRA's tests for hospitality, marketing co-operatives and mandated suppliers decide what counts (R2, R3). Legal Workflows does not decide whether a payment is a referral fee, but keeps the evidence a firm would need to show otherwise.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Record: the item is discharged only with evidence attached (a document version, a note or a decision). Evidence is append-only and audited, so it can be shown to the SRA under Code 7.2 and Firms 2.2.
  • Referral fee carries its LASPO 2012 meaning (personal injury and death claims).

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

R3 (The Prohibition of referral fees in LASPO 56 60), R2 (Q&As on the ban of personal injury referral fees)

The SRA's tests for whether a payment is a referral fee: hospitality, marketing co-operatives, mandated suppliers.

Legislation

RF1 (LASPO 2012 s56 (referral fee ban), s57 (regulators' rules and presumption), s58 (FCA), s59 (regulators and regulated persons), s60 (regulations)) (LASPO s57(7) to (9)); Glossary "referral fee"

5.2 is the rule made under s57(8). "Referral fee" is the s57(7) definition, so the presumption applies only to payments connected with referrals of prescribed legal business (see C4).

Civil courts

A4 Day; A19 Hopcraft

Fee sharing and referral arrangements were tested under the 2007 rules 8 and 9 (Day). Disclosing a payment means disclosing the material facts, usually including the amount (Hopcraft; Wood [134]).

What we are asking you

  1. Is the organisation's matter type a reliable way to tell that a matter is a personal injury or death claim?
  2. Should the evidence be kept once per arrangement with a referrer, or on each matter the arrangement touches?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 5.2.

Respond on Code 5.2
Your view of Code 5.2

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 5.3

Code 5.3: get the client's informed consent before sending them to, or splitting their matter with, a separate business.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL
Kinds of duty (provisional)
consent
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Referring a client, or part of their matter, to a separate business (a new record this would add)
  • Recording the client's informed consent before the referral: who gave it, when, in what form, and the document that evidences it

Why we apply it this way

The SRA expects clients sent to a separate business to give informed consent, and not to be confused about which business is regulated (R5). Consent is informed only when the client knows the material facts, including any payment involved (Hopcraft). So Legal Workflows records the consent, with its evidence, before the work goes ahead.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Consent: the item records the client’s informed consent before the work goes ahead: who gave it, when, in what form, and the document version that evidences it.
  • Raised when a matter is referred to, or split with, a separate business.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

R5 (Separate Business), R1 (Referral fees LASPO and SRA Principles), R2 (Q&As on the ban of personal injury referral fees)

Clients referred to a separate business must give informed consent, and must not be confused about which business is regulated.

Legislation

No specific legislation

Sharing client personal data with the separate business is processing under UK GDPR (DP1), but that is general.

Civil courts

A4 Day; A19 Hopcraft

Fee sharing and referral arrangements were tested under the 2007 rules 8 and 9 (Day). Disclosing a payment means disclosing the material facts, usually including the amount (Hopcraft; Wood [134]).

What we are asking you

  1. Should the consent record also show what the client was told about which business the SRA regulates?
  2. Where the separate business shares owners with the firm, should splitting a matter between them be recorded as well as a referral?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 5.3.

Respond on Code 5.3
Your view of Code 5.3

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 5.4

Code 5.4: do not take part in an unauthorised business that uses "solicitors" in its name or describes its work as done by solicitors.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Linked

For reference. The paragraph has its own page, with our summary, a link to the SRA's text and its authorities, but nothing on a matter raises it.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • No activity raises Code 5.4
  • Shown as reference on its own page, with the offences in the Solicitors Act 1974 and the Legal Services Act 2007

Why we apply it this way

Code 5.4 is about the business a person takes part in, not about any matter. Legal Workflows cannot see a business's name or how it describes its work to the public. Whether a business is unauthorised, and whether its use of the word solicitors is an offence under SA 1974 ss20 and 21 or LSA 2007 ss14 and 17, is a legal judgment for a person.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Reference only.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

none found

None found. R8 only touches on practising in unauthorised bodies.

Legislation

SA1 (SA 1974 s20 (unqualified person not to act as a solicitor), s21 (not to pretend to be a solicitor)) (SA ss20, 21); LS1 (LSA 2007 s12 (reserved legal activities), s14 (offence to carry on reserved activity unless entitled), s15 (employers and employees), s17 (offence to pretend to be entitled), s18 (authorised persons)) (LSA ss14, 17)

It is an offence for an unqualified person to act as, or pretend to be, a solicitor, or to pretend to be entitled to carry on reserved activities. A business using "solicitors" without authorisation may be committing these offences.

What we are asking you

  1. Is it right that no activity in the product raises Code 5.4?
  2. Would a reference page help solicitors who work in, or are asked to join, a business the SRA does not authorise?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 5.4.

Respond on Code 5.4
Your view of Code 5.4

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 5.5

Code 5.5: if you practise, file the annual return the SRA prescribes.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL
Kinds of duty (provisional)
report
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • The SRA annual return falling due for the organisation's practising solicitors (a reminder this would add)
  • Recording that the return was filed, or why it was not needed this year

Why we apply it this way

Filing the return is a yearly duty with no SRA guidance beyond the enabling power in SA 1974 s28. Whether someone practises is not a condition the product can test, so Legal Workflows only reminds and records. A person decides whether the duty applies and records the filing.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Report: the item prompts a recorded decision on whether to notify the SRA (or another body), and records the notification if one is made. The product never sends a report itself.
  • A reminder to file the SRA annual return, for those who practise. “If practising” is not a machine condition; it stays in the text.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

R8 (Unregulated organisations for employers of SRA regulated lawyers) (passing reference only)

No specific guidance found.

Legislation

A2 (SA 1974 s2 (training regulations), s13 (practising certificate appeals), s28 (regulations on admission, the roll and practising certificates), s32 (accounts rules), s33A (inspection of practice bank accounts), s34 (accountants' reports), s37 (indemnity rules)) (SA s28)

No legislation beyond the enabling power.

What we are asking you

  1. Should the reminder go to each practising solicitor, to the COLP, or to both?
  2. Is a compliance item the right home for a yearly duty that has no matter, or should it sit at organisation level?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 5.5.

Respond on Code 5.5
Your view of Code 5.5

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 5.6

Code 5.6: a solicitor or REL who carries on reserved legal activities for the public through a non-commercial body (LSA 2007 s23) must make sure it has adequate and appropriate indemnity insurance.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL
Kinds of duty (provisional)
record
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Recording that the organisation is a non-commercial body carrying on reserved legal activities for the public (a new setting this would add)
  • Uploading the indemnity insurance policy and the reasoned assessment of cover as evidence
  • Renewal of the cover falling due (a reminder this would add)

Why we apply it this way

Non-commercial body has a narrow legal meaning under LSA 2007 s23, so a person confirms it rather than the product inferring it from the organisation type. Once the duty applies, cover must address all the services given, and the SRA expects evidence of a reasoned assessment (R7). So Legal Workflows closes the item only with that evidence attached, and raises it only for solicitors and RELs.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Record: the item is discharged only with evidence attached (a document version, a note or a decision). Evidence is append-only and audited, so it can be shown to the SRA under Code 7.2 and Firms 2.2.
  • Audience is narrowed to solicitors and RELs. “Non-commercial body” has its LSA 2007 s23 meaning and is not a machine condition.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

R7 (Adequate and appropriate indemnity insurance)

Once triggered, cover must address all services. The SRA expects evidence of a reasoned assessment of cover.

Legislation

LS2 (LSA s23); Glossary "non-commercial body"; A2 (SA 1974 s2 (training regulations), s13 (practising certificate appeals), s28 (regulations on admission, the roll and practising certificates), s32 (accounts rules), s33A (inspection of practice bank accounts), s34 (accountants' reports), s37 (indemnity rules)) (SA s37)

A "non-commercial body" is a not-for-profit body, community interest company or independent trade union with LSA s23 transitional protection. LSA s106 is prospective (not in force), so do not cite it as current. The paragraph applies only to solicitors and RELs (see C5).

What we are asking you

  1. Should an advice agency or law centre be asked whether it is a non-commercial body when it first sets up Legal Workflows?
  2. Is the policy plus a written assessment of cover the right evidence, or would you expect the SRA to ask for more?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 5.6.

Respond on Code 5.6
Your view of Code 5.6

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 6.1

Code 6.1: do not act where your own interests conflict, or are at significant risk of conflicting, with the client's.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL
Kinds of duty (provisional)
conflict
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Integrated (already live)

Legal Workflows already acts on this duty today. It will add the paragraph's own page, and cite the paragraph on what the product already does.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Running a conflict check when a matter is opened
  • Recording a decision on a check that found an own interest: only Decline or Refer is offered, as no consent cures it
  • Recording a member's own interests, including connected persons and companies (a register this would add)
  • Recording that something went wrong on a matter, which can create an own interest (a new record this would add)

Why we apply it this way

No consent cures an own-interest conflict, and own mistakes, funding and referral arrangements can each create one (K1, K3, M4). The check keys on the legal client, so SDT 12560 and SRA decision 594846 show that ties to a client's owners and directors, and a member's connected persons and companies, need their own record. Legal Workflows blocks any waiver and asks a person to decline or refer.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Existing product behaviour: Own-interest hit cannot be waived (ConflictDecisionForm.tsx).
  • Conflict: the item is tied to the conflict search and its recorded decision. The decision outcome (for example acting under an exception) is the evidence, and an own-interest conflict cannot be waived.
  • Code 6.1 to 6.5 resolve to edition sra-2025-04-11 (acceptance criterion).

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

K1 (Conflicts of interest), K3 (Putting matters right when things go wrong, and own interest conflicts), S7 (Drafting and preparation of wills), R1 (Referral fees LASPO and SRA Principles), R4 (Offering inducements to potential clients or clients), M4 (Using or arranging Third-Party Litigation Funding), S4 (Terminating a retainer)

No consent cure. Own mistakes create own-interest conflicts. Funding and referral arrangements can do so too. Ceasing to act still requires protecting the client urgently.

Legislation

No specific legislation

Not statutory.

Civil courts

A19 Hopcraft; A29 Grunhut; Mothew (via A27)

The core fiduciary duties are no conflict and no profit (via Mothew). Undisclosed personal loans from clients were hidden from the firm; Grunhut was charged under 1.4, not 6.1, but the facts are an own-interest risk.

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12560 (SDT 12560-2024, 14 Jul 2025). Paragraphs found or considered: P2, P3, P5, 6.1.

A loan to the individual behind a corporate client failed as a 6.1 allegation, because the client was the company and the individual had never been a client. For Legal Workflows: the conflict engine keys on the legal client, so relationships with a client's owners and directors need their own flag. The SRA cannot rely on 6.1 for them.

Tribunal or SRA decision

SRA decision 594846 (SRA agreed outcome 594846, 21 Sep 2026). Paragraphs found or considered: P2, 6.1, Accounts Rule 3.3.

Payments from client account to companies controlled by the solicitor's family, or by his own company, were admitted as an own-interest conflict risk. For Legal Workflows: own-interest checks should include connected persons and companies.

What we are asking you

  1. Should the own-interest register cover connected persons and companies, and ties to the owners and directors of corporate clients?
  2. When a fee earner's own mistake may lead to a claim, should that open a 6.1 item as well as a 7.11 item?
  3. Is it right to offer only Decline or Refer, rather than a recorded judgment that the risk of conflict is not significant?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 6.1.

Respond on Code 6.1
Your view of Code 6.1

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 6.2

Code 6.2: do not act for two or more clients whose interests conflict, or are at significant risk of conflicting, unless one of the two exceptions applies with the conditions it sets.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL
Kinds of duty (provisional)
conflict, consent
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Integrated (already live)

Legal Workflows already acts on this duty today. It will add the paragraph's own page, and cite the paragraph on what the product already does.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Running a conflict check that matches every current client, whatever matter they are on
  • Recording Act under an exception (6.2), with each client's consent document, the safeguards and a reviewer's confirmation that acting is reasonable
  • Declining or referring a check where neither exception applies

Why we apply it this way

Each exception carries conditions: written consent, safeguards unless the clients agree otherwise, and a judgment that acting is reasonable (K1). Legal Workflows makes each a required part of the decision, and the approver cannot be the person who ran the check. SDT 12699 shows the check must reach every current client and treat witnesses and complainants as adverse, and M&S v Freshfields shows a firm cannot wait to see whether a matter turns hostile.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Conflict: the item is tied to the conflict search and its recorded decision. The decision outcome (for example acting under an exception) is the evidence, and an own-interest conflict cannot be waived.
  • Consent: the item records the client’s informed consent before the work goes ahead: who gave it, when, in what form, and the document version that evidences it.
  • Exception (b) carries the three conditions (I) to (III) as limbs of the paragraph.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

K1 (Conflicts of interest), K2 (Conflict of interest - Case studies), K4 (Dealing with conflicts of interest, independence and confidentiality for in-house solicitors), M4 (Using or arranging Third-Party Litigation Funding), G12 (Investment schemes), S8 (Advising on leasehold provisions including ground rent clauses)

Applies to a matter or an aspect of it, and to prospective clients. Conditions on the exceptions:

  • informed consent, given or evidenced in writing
  • structural safeguards unless clients agree otherwise
  • reasonableness, judged on bargaining power and how much negotiation is needed

Limited retainers must not leave a client unprotected.

Legislation

No specific legislation

Not statutory.

Civil courts

A21 M&S v Freshfields (Bolkiah via A21)

A firm may not act for and against a current client without consent, a conflict that does not depend on confidential information. It may not wait to see whether a bid turns hostile (M&S [6], [16], [26]). Note that M&S is a decision refusing permission to appeal.

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12699 (SDT 12699-2024, 23 Sep 2025). Paragraphs found or considered: P2, P5, P7, 6.2, 6.5.

A criminal defence solicitor acted for a defendant whose alleged victim was his existing client in unrelated matters, and advised her about a witness summons. The test was whether he knew or ought to have known of the conflict. Neither exception applied, and 6.5 was breached because of a real risk to her confidential information. The only proper course was to decline. For Legal Workflows: the conflict search must match all current clients, whatever matter they are on. Witness and complainant roles are adverse parties.

What we are asking you

  1. Is it right to treat witness and complainant roles as adverse when the check runs?
  2. Is a separate approver workable for sole practitioners and small in-house teams, and what should happen where there is no one else?
  3. Should adding a party to a live matter run a fresh check, rather than relying on the check made at opening?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 6.2.

Respond on Code 6.2
Your view of Code 6.2

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 6.3

Code 6.3: keep current and former clients' affairs confidential, and do not misuse them, unless the law requires or permits disclosure or the client agrees.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL
Kinds of duty (provisional)
confidentiality
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Integrated (already live)

Legal Workflows already acts on this duty today. It will add the paragraph's own page, and cite the paragraph on what the product already does.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Opening a matter: only its members can see its documents, notes and chats
  • Setting up an information barrier that screens named members from a matter
  • Reading a conflict check: anyone who is not a conflicts reviewer sees counts and bands only
  • Using the assistant on a matter's documents, where a person approves every draft and every quotation is checked

Why we apply it this way

The duty covers misuse as well as disclosure, lasts after the retainer ends, and includes keeping files secure (K6, Glencairn, SDT 12570). So Legal Workflows makes matter membership the boundary, shows conflict results in full only to reviewers, and records the barrier or consent that lets work continue. The Misuse of AI notice (G1) is why client data in the assistant has safeguards and a person in the loop.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Existing product behaviour: Matter membership is the confidentiality boundary; cross-matter conflict reads (parties.shared.ts, conflicts.decisions.ts).
  • Confidentiality: matter membership and information barriers enforce the boundary. The item records the barrier, or the consent, that allows the work to continue.
  • The SRA’s Misuse of AI warning notice (17 August 2026) applies here. The paragraph's page links it, and the assistant verifies every quotation and keeps a person in the loop on every draft.
  • Client data in AI tools needs contractual, technical and organisational safeguards.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

K6 (Confidentiality of client information), G1 (Misuse of AI), K7 (Legal professional privilege when working in-house), K8 (Mergers, acquisitions and sales of law firms), K9 (Information security and cybercrime - Case studies), S1 (Accepting instructions from vulnerable clients or third parties acting on their behalf), S2 (Access to and disclosure of an incapacitated person's will), A1 (Reporting and notification obligations), C7 (Sham litigation)

The duty is unqualified and extends to misuse. Key applications:

  • AI tools need safeguards: no training use, a secure environment, limited retention.
  • Merger due diligence needs redaction and consent.
  • Outsourcing and cloud need review.
  • Disclosure to the SRA is usually justified, but privileged material needs client consent (Carter-Ruck).

Legislation

A7 (LSA 2007 s1: regulatory objectives (s1(1)) and professional principles (s1(3))) (LSA s1(3)(e)); DP1 (UK GDPR art 5 (principles, including 5(1)(f) integrity and confidentiality, and 5(2) accountability)) (UK GDPR art 5(1)(f)); DP3; DP5 (DPA 2018 Sch 2 para 19 (legal professional privilege exemption from the listed GDPR provisions)); CO5 (Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984 s10 (items subject to legal privilege)) (PACE s10); A14 (SA 1974 s44B (notice to provide information or produce documents) and s44BA (requirement to attend and explain); LSA 2007 s93 (licensing authority's information power)) (SA s44B, LSA s93, s111A); PC1 (Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 s328 (arrangements), s330 (failure to disclose: regulated sector), s333A (tipping off: regulated sector), s333D (permitted disclosures), s337 (protected disclosures), s342 (prejudicing an investigation)) (POCA ss330, 337); TA1 (Terrorism Act 2000 s21A (failure to disclose: regulated sector), s21B (protected disclosures), s21D (tipping off: regulated sector)) (ss21A, 21B); EC1 (ECCTA 2023 s188 (direct disclosures: no breach of confidence)) (ECCTA s188)

"Disclosure required or permitted by law" includes: SRA statutory notices (s44B, s111A); required money laundering and terrorist financing reports (POCA s330, TA s21A), which do not breach confidence (POCA s337, TA s21B); and ECCTA s188 direct disclosures, which exclude privileged material. Privilege, defined for PACE in s10, and confidentiality are different. Privileged information is outside the s330 duty in the s330(6) and (10) circumstances, unless given to further a criminal purpose (s330(11)). The UK GDPR adds a parallel statutory duty to keep client data secure.

Civil courts

A22 Glencairn; A21 M&S; A28 Hurst

Information received as a fiduciary is protected strictly after the retainer ends (Glencairn [66]-[67]). Labelling a letter "confidential" is judged by whether the claim is arguable on the law of confidence (Hurst [109]).

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12570 (SDT 12570-2024, 23 Oct 2024). Paragraphs found or considered: P2, P5, P7, 4.2, 6.3, 7.3, 7.4, 7.6.

Abandoning a practice and leaving confidential files unattended breached 6.3. The SRA relied on its guidance that files must be stored securely. For Legal Workflows: 6.3 covers secure custody of records, not only disclosure.

What we are asking you

  1. Is matter membership the right default boundary, or do supervisors need wider access by default?
  2. Should the product raise 6.3 when a matter is left with no active member, for example when a fee earner leaves?
  3. Are counts and bands enough for someone who runs a conflict check but is not a reviewer?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 6.3.

Respond on Code 6.3
Your view of Code 6.3

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 6.4

Code 6.4: tell the client all information material to their matter that you know of, unless the law forbids it (for example tipping off), the client has agreed in writing not to be told, telling them risks serious injury, or it comes from a privileged document disclosed to you by mistake.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL
Kinds of duty (provisional)
inform
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Recording something the client must be told, for example a shortage on their money (a new record this would add)
  • Issuing the letter that tells the client, from the correspondence register
  • Recording that information is withheld under an exception, with reasons, for example to avoid serious injury
  • Recording a suspicion report on a matter, which stops any prompt or draft to tell the client (a new record this would add)

Why we apply it this way

A duty of confidence to another client does not excuse withholding material information from this one (Hilton, Armstrong). Telling a client about a suspicion report can be tipping off (POCA s333A, TA 2000 s21D), so where one is recorded Legal Workflows stays silent and leaves any s333D decision to a person. It offers withholding under 6.4(c) with reasons, never a false statement, which SDT 12904 shows engages Code 1.4.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Inform: the item asks for the client to be told something, and is discharged by recording what was sent, when and how. The assistant can prepare the communication as a draft for a person to approve.
  • The one place the product must actively stay silent: where a suspicious activity report is recorded on a matter, the product does not prompt or draft a disclosure to the client under 6.4 (POCA 2002 s333A; Terrorism Act 2000 s21D).
  • Not cited in code today; the paragraph is present with four exceptions.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

K1 (Conflicts of interest), K4 (Dealing with conflicts of interest, independence and confidentiality for in-house solicitors), M1 (Money missing from client account), A1 (Reporting and notification obligations)

Use the 6.4(b) informed-consent route when withholding information. A client-account shortage is material information the client must be told.

Legislation

(a) PC1 (Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 s328 (arrangements), s330 (failure to disclose: regulated sector), s333A (tipping off: regulated sector), s333D (permitted disclosures), s337 (protected disclosures), s342 (prejudicing an investigation)) (POCA ss333A, 333D, 342); TA1 (Terrorism Act 2000 s21A (failure to disclose: regulated sector), s21B (protected disclosures), s21D (tipping off: regulated sector)) (s21D). (d) CO2 (Civil Procedure Rules 1998 r31.20 (privileged document inspected by mistake)) (CPR 31.20).

(a) Tipping off. Telling a client that a suspicious activity report has been made, or that an investigation is contemplated, can be an offence (POCA s333A, TA s21D, POCA s342). The product must not create or draft a "tell the client" item where a suspicion report or internal disclosure is recorded on the matter. It must keep that record hidden from people working the 6.4 item. s333D(2) allows a legal adviser to disclose to the client only to dissuade them from offending, and that decision is for the MLRO or a lawyer, not the product. (d) CPR 31.20: a party who has inspected a privileged document that was disclosed by mistake may use it only with the court's permission. Draft no client disclosure of such a document's contents. (b), (c) are not statutory. See C6.

Civil courts

Hilton and Spector (via A24 Armstrong); A25 Rawlinson; A26 Atlantisrealm (Al-Fayed via both)

A duty of confidence to another client is no excuse for withholding material information from this one. If the two cannot both be met, do not act (via Hilton [41]; Armstrong [100]-[101]). For the mistaken-disclosure exception, the test is whether the mistake was obvious to a reasonable solicitor, or actually spotted by anyone in the firm before the document was used (Atlantisrealm [31], [48]; Rawlinson [15]).

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12904 (above), my inference. Paragraphs found or considered: 1.4 (6.4 not pleaded).

Not a finding on 6.4. The Tribunal accepted a genuine concern to avoid harming a vulnerable client, but actively telling him the report had not arrived still breached 1.4. 6.4(c) allows withholding where serious injury is likely. For Legal Workflows: offer "withhold under 6.4(c), recorded with reasons" as a route, and never a false statement.

What we are asking you

  1. Which events on a matter most often carry information the client must be told, apart from a shortage on their money?
  2. Is it right that a suspicion record is hidden from people working the 6.4 item, and that only the MLRO or a lawyer decides on s333D?
  3. Should a client's written agreement not to be told be recorded once per client, or for each piece of information?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 6.4.

Respond on Code 6.4
Your view of Code 6.4

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 6.5

Code 6.5: do not act against a current or former client of yours, your firm or your employer while any of you holds their material confidential information, unless effective measures leave no real risk of disclosure or that client gives informed consent, in writing or evidenced in writing, to your acting and to the measures.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL
Kinds of duty (provisional)
confidentiality, conflict, consent
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Integrated (already live)

Legal Workflows already acts on this duty today. It will add the paragraph's own page, and cite the paragraph on what the product already does.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Recording Act with consent and measures (6.5), with the measures and the client's consent document
  • Setting up an information barrier with a reason, a review date and the members it screens
  • A screened member trying to open the protected matter, which is refused and logged
  • Reviewing a barrier on its review date, or ending it with a reason

Why we apply it this way

The burden is on the firm, and the risk need only be real, not substantial (Bolkiah). A barrier set up promptly can still succeed on clear evidence (Bank of London), and Re A and C relied on lock-out, team separation and access logs, so Legal Workflows records who is screened, refuses and logs every attempt, and keeps each review. Consent must cover the measures as well as the acting, so the decision records both.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Existing product behaviour: consent_6_5 outcome and information barriers (lib/matters/barriers.ts).
  • Confidentiality: matter membership and information barriers enforce the boundary. The item records the barrier, or the consent, that allows the work to continue.
  • Conflict: the item is tied to the conflict search and its recorded decision. The decision outcome (for example acting under an exception) is the evidence, and an own-interest conflict cannot be waived.
  • Consent: the item records the client’s informed consent before the work goes ahead: who gave it, when, in what form, and the document version that evidences it.
  • Covers information held by the person’s firm or employer. Consent must be in writing or evidenced in writing and extend to the measures (Bolkiah).

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

K6 (Confidentiality of client information), K1 (Conflicts of interest)

Information held by "you or your business or employer" counts. Barriers must leave no real risk of disclosure, and the Bolkiah standard is high. Consent must be informed and given or evidenced in writing.

Legislation

No specific legislation

Not statutory. Information barriers are a regulatory construct.

Civil courts

Bolkiah (via A21, A22, A23); A22 Glencairn; A23 Bank of London v Simmons

The burden is on the firm. The risk must be real, not fanciful, but need not be substantial. A barrier must be effective, and is ideally an established part of the firm's structure (via Bolkiah). One set up promptly can still succeed on clear, credible evidence (Bank of London [26], [32]-[33]). The strict rule protects former clients, not former opponents (Glencairn [74], [79]).

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12699 (SDT 12699-2024, 23 Sep 2025). Paragraphs found or considered: P2, P5, P7, 6.2, 6.5.

A criminal defence solicitor acted for a defendant whose alleged victim was his existing client in unrelated matters, and advised her about a witness summons. The test was whether he knew or ought to have known of the conflict. Neither exception applied, and 6.5 was breached because of a real risk to her confidential information. The only proper course was to decline. For Legal Workflows: the conflict search must match all current clients, whatever matter they are on. Witness and complainant roles are adverse parties.

Tribunal or SRA decision

Re A and C (Solicitors: Conflict of Interest) [2026] EWHC 2842 (Fam), 4 Nov 2026 (High Court, not SDT). Paragraphs found or considered: 6.5 (as reflecting the Bolkiah principles).

There is no automatic rule imputing one solicitor's knowledge to the whole firm. 6.5 itself contemplates effective measures. A lateral hire who was locked out of the file, had no contact with the team, worked in a separate team, and had no access-log evidence against him was behind an effective barrier. For Legal Workflows: the information-barrier feature should record system lock-out, team separation and access logs, because those are the facts a court relied on.

What we are asking you

  1. Are the lock-out, the log of refused attempts and the review record the evidence you would rely on, and should team separation be recorded too?
  2. Should a barrier be required whenever 6.5 consent is recorded, or is consent alone enough where the client agrees?
  3. Is a review date the right control for a long-running barrier, and what interval do you use?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 6.5.

Respond on Code 6.5
Your view of Code 6.5

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 7.1

Code 7.1: know, and comply with, the current legal and regulatory requirements on your practice.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Linked

For reference. The paragraph has its own page, with our summary, a link to the SRA's text and its authorities, but nothing on a matter raises it.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • No activity raises Code 7.1 on its own
  • Shown as reference on its own page, which says the Accounts Rules, Transparency Rules and Money Laundering Regulations are not yet in the product

Why we apply it this way

Code 7.1 is the paragraph that brings general law into the Code, so an item per statute here would duplicate the specific paragraphs. A failure under another law becomes a conduct matter only if it is serious enough (Dentons, Sa'id), and Legal Workflows does not grade seriousness. Where the product records a legal duty, it cites the specific paragraph instead.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • The Transparency Rules, Accounts Rules, MLRs and Authorisation of Firms Rules reach the codes only through 7.1. The page says plainly that these instruments are not yet in the product.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

E7 (Topic guide: Anti-money laundering), F3–F8 (Complying with the UK Sanctions Regime), S4 (Terminating a retainer), P6 (Transparency in price and service)

Brings in legal duties: MLRs, POCA, sanctions, the Equality Act, Transparency Rules and Consumer Contracts information.

Legislation

All entries in 2.1, especially ML1 (Money Laundering, Terrorist Financing and Transfer of Funds (Information on the Payer) Regulations 2017: reg 7 (supervisors), 12 (independent legal professional), 18 (risk assessment), 19 (policies and controls), 21 (internal controls and nominated officer), 24 (training), 26 (approval of beneficial owners, officers and managers), 27 and 28 (customer due diligence), 40 (record-keeping)), PC1 (Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 s328 (arrangements), s330 (failure to disclose: regulated sector), s333A (tipping off: regulated sector), s333D (permitted disclosures), s337 (protected disclosures), s342 (prejudicing an investigation)), DP1 (UK GDPR art 5 (principles, including 5(1)(f) integrity and confidentiality, and 5(2) accountability)), EQ5, EQ6 (EA 2010 s40A (employer's duty to prevent sexual harassment))

This is the paragraph that imports general law. The product should not create one item per statute here, or it would duplicate the specific rows.

Civil courts

A34 Dentons (HC, CA); A33 Sa'id; A29 Grunhut

A breach of law, such as the Money Laundering Regulations, becomes a breach of the Principles or Code only if it is sufficiently serious. Seriousness is inherent in the duty (Dentons CA [98], [119]; Sa'id [69]-[70]). A customer due diligence failure was charged under 7.1 (Grunhut).

Tribunal or SRA decision

Grunhut (above); SRA decision 508044 (SRA agreed outcome 508044, 27 Aug 2026). Paragraphs found or considered: 7.1; Firms 2.1(a), 2.2, 3.1.

Breaches of the Money Laundering Regulations (customer due diligence, risk-assessment records) are charged through 7.1 / Firms 3.1. In SRA decision 508044, risk-assessing without recording the assessment was admitted as a breach of Firms 2.2 because compliance could not be shown. For Legal Workflows: for the "record" type, an unrecorded action counts as not done.

What we are asking you

  1. Is it right that 7.1 stays a reference page rather than a source of items?
  2. SRA decision 508044 treated an unrecorded risk assessment as one that could not be shown. Should the product treat an unrecorded step as not done?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 7.1.

Respond on Code 7.1
Your view of Code 7.1

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 7.2

Code 7.2: be able to show that your decisions and actions comply.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL
Kinds of duty (provisional)
record
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Closing any compliance item, which needs evidence attached: a document version, a note or a decision
  • Recording a conflict decision, which is kept and never edited
  • Writing a matter note, where an edit keeps the earlier version
  • Exporting a matter with a manifest that lets each file be checked against what was held

Why we apply it this way

SRA guidance asks again and again for evidence of decisions: supervision, reporting, putting things right and AI use (S3, A1, K3, G1). So every item in the conduct layer closes only with evidence, and that evidence cannot be edited or removed. MLR reg 40 and UK GDPR art 5(2) sit beside 7.2, so retention settings must not delete records earlier than the law requires.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Record: the item is discharged only with evidence attached (a document version, a note or a decision). Evidence is append-only and audited, so it can be shown to the SRA under Code 7.2 and Firms 2.2.
  • Satisfied by the append-only evidence on every discharged item. This is what makes the record type useful across the layer.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

G1 (Misuse of AI), S3 (Effective supervision), A1 (Reporting and notification obligations), K3 (Putting matters right when things go wrong, and own interest conflicts), E1 (SRA enforcement strategy)

The guidance repeatedly calls for evidence of decisions: supervision arrangements, reporting decisions, remedial pathways and AI use.

Legislation

ML1 (Money Laundering, Terrorist Financing and Transfer of Funds (Information on the Payer) Regulations 2017: reg 7 (supervisors), 12 (independent legal professional), 18 (risk assessment), 19 (policies and controls), 21 (internal controls and nominated officer), 24 (training), 26 (approval of beneficial owners, officers and managers), 27 and 28 (customer due diligence), 40 (record-keeping)) (MLR reg 40, five-year retention); DP1 (UK GDPR art 5 (principles, including 5(1)(f) integrity and confidentiality, and 5(2) accountability)) (art 5(2) accountability)

Statutory record-keeping sits beside 7.2. MLR reg 40 requires records for five years from when the transaction completes or the business relationship ends. The product's retention and immutability settings must not delete such records earlier.

What we are asking you

  1. Is a document version, a note or a recorded decision enough to show compliance, or should some items need a particular kind of evidence?
  2. Do any of your records need keeping longer than the five years in MLR reg 40, and should the product hold them for that period?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 7.2.

Respond on Code 7.2
Your view of Code 7.2

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 7.3

Code 7.3: work with the SRA and with other regulators, ombudsmen and oversight bodies for legal services.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL
Kinds of duty (provisional)
report
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Recording a request or notice from the Legal Ombudsman, the SRA or another oversight body (a new record this would add)
  • Setting a key date for the reply, with reminders before it falls due
  • Recording the reply and when it was sent

Why we apply it this way

Cooperation is a statutory duty as well as a Code one, as the Legal Ombudsman can compel information under LSA 2007 s147. SDT 12681 and 12852 show that slow or patchy replies, including to a s147 notice, are what goes wrong. So Legal Workflows records each request, its deadline and the reply, and any draft it prepares says the SRA cannot compel a client's privileged material without consent.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Report: the item prompts a recorded decision on whether to notify the SRA (or another body), and records the notification if one is made. The product never sends a report itself.
  • Any cooperation or reporting draft for this paragraph says that the SRA cannot compel production of a client’s privileged material without that client’s consent.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

A5 (On-site investigations (inspections)), A6 (How we gather evidence in our regulatory and disciplinary investigations), K6 (Confidentiality of client information), C4 (Use of non disclosure agreements (NDAs)), C10 (High-volume financial service claims), P5 (Complaints about solicitors working outside SRA-regulated firms - Case studies)

Cooperation includes with LeO, which may compel information by s147 notice. Refusing to talk to the SRA is non-cooperation.

Legislation

LS3 (LSA 2007 Part 6 (legal complaints): s112 (complaints procedures of authorised persons), s125 (ombudsman jurisdiction), s126 (respondent's own procedure must be used first), s133 (scheme rules, including time limits), s147 (ombudsman's information powers)) (LSA s147, ombudsman information notices); ML1 (Money Laundering, Terrorist Financing and Transfer of Funds (Information on the Payer) Regulations 2017: reg 7 (supervisors), 12 (independent legal professional), 18 (risk assessment), 19 (policies and controls), 21 (internal controls and nominated officer), 24 (training), 26 (approval of beneficial owners, officers and managers), 27 and 28 (customer due diligence), 40 (record-keeping)) (reg 7, supervisory authorities)

The Legal Ombudsman can compel documents and information. Cooperation with the Ombudsman is a statutory as well as a regulatory duty.

Civil courts

A31 Husain

Gratuitous abuse of an SRA investigating officer breached the Principles (Husain [130]).

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12681 (above); SDT 12852 (SDT 12852-2025, 5 Jun 2026). Paragraphs found or considered: 7.3, 7.4, P2.

Slow or sporadic replies to the Legal Ombudsman and the SRA, including ignoring a section 147 notice, breached 7.3 and 7.4.

What we are asking you

  1. Are requests from the Legal Ombudsman and the SRA usually tied to one matter, or should they also be recorded at organisation level?
  2. Should a missed reply deadline go to the COLP as well as to the matter's admin?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 7.3.

Respond on Code 7.3
Your view of Code 7.3

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 7.4

Code 7.4: answer the SRA promptly, fully and accurately, and make relevant information available for inspection, including information held by third parties performing critical functions for you.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL
Kinds of duty (provisional)
report, record
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Recording an SRA notice or request, with the power it cites and its deadline (a new record this would add)
  • Exporting a matter's files with a manifest that lets each file be checked
  • Exporting the organisation's audit trail for a date range
  • Recording which outside providers hold information for the firm (a new record this would add)

Why we apply it this way

The SRA expects information to be organised and available, including what third parties hold for the firm (A5, A6). Its powers under SA 1974 ss44B and 44BA and LSA 2007 s93 come with deadlines, so the item records the power and the date. The SRA cannot compel privileged material without the client's consent (K7, Carter-Ruck, under appeal), so Legal Workflows never prompts a user to hand it over.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Report: the item prompts a recorded decision on whether to notify the SRA (or another body), and records the notification if one is made. The product never sends a report itself.
  • Record: the item is discharged only with evidence attached (a document version, a note or a decision). Evidence is append-only and audited, so it can be shown to the SRA under Code 7.2 and Firms 2.2.
  • Includes information held by third parties performing critical functions for the firm.
  • Any cooperation or reporting draft for this paragraph says that the SRA cannot compel production of a client’s privileged material without that client’s consent.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

A5 (On-site investigations (inspections)), A6 (How we gather evidence in our regulatory and disciplinary investigations), A1 (Reporting and notification obligations), K7 (Legal professional privilege when working in-house)

Information must be organised. The SRA cannot compel privileged material without client consent (Carter-Ruck, under appeal). The duty covers information held by critical third parties.

Legislation

A14 (SA 1974 s44B (notice to provide information or produce documents) and s44BA (requirement to attend and explain); LSA 2007 s93 (licensing authority's information power)) (SA ss44B, 44BA; LSA s93; LSA s111A)

These are the SRA's statutory compulsion powers. A "report" item raised in response to a statutory notice should record which power it cites and the deadline. See also C10.

Civil courts

A31 Husain

Gratuitous abuse of an SRA investigating officer breached the Principles (Husain [130]).

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12681 (above); SDT 12852 (SDT 12852-2025, 5 Jun 2026). Paragraphs found or considered: 7.3, 7.4, P2.

Slow or sporadic replies to the Legal Ombudsman and the SRA, including ignoring a section 147 notice, breached 7.3 and 7.4.

What we are asking you

  1. Should Legal Workflows itself be treated as a third party performing a critical function, and what should it make available for an inspection?
  2. Is an export of matter files and the audit trail what an SRA inspection asks for, or is something missing?
  3. Should a statutory notice always open an item for the COLP, whoever records it?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 7.4.

Respond on Code 7.4
Your view of Code 7.4

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 7.5

Code 7.5: do not stop anyone, including through a settlement or non-disclosure agreement, from giving information to the SRA or any other regulator, supervisor, investigator or prosecutor.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Linked

For reference. The paragraph has its own page, with our summary, a link to the SRA's text and its authorities, but nothing on a matter raises it.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • No activity raises Code 7.5
  • Shown as reference on its own page, with notes on settlement and non-disclosure agreements and the Victims and Prisoners Act 2024 s17

Why we apply it this way

Whether a term stops someone reporting to a regulator turns on its wording and context, which is a legal judgment. Legal Workflows cannot tell a settlement agreement from any other document it holds. So the page sets out the duty and the statutory rules that make such terms void (ERA 1996 s43J, VPA 2024 s17), and the product does not check drafts against it.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Reference only. The page notes non-disclosure agreements and the Victims and Prisoners Act 2024 s17.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

C4 (Use of non disclosure agreements (NDAs)), A1 (Reporting and notification obligations), E1 (SRA enforcement strategy)

NDAs and settlement terms must not deter reporting or protected disclosures.

Legislation

WB1 (Employment Rights Act 1996 s43B (qualifying disclosures), s43F (disclosure to a prescribed person), s43J (confidentiality clauses void), s47B (detriment), s103A (dismissal)) (ERA s43J); WB3 (Victims and Prisoners Act 2024 s17 (agreements cannot stop victims making certain disclosures)) (VPA 2024 s17); WB2 (Public Interest Disclosure (Prescribed Persons) Order 2014, Schedule (Law Society, including the SRA))

A contract term that stops a worker making a protected disclosure is void (s43J). VPA s17 makes void any term stopping a victim of crime disclosing to police, lawyers, regulators of regulated professions and others. A product that drafts settlement agreements or NDAs should check them against 7.5. Watch the pending substitution of VPA s17 by the Victims and Courts Act 2026 s6.

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12691 (above). Paragraphs found or considered: 7.5.

Trying to dissuade the other side's solicitor and client from reporting him to the SRA breached 7.5.

What we are asking you

  1. Should a letter template marked as a settlement or non-disclosure agreement prompt a 7.5 check when a draft is generated?
  2. Is a reference page enough, given that SDT 12691 concerned pressure not to report rather than a written term?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 7.5.

Respond on Code 7.5
Your view of Code 7.5

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 7.6

Code 7.6: notify the SRA promptly of a criminal charge, conviction or caution (the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974 applies), any relevant insolvency event, a material change to information you gave it, or information you gave that may be false or incomplete.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL
Kinds of duty (provisional)
report
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Recording a criminal charge, conviction or caution, or a relevant insolvency event (a new record this would add)
  • Recording a material change to information given to the SRA, or information that may be false or incomplete (a new record this would add)
  • Recording the decision to notify the SRA, and the notification when it is made

Why we apply it this way

These events are personal, and the duty runs on until it is met, as SDT 12484 and 12793 show. So Legal Workflows keeps the item open until a notification is recorded, and reads each event under the edition in force on its date. Solicitors are an excepted profession under the 1975 Exceptions Order, so the product never suppresses a notification because a conviction is spent under ROA 1974, and leaves that question to a person.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Report: the item prompts a recorded decision on whether to notify the SRA (or another body), and records the notification if one is made. The product never sends a report itself.
  • A notification item for a criminal charge, conviction or caution, a relevant insolvency event, or a material change to information given to the SRA. The product records the decision and the notification.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

E5 (Topic guide: Criminal offences outside of practice), E8 (Topic guide: Driving with excess alcohol convictions), G8 (Convictions arising from matters of principle or social conscience), A1 (Reporting and notification obligations), M6 (Closing down your practice)

Self-report charges and convictions, including protest convictions. A late report aggravates.

Legislation

RO1 (Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974 s4 (effect of rehabilitation)) (ROA s4); RO2 (Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974 (Exceptions) Order 1975 Sch 1 Part I para 2 (solicitor among the excepted professions)) (Exceptions Order Sch 1 Pt I para 2); IN1 (Insolvency Act 1986 s123 (inability to pay debts), s214 (wrongful trading)) and the Glossary (IA 1986 events)

7.6(a) is "subject to" ROA 1974, but solicitors are an excepted profession under the 1975 Order. How the two interact for notification is a legal question; the product should not auto-suppress a notification because a conviction is spent. 7.6(b) "relevant insolvency event" is defined in the Glossary by reference to the Insolvency Act. See C7.

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12484 (SDT 12484-2023, 6 May 2025); SDT 12793 (SDT 12793-2025, 6 May 2026). Paragraphs found or considered: 7.6(a)/(b), P2, P4, P5.

Non-disclosure of a bankruptcy (SDT 12484) and of drink-driving convictions (SDT 12793) continued for years. Conduct spanning 25 Nov 2019 was charged under the 2011 instruments before that date and the 2019 instruments after it. For Legal Workflows: a notification duty runs on until met. The product's history must apply the instrument in force on each date.

What we are asking you

  1. Who should see a 7.6 item: only the person it concerns, or the COLP as well?
  2. Is it right that the product never treats a spent conviction as removing the need to decide on notifying?
  3. Should a change to details the product already holds, such as a member's name, prompt a 7.6 decision?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 7.6.

Respond on Code 7.6
Your view of Code 7.6

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 7.7

Code 7.7: report promptly any facts you reasonably believe could be a serious breach of the SRA's rules by anyone it regulates, including yourself.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL
Kinds of duty (provisional)
report, record
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Marking a compliance item on any paragraph as facts that may need reporting to the SRA
  • Recording a wasted costs order or a court's criticism on a matter (a new record this would add)
  • Recording the decision whether to report, including a report about yourself, and any report made
  • Handing the item to the COLP, which opens a task for them (see Code 7.12)

Why we apply it this way

The SRA expects a record of the decision whether to report, and says the duty covers self-reports and can arise before an internal investigation ends (A1, A4), and loyalty to a colleague is no excuse (James). Legal Workflows does not judge whether facts are serious, but asks a person to decide and record the decision. Any draft says the SRA cannot compel a client's privileged material without consent.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Report: the item prompts a recorded decision on whether to notify the SRA (or another body), and records the notification if one is made. The product never sends a report itself.
  • Record: the item is discharged only with evidence attached (a document version, a note or a decision). Evidence is append-only and audited, so it can be shown to the SRA under Code 7.2 and Firms 2.2.
  • Includes reporting yourself. The item records the decision whether to report, as well as any report made.
  • Any cooperation or reporting draft for this paragraph says that the SRA cannot compel production of a client’s privileged material without that client’s consent.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

A1 (Reporting and notification obligations), A2 (Reporting and notification obligations - Case studies), A3 (Reporting concerns about wrongdoing when working in-house), A4 (Internal investigations), E1 (SRA enforcement strategy), E9 (Making decisions to investigate concerns), C2 (Workplace environment: risks of failing to protect and support colleagues), G9 (Sexual Misconduct), M1 (Money missing from client account)

This duty covers self-reports. It applies to historic matters, and may arise before an internal investigation ends. Keep a record of the decision whether to report. Reports to the COLP count (7.12).

Legislation

WB1 (Employment Rights Act 1996 s43B (qualifying disclosures), s43F (disclosure to a prescribed person), s43J (confidentiality clauses void), s47B (detriment), s103A (dismissal)), WB2 (Public Interest Disclosure (Prescribed Persons) Order 2014, Schedule (Law Society, including the SRA)); CO1 (Senior Courts Act 1981 s51(6), (7) and (7A) (wasted costs)) (SCA s51(7A))

A report to the SRA by a worker can be a protected disclosure: the Law Society, including the SRA, is a prescribed person from 2 June 2026. An SDT, court or wasted costs signal can trigger a 7.7 review.

Civil courts

A6 James (MacGregor)

Loyalty and concern for a colleague's health are no excuse (James [115], [119]-[120]).

What we are asking you

  1. Are a wasted costs order and a court's criticism the right signals for a 7.7 review, and what others would you add?
  2. While a decision is pending, should a 7.7 item be visible to the person it concerns, or only to the COLP?
  3. Is a record of a decision not to report as useful to your firm as a record of a report made?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 7.7.

Respond on Code 7.7
Your view of Code 7.7

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 7.8

Code 7.8: tell the SRA promptly about anything you reasonably believe it should consider investigating.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL
Kinds of duty (provisional)
report
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Recording a cyber-attack or near miss affecting the organisation (a new record this would add)
  • Recording the decision whether to tell the SRA, and when it was told

Why we apply it this way

Code 7.8 reaches beyond rule failures to anything the SRA should consider investigating, and the SRA names novel or significant cyber-attacks and near misses (E1). Legal Workflows does not decide what the SRA should look at. It records the decision so the firm can show it considered the question, and notes that a report by a worker may also be a protected disclosure.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Report: the item prompts a recorded decision on whether to notify the SRA (or another body), and records the notification if one is made. The product never sends a report itself.
  • Records the decision whether to tell the SRA.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

A1 (Reporting and notification obligations), E1 (SRA enforcement strategy), A4 (Internal investigations)

Notably novel or significant cyber-attacks and near misses (E1).

Legislation

WB1 (Employment Rights Act 1996 s43B (qualifying disclosures), s43F (disclosure to a prescribed person), s43J (confidentiality clauses void), s47B (detriment), s103A (dismissal)), WB2 (Public Interest Disclosure (Prescribed Persons) Order 2014, Schedule (Law Society, including the SRA))

As 7.7.

What we are asking you

  1. Apart from cyber incidents, which events do you most often consider telling the SRA about under 7.8?
  2. Should 7.8 items sit at organisation level rather than on a matter, as many of these events have no matter?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 7.8.

Respond on Code 7.8
Your view of Code 7.8

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 7.9

Code 7.9: do not subject anyone to detriment for reporting, or proposing to report, on the basis of a reasonably held belief, whether or not any action follows.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Linked

For reference. The paragraph has its own page, with our summary, a link to the SRA's text and its authorities, but nothing on a matter raises it.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • No activity raises Code 7.9
  • Cited on its own page beside Code 7.7 and 7.8, which events can engage

Why we apply it this way

Detriment happens in how people are treated at work, which has no matter to hang on, and Legal Workflows does not monitor staff. The page explains that 7.9 is wider than statutory whistleblowing protection. It protects a report made on a reasonably held belief, whatever follows, while ERA 1996 s43B needs a qualifying disclosure in the public interest.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Reference only. The page links ERA 1996 ss43B and 47B; the Law Society (including the SRA) has been a prescribed person since 2 June 2026.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

A1 (Reporting and notification obligations), G7 (Complying with Principle 6 - encouraging equality, diversity and inclusion), E1 (SRA enforcement strategy)

Protection applies whether or not the SRA acts on the report.

Legislation

WB1 (Employment Rights Act 1996 s43B (qualifying disclosures), s43F (disclosure to a prescribed person), s43J (confidentiality clauses void), s47B (detriment), s103A (dismissal)) (ERA ss43B, 47B, 103A); EQ3 (s27 victimisation, where linked to Equality Act complaints)

Statutory whistleblowing protection is separate from, and narrower than, 7.9. It needs a "qualifying disclosure" made in the reasonable belief that it is in the public interest, and s43B(4) excludes some privileged disclosures. 7.9 protects reports based on a reasonably held belief, whatever happens next. The product summary says "in good faith", which is wrong (see C8).

What we are asking you

  1. Is our reading right that 7.9 protects more reports than the Employment Rights Act 1996 does?
  2. Should 7.9 join the duties an organisation certifies with its own evidence, beside fair treatment under Code 1.5?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 7.9.

Respond on Code 7.9
Your view of Code 7.9

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 7.10

Code 7.10: carry out remedial action the SRA asks for promptly, and investigate possible serious breaches if it asks.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL
Kinds of duty (provisional)
report
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Recording a request from the SRA for remedial action or an investigation (a new record this would add)
  • Assigning each step as a task with a due date, and recording each one done
  • Closing the item only when the last step is recorded as complete

Why we apply it this way

The SRA may agree a compliance plan for putting things right (E1), and SDT 12852 shows remediation, including conditions on authorisation, left undone for two years. So Legal Workflows tracks the request to completion with tasks a person owns. It records what was done, and leaves any investigation and its findings to the people the firm appoints (A4).

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Report: the item prompts a recorded decision on whether to notify the SRA (or another body), and records the notification if one is made. The product never sends a report itself.
  • Raised when the SRA asks for remedial action or an investigation; recorded to completion.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

A4 (Internal investigations), E1 (SRA enforcement strategy)

The SRA may agree a compliance plan for remediation.

Legislation

No specific legislation

Not statutory, beyond the A9 enforcement power.

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12852 (above). Paragraphs found or considered: 7.10, Firms 9.1(a)-(b), 2.1(a)-(b), 3.2, 3.4.

The firm failed for two years to bring its websites into line with the Transparency Rules (prices, complaints information, SRA number and badge) and with conditions an adjudicator had imposed. Breaches were charged to the firm under Firms 2.1, 3.2 and 3.4, and to the COLP under Firms 9.1 and Code 7.10. The Tribunal applied the Dentons seriousness test and found it met. For Legal Workflows: website price publication is a Transparency Rules duty reached through Firms 2.1, not Code 8.8. A COLP item should exist for any authorisation conditions.

What we are asking you

  1. Should conditions on the firm's authorisation open a standing item for the COLP, as well as remedial requests?
  2. Is a task list the right shape for a compliance plan, or do you need milestones agreed with the SRA?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 7.10.

Respond on Code 7.10
Your view of Code 7.10

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 7.11

Code 7.11: be honest and open with clients when things go wrong; if a client suffers loss or harm, put it right where you can and explain promptly what happened and its likely effect; if the SRA asks, investigate possible claims, report to it and tell those affected.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL
Kinds of duty (provisional)
inform, report, record
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Recording on a matter that something went wrong for the client (a new record this would add)
  • Issuing a letter that explains what happened and its likely effect, from the correspondence register
  • Recording the decision whether to tell the insurer or the SRA, and any notification made
  • Linking a personal data incident to its own record where personal data was affected (a new record this would add)

Why we apply it this way

SDT 12509 shows that a contemporaneous written acknowledgment to the client is the evidence openness needs, so Legal Workflows asks for the letter and keeps the issued version fixed. K3 covers telling the client, independent advice, insurers and a record of decisions, so each has its own step. A personal data incident runs separate clocks under UK GDPR arts 33 and 34, so the item links to that record rather than replacing it.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Inform: the item asks for the client to be told something, and is discharged by recording what was sent, when and how. The assistant can prepare the communication as a draft for a person to approve.
  • Report: the item prompts a recorded decision on whether to notify the SRA (or another body), and records the notification if one is made. The product never sends a report itself.
  • Record: the item is discharged only with evidence attached (a document version, a note or a decision). Evidence is append-only and audited, so it can be shown to the SRA under Code 7.2 and Firms 2.2.
  • Triggered where a client suffers loss or harm. Inform, report and record each have their own step.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

K3 (Putting matters right when things go wrong, and own interest conflicts), E4 (Topic guide: Competence and Standard of Service), M1 (Money missing from client account), S8 (Advising on leasehold provisions including ground rent clauses)

Covers telling the client, independent advice, insurers, a record of decisions, and the SRA-requested investigation of claims.

Legislation

DP3 (UK GDPR arts 33, 34)

When what went wrong is a personal data breach, separate statutory clocks run: notify the Commission within 72 hours where feasible, and tell affected individuals where the risk is high. The "inform" item should link to a data breach item rather than replace it.

Civil courts

None found

No change.

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12509 (above). Paragraphs found or considered: 7.11.

Openness was not shown to be lacking, because the solicitor had drafted a letter to the client acknowledging her failure to register the LPA. For Legal Workflows: a contemporaneous written acknowledgment to the client is the evidence that meets 7.11.

What we are asking you

  1. Should recording that something went wrong also prompt advice to the client to take independent advice, as K3 describes?
  2. Is the client letter the right evidence of openness, or do you also rely on notes of a call or meeting?
  3. Should the item open only when a person records the problem, or earlier, for example when a key date is missed?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 7.11.

Respond on Code 7.11
Your view of Code 7.11

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 7.12

Code 7.12: you can meet a duty to tell the SRA by telling your firm's COLP or COFA, as appropriate, on the understanding that they will pass it on.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSL
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Linked

For reference. The paragraph has its own page, with our summary, a link to the SRA's text and its authorities, but nothing on a matter raises it.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • No activity raises Code 7.12 on its own
  • Handing a 7.7 or 7.8 item to the COLP or COFA, which opens a task for them and leaves the item open

Why we apply it this way

Code 7.12 is a route for meeting other duties, not a duty of its own. Telling the COLP or COFA meets the individual's duty on the understanding that they pass it on, so Legal Workflows keeps the item open until they record their decision. The SRA does not expect the individual to check that the COLP reported, but they should report themselves if they disagree (E1, A1).

How it works in Signal & Line

  • A hand-off to the COLP or COFA opens a task for them. It does not close the item, because the duty is met only on the understanding that they report it.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

E1 (SRA enforcement strategy), A1 (Reporting and notification obligations)

The individual is not expected to check that the COLP reported. They should report themselves if they disagree with the COLP's view.

Legislation

No specific legislation

Not statutory.

What we are asking you

  1. Should the person who handed over an item be told what the COLP or COFA decided?
  2. Where there is no separate COLP or COFA, for example in a sole practice, how should the hand-off work?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 7.12.

Respond on Code 7.12
Your view of Code 7.12

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 8.1

Code 8.1: establish whom you act for in each matter.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSLOnly services offered to the public or a section of it
Kinds of duty (provisional)
identify
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Integrated (already live)

Legal Workflows already acts on this duty today. It will add the paragraph's own page, and cite the paragraph on what the product already does.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Opening a matter for a client chosen from the client register
  • Promoting a party to a client before a matter opens
  • Recording who instructs on the matter, such as an instructing solicitor or a client's representative
  • Giving one-off advice to someone who is not a client (a new record of the advice's limits this would add)

Why we apply it this way

Code 8.1 asks whom the firm acts for, and the client register already answers that on every matter. Legal Workflows keeps this apart from customer due diligence, which is a separate legal duty that applies only to some work (MLR regs 12, 27, 28). Checks should be proportionate and aimed at fraud (P1, P11), so the item asks a person to confirm the client and links the evidence held, rather than asking for identity documents.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Existing product behaviour: Matter client taken from the client register.
  • Identify: the item asks the person acting to confirm who the client is, or who is authorised to instruct, and links the evidence already held (the client register entry, the instructing party on the matter).
  • Evidence that satisfies 8.1 is not customer due diligence under the Money Laundering Regulations 2017 regs 27 and 28. The product never presents it as such.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

P1 (Identifying your client), P2 (Identifying your client when working in-house), C7 (Sham litigation), C8 (Supporting your client with interviews during external investigations), P11 (Bogus law firms and identity theft), F8 (Complying with the UK Sanctions Regime)

Know who you are dealing with, as a fraud-prevention measure. Checks are proportionate and need not be AML-level. Make a file note when departing from firm policy. In-house, 8.1 does not apply unless the work is public-facing, but P7 and section 6 still require identifying the client.

Legislation

ML1 (Money Laundering, Terrorist Financing and Transfer of Funds (Information on the Payer) Regulations 2017: reg 7 (supervisors), 12 (independent legal professional), 18 (risk assessment), 19 (policies and controls), 21 (internal controls and nominated officer), 24 (training), 26 (approval of beneficial owners, officers and managers), 27 and 28 (customer due diligence), 40 (record-keeping)) (MLR regs 12, 27, 28)

8.1 asks whom you act for. MLR customer due diligence is a separate legal duty: identify and verify, including beneficial owners. It applies only where the firm is an "independent legal professional", meaning it takes part in the financial or real property transactions listed in reg 12. Satisfying one does not satisfy the other. The existing "matter client from the client register" evidence meets 8.1 only (see C9).

Civil courts

A15 Spire

The scope of any responsibility assumed is judged objectively, including for non-clients. Record the limits of one-off advice to non-clients (Spire [104]).

What we are asking you

  1. Is confirming the client from the client register enough for 8.1, or should the item also ask how the client's identity was checked?
  2. Should advice given to a non-client be recorded with its limits, as Spire suggests, and where should that record sit?
  3. For in-house teams doing public-facing work, does this fit how you identify the client (P2)?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 8.1.

Respond on Code 8.1
Your view of Code 8.1

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 8.2

Code 8.2: have, or take part in, a procedure for handling complaints.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSLOnly services offered to the public or a section of it
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Linked

For reference. The paragraph has its own page, with our summary, a link to the SRA's text and its authorities, but nothing on a matter raises it.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • No activity on a matter raises Code 8.2
  • Shown as reference on its own page, where the firm can hold its complaints procedure as office-manual evidence
  • Cited beside Code 8.3 to 8.5, which matter events can engage

Why we apply it this way

Having a complaints procedure is a duty on the firm's arrangements, not on any one matter (LSA s112). The procedure is the firm's own, so Legal Workflows holds it as evidence and does not judge its content. The Legal Ombudsman can uphold a complaint on fairness alone (Aina Khan), so a procedure on file says little about how a given complaint was handled.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Reference only: the procedure is the firm’s own, and can be held as office-manual evidence.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

P4 (Publishing complaints procedure), P5 (Complaints about solicitors working outside SRA-regulated firms - Case studies), P10 (Unregulated organisations giving information to clients), E4 (Topic guide: Competence and Standard of Service)

Publish the complaints procedure (Transparency Rule 2.1). The LeO time limits must be stated accurately. Poor complaint handling aggravates competence cases.

Legislation

LS3 (LSA 2007 Part 6 (legal complaints): s112 (complaints procedures of authorised persons), s125 (ombudsman jurisdiction), s126 (respondent's own procedure must be used first), s133 (scheme rules, including time limits), s147 (ombudsman's information powers)) (LSA s112); CN3 (Provision of Services Regulations 2009 reg 8 (information to be made available), reg 10 (dispute resolution information), reg 11 (manner and timing), reg 12 (complaints)) (PSR reg 12)

LSA s112 requires the regulator to make authorised persons have complaint procedures. PSR reg 12 requires complaints to be answered quickly and best efforts made to resolve them.

Civil courts

A36 Aina Khan

The Legal Ombudsman decides on what is fair and reasonable and has wide latitude, so a complaint can be upheld even where no Code breach is shown (Aina Khan [35]-[37], [92]).

What we are asking you

  1. Is it right that no matter event raises 8.2, since it concerns the firm's procedure rather than a matter?
  2. Would a periodic prompt to check that the published procedure states the Ombudsman time limits accurately (P4) be useful?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 8.2.

Respond on Code 8.2
Your view of Code 8.2

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 8.3

Code 8.3: at the start, tell the client in writing that they can complain to you, how to do so, and about their rights to go to the Legal Ombudsman.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSLOnly services offered to the public or a section of it
Kinds of duty (provisional)
inform
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Opening a matter for a client, which raises the item at the start of the retainer
  • Issuing a client care letter from the matter's Correspondence tab, recorded with its channel, date and sender
  • Recording on the item what complaint information was sent, when and how

Why we apply it this way

The Ombudsman will not normally take a complaint until the firm's own procedure has been used, and time limits apply (LSA ss126, 133), so the client needs this information from the start. An issued letter on the correspondence register cannot be changed, which makes it good evidence of what was sent. Legal Workflows uses an inform item because the duty is met by telling the client, not by a judgment about the matter.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Inform: the item asks for the client to be told something, and is discharged by recording what was sent, when and how. The assistant can prepare the communication as a draft for a person to approve.
  • Raised at the start of the matter (client care).

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

P4 (Publishing complaints procedure), P5 (Complaints about solicitors working outside SRA-regulated firms - Case studies), P10 (Unregulated organisations giving information to clients), E4 (Topic guide: Competence and Standard of Service)

Publish the complaints procedure (Transparency Rule 2.1). The LeO time limits must be stated accurately. Poor complaint handling aggravates competence cases.

Legislation

LS3 (LSA 2007 Part 6 (legal complaints): s112 (complaints procedures of authorised persons), s125 (ombudsman jurisdiction), s126 (respondent's own procedure must be used first), s133 (scheme rules, including time limits), s147 (ombudsman's information powers)) (LSA ss125, 126, 133); CN3 (Provision of Services Regulations 2009 reg 8 (information to be made available), reg 10 (dispute resolution information), reg 11 (manner and timing), reg 12 (complaints)) (PSR regs 8, 10, 11)

The Ombudsman will not normally take a complaint until the firm's own procedure has been used (s126), and scheme rules set time limits (s133). PSR reg 10 requires telling recipients about a non-judicial dispute resolution procedure and how to find out about it.

Civil courts

A36 Aina Khan

The Legal Ombudsman decides on what is fair and reasonable and has wide latitude, so a complaint can be upheld even where no Code breach is shown (Aina Khan [35]-[37], [92]).

Tribunal or SRA decision

SRA decision 081485 (SRA decision 081485, 31 Jul 2026). Paragraphs found or considered: 1.3, 3.2, 4.2, 8.3, 8.4, 8.5.

This records breaches; there is little interpretation. Listed only to show how 8.3-8.5 failures are usually charged together with Legal Ombudsman non-cooperation.

What we are asking you

  1. Is opening the matter the right trigger, or should the item wait until the client is formally engaged?
  2. Is an issued client care letter enough evidence, or should the item also check that it explains the Ombudsman and its time limits?
  3. For repeat or high-volume clients, should one written notice cover several matters?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 8.3.

Respond on Code 8.3
Your view of Code 8.3

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 8.4

Code 8.4: if a complaint is not resolved within eight weeks, or your procedure is exhausted, tell the client in writing about the Legal Ombudsman and, where it applies, alternative dispute resolution (see the DMCC Act 2024 note in the authorities map).

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSLOnly services offered to the public or a section of it
Kinds of duty (provisional)
inform
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Recording a complaint on the matter, with the date it was made (a new record this would add)
  • Eight weeks passing from that date with the complaint still open
  • Sending the client the firm's final response, which for consumer clients also raises the DMCC s308 duty
  • Issuing the Ombudsman and ADR letter, recorded on the matter's correspondence register

Why we apply it this way

Code 8.4 is set off by time or by the end of the firm's procedure, so both need a recorded complaint with a start date, which the product does not keep yet. Since the 2015 ADR Regulations were revoked, DMCC s308 requires a consumer to be told about ADR, including the Ombudsman, with a complaint outcome. So Legal Workflows raises an inform item on the final response as well as at eight weeks, and flags that the Code's wording lags the statute.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Inform: the item asks for the client to be told something, and is discharged by recording what was sent, when and how. The assistant can prepare the communication as a draft for a person to approve.
  • The ADR Regulations 2015 were revoked on 6 April 2026. For consumer clients the complaint-outcome event also raises the DMCC Act 2024 s308 duty to tell the client about available ADR, including the Legal Ombudsman. Legal Workflows flags 8.4 as out of step with statute until the SRA amends it.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

P4 (Publishing complaints procedure), P5 (Complaints about solicitors working outside SRA-regulated firms - Case studies), P10 (Unregulated organisations giving information to clients), E4 (Topic guide: Competence and Standard of Service)

Publish the complaints procedure (Transparency Rule 2.1). The LeO time limits must be stated accurately. Poor complaint handling aggravates competence cases.

Legislation

LS3 (LSA 2007 Part 6 (legal complaints): s112 (complaints procedures of authorised persons), s125 (ombudsman jurisdiction), s126 (respondent's own procedure must be used first), s133 (scheme rules, including time limits), s147 (ombudsman's information powers)); CN4 (ADR for Consumer Disputes (Competent Authorities and Information) Regulations 2015 reg 19) (revoked); CN5 (Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 s291 (meaning of ADR), s308 (trader's duty to tell the consumer about ADR arrangements)) (DMCC ss291, 308)

8.4(b) still speaks of an "ADR approved body", a term from the 2015 Regulations. Those Regulations, including the reg 19 duty to name a competent ADR entity, were revoked on 6 April 2026. DMCC s308 now applies, from 6 April 2026: when a trader tells a consumer the outcome of a complaint, it must also tell them about any ADR or other arrangement available. The Legal Ombudsman is an "ombudsman scheme", which s291(4)(d) treats as ADR. So for consumer clients the product needs a statutory "inform" item when the final response is sent, in addition to the eight-week trigger (see C2).

Civil courts

A36 Aina Khan

The Legal Ombudsman decides on what is fair and reasonable and has wide latitude, so a complaint can be upheld even where no Code breach is shown (Aina Khan [35]-[37], [92]).

Tribunal or SRA decision

SRA decision 081485 (SRA decision 081485, 31 Jul 2026). Paragraphs found or considered: 1.3, 3.2, 4.2, 8.3, 8.4, 8.5.

This records breaches; there is little interpretation. Listed only to show how 8.3-8.5 failures are usually charged together with Legal Ombudsman non-cooperation.

What we are asking you

  1. Should a complaint be its own record on the matter, or a kind of matter note with a start date?
  2. Is it right to raise the DMCC s308 item only for consumer clients, and how do you tell consumer from business clients in practice?
  3. Should the eight-week item open some days before the deadline, so the letter can go on time?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 8.4.

Respond on Code 8.4
Your view of Code 8.4

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 8.5

Code 8.5: deal with complaints promptly, fairly and without charge.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSLOnly services offered to the public or a section of it
Kinds of duty (provisional)
review
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Recording a complaint on the matter (a new record this would add)
  • Closing a complaint, with its outcome and the date of the response
  • Recording time against a complaint-handling task, so a person can check the client is not charged for it

Why we apply it this way

Whether a complaint was handled promptly and fairly is a judgment, so Legal Workflows opens a review item for a person to complete, not a pass or fail. The no-charge requirement comes from the Code, not from statute (LSA s112, PSR reg 12), so the product cites it on its own. Poor complaint handling weighs in competence cases (E4), and the Ombudsman judges fairness widely (Aina Khan), so the review records its reasons as well as its outcome.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Review: the item opens a review task on the matter (for example of service, timeliness or risk). It is discharged by a person recording the review and its outcome.
  • A review item on complaint handling: prompt, fair and free of charge.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

P4 (Publishing complaints procedure), P5 (Complaints about solicitors working outside SRA-regulated firms - Case studies), P10 (Unregulated organisations giving information to clients), E4 (Topic guide: Competence and Standard of Service)

Publish the complaints procedure (Transparency Rule 2.1). The LeO time limits must be stated accurately. Poor complaint handling aggravates competence cases.

Legislation

LS3 (LSA 2007 Part 6 (legal complaints): s112 (complaints procedures of authorised persons), s125 (ombudsman jurisdiction), s126 (respondent's own procedure must be used first), s133 (scheme rules, including time limits), s147 (ombudsman's information powers)) (LSA s112); CN3 (Provision of Services Regulations 2009 reg 8 (information to be made available), reg 10 (dispute resolution information), reg 11 (manner and timing), reg 12 (complaints)) (PSR reg 12)

Statutory complaint duties overlap. Neither statute sets the "free of charge" requirement; that is regulatory.

Civil courts

A36 Aina Khan

The Legal Ombudsman decides on what is fair and reasonable and has wide latitude, so a complaint can be upheld even where no Code breach is shown (Aina Khan [35]-[37], [92]).

Tribunal or SRA decision

SRA decision 081485 (SRA decision 081485, 31 Jul 2026). Paragraphs found or considered: 1.3, 3.2, 4.2, 8.3, 8.4, 8.5.

This records breaches; there is little interpretation. Listed only to show how 8.3-8.5 failures are usually charged together with Legal Ombudsman non-cooperation.

What we are asking you

  1. Should the review item open when a complaint is received, when it is closed, or both?
  2. Is flagging time recorded against complaint handling a useful check on the no-charge requirement, or too blunt?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 8.5.

Respond on Code 8.5
Your view of Code 8.5

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 8.6

Code 8.6: give clients information they can understand, so they can make informed decisions.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSLOnly services offered to the public or a section of it
Kinds of duty (provisional)
inform
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Issuing a client care letter when a matter opens
  • Adding or changing a funding line on the matter, such as a no win, no fee arrangement
  • Closing a matter before the work is done, where the client needs to understand what ending the retainer means

Why we apply it this way

The duty is about whether the client can understand and decide, so it is engaged where the client faces a choice: at engagement, on funding and at termination (P3, C12, S4). For consumers, what the firm says can become a binding term (CRA s50), and clients should know of options outside the firm (SDT 12579). Legal Workflows records what was sent and leaves the judgment to a person, because software cannot tell whether a client understood.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Inform: the item asks for the client to be told something, and is discharged by recording what was sent, when and how. The assistant can prepare the communication as a draft for a person to approve.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

P3 (Client care letters), G13 (Tax avoidance your duties), S4 (Terminating a retainer), C12 ('No win, no fee' and other fee arrangements in high-volume consumer claims), R4 (Offering inducements to potential clients or clients), P10 (Unregulated organisations giving information to clients)

Information must be understandable, including at termination, on funding and on fees.

Legislation

CN2 (Consumer Contracts (Information, Cancellation and Additional Charges) Regulations 2013 reg 9, reg 13, reg 36, Sch 2) (CCR regs 9, 13, Sch 2); CN3 (Provision of Services Regulations 2009 reg 8 (information to be made available), reg 10 (dispute resolution information), reg 11 (manner and timing), reg 12 (complaints)) (PSR regs 8, 11); CN1 (Consumer Rights Act 2015 s49 (reasonable care and skill), s50 (information binding), s52 (reasonable time)) (CRA s50)

For consumer contracts, statutory pre-contract information must be given clearly before the client is bound. What the firm says about the service can become a binding term (CRA s50). Off-premises and distance contracts carry cancellation rights, and starting work early needs an express request (CCR reg 36).

Civil courts

A27 Belsner; A36 Aina Khan

The best possible information must cover price, likely overall cost and costs incurred. It must include facts the client needs to compare, such as fixed recoverable costs (Belsner [65], [83]-[84]). Failing to update a client on rising costs was upheld as a complaint (Aina Khan [70]).

Tribunal or SRA decision

SDT 12579 (above). Paragraphs found or considered: 8.6.

Clients must be told of options other than instructing the firm, including free ombudsman and compensation-scheme routes.

What we are asking you

  1. Are engagement, a change of funding and early termination the right moments for 8.6, or is one missing?
  2. Should the item prompt the firm to mention free routes such as an ombudsman in claim-type matters, as SDT 12579 suggests?
  3. Should a recorded communication need or vulnerability flag on the client change what the item asks for?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 8.6.

Respond on Code 8.6
Your view of Code 8.6

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 8.7

Code 8.7: give clients the best information you can about how their matter will be priced and, at the start and as it goes on, about the likely overall cost and the costs incurred.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSLOnly services offered to the public or a section of it
Kinds of duty (provisional)
inform
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Integrated (already live)

Legal Workflows already acts on this duty today. It will add the paragraph's own page, and cite the paragraph on what the product already does.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • A phase's recorded time reaching an estimate threshold, 75% and 100% by default, which alerts the matter admins
  • Setting a matter's own estimate thresholds
  • Recording the costs estimate for each phase of the matter
  • Sending the client a costs update, recorded on the correspondence register

Why we apply it this way

Code 8.7 asks for price information at the start and as the matter goes on, including costs incurred (Belsner). A time threshold is an objective point where the estimate may no longer hold, and failing to update a client on rising costs has been upheld as a complaint (Aina Khan). The alert prompts a person and records that it did, but sends nothing to the client, because what to say and when is for the solicitor.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Existing product behaviour: estimate.threshold matter event (billing.estimates.ts).
  • Inform: the item asks for the client to be told something, and is discharged by recording what was sent, when and how. The assistant can prepare the communication as a draft for a person to approve.
  • Adds costs incurred as the matter goes on (Belsner v CAM Legal Services).

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

P3 (Client care letters), P6 (Transparency in price and service), C12 ('No win, no fee' and other fee arrangements in high-volume consumer claims), M5 (SRA consumer credit)

Cover the price and any costs incurred. In high-volume consumer claims, disclose every deduction.

Legislation

CN2 (Consumer Contracts (Information, Cancellation and Additional Charges) Regulations 2013 reg 9, reg 13, reg 36, Sch 2) (CCR Sch 2 para (f), total price or how it is calculated); CN3 (Provision of Services Regulations 2009 reg 8 (information to be made available), reg 10 (dispute resolution information), reg 11 (manner and timing), reg 12 (complaints)) (PSR reg 8(1)(l)); SA3 (SA ss57, 59, 69, 70); FA1 (Courts and Legal Services Act 1990 s58 (conditional fee agreements), s58AA (damages-based agreements)) (CLSA ss58, 58AA)

Price information is also a statutory duty for consumers. Bills can be challenged by assessment (SA s70). Conditional fee and damages-based agreements have statutory conditions. The estimate.threshold event fits 8.7 and the CCR and PSR information duties.

Civil courts

A27 Belsner; A36 Aina Khan

The best possible information must cover price, likely overall cost and costs incurred. It must include facts the client needs to compare, such as fixed recoverable costs (Belsner [65], [83]-[84]). Failing to update a client on rising costs was upheld as a complaint (Aina Khan [70]).

What we are asking you

  1. Are 75% and 100% of the estimate sensible default thresholds for prompting a costs update?
  2. Should the alert also count disbursements and expenses, not only recorded time?
  3. For fixed-fee or high-volume consumer work, what event should prompt a costs update instead?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 8.7.

Respond on Code 8.7
Your view of Code 8.7

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 8.8

Code 8.8: make sure your publicity, including about charges and when interest is payable, is accurate and not misleading, including publicity others put out for you.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSLOnly services offered to the public or a section of it
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Linked

For reference. The paragraph has its own page, with our summary, a link to the SRA's text and its authorities, but nothing on a matter raises it.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • No activity on a matter raises Code 8.8
  • Shown as reference on its own page, since publicity is made for the firm, not for a matter

Why we apply it this way

Legal Workflows does not hold the firm's website, adverts or marketing by introducers (P8), so it has no event that could show misleading publicity. Whether a statement misleads also depends on its audience and context, which consumer law tests separately (DMCC ss225 to 227, BPMMR reg 3). So the product does not monitor publicity and leaves it to the firm.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Reference only. Covers publicity others put out for you, and when interest is payable.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

P6 (Transparency in price and service), P8 (Marketing your services to members of the public), R4 (Offering inducements to potential clients or clients), R5 (Separate Business), M5 (SRA consumer credit)

Covers charges and interest, third-party marketing, statements about prospects and awards, and statutory bans such as PI inducements.

Legislation

CN6 (DMCC 2024 s225 (unfair commercial practices prohibited), s226 (misleading actions), s227 (misleading omissions), s229 (professional diligence), Sch 20 (practices always unfair: para 1 code of conduct signatory claims; para 4 false approval or authorisation claims; para 13 fake reviews; para 28 persistent unwanted solicitations)) (DMCC ss225 to 227, Sch 20 paras 1, 4, 13); CN8 (Business Protection from Misleading Marketing Regulations 2008 reg 3) (BPMMR reg 3, business audiences); FS1 (Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 s21 (financial promotion), s327 (exemption for professional firms)) (FSMA s21)

Misleading publicity to consumers is also prohibited as an unfair commercial practice (since 6 April 2025), including fake or incentivised reviews. Advertising aimed at businesses is covered by BPMMR. Promotions inviting investment activity are restricted by FSMA s21.

Civil courts

None found

No change.

What we are asking you

  1. Is it right that the product does not raise 8.8, given that publicity sits outside matters?
  2. Would a checklist of what price publicity should cover, linked to the consumer law, help a COLP review it?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 8.8.

Respond on Code 8.8
Your view of Code 8.8

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 8.9

Code 8.9: do not approach members of the public uninvited to promote your services, except current or former clients, and the electronic marketing rules (PECR) still apply to them.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSLOnly services offered to the public or a section of it
Kinds of duty (provisional)
none
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Linked

For reference. The paragraph has its own page, with our summary, a link to the SRA's text and its authorities, but nothing on a matter raises it.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • No activity raises Code 8.9, because Legal Workflows does not send marketing
  • Shown as reference on its own page, with the electronic marketing rules noted for current and former clients

Why we apply it this way

Legal Workflows is not a marketing tool and sends nothing to prospective clients, so no matter event can show an uninvited approach. The risk lies in how the firm and its introducers market (P9, P8), which happens outside the product. The page notes that the Code's exception for current and former clients does not lift PECR (regs 21, 22).

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Reference only. PECR 2003 still applies to current and former clients.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

P9 (Unsolicited approaches (advertising) to members of the public), P8 (Marketing your services to members of the public), R6 (Lawtech providers Q&A)

Targeted or individual approaches are banned, including through introducers. Untargeted advertising is allowed.

Legislation

CN7 (Privacy and Electronic Communications (EC Directive) Regulations 2003 reg 21 (marketing calls), reg 22 (marketing email and texts)) (PECR regs 21, 22); CN6 (DMCC 2024 s225 (unfair commercial practices prohibited), s226 (misleading actions), s227 (misleading omissions), s229 (professional diligence), Sch 20 (practices always unfair: para 1 code of conduct signatory claims; para 4 false approval or authorisation claims; para 13 fake reviews; para 28 persistent unwanted solicitations)) (Sch 20 para 28)

PECR controls marketing calls and email or text marketing, including to existing and former clients: the reg 22(3) soft opt-in is limited. "Persistent and unwanted solicitations" are always unfair to consumers. The Code's exception for current and former clients does not lift PECR (see C12).

Civil courts

None found

No change.

What we are asking you

  1. Should using a client's contact details for anything other than their matter prompt a reminder about PECR and 8.9?
  2. Is a reference page enough, or do firms that use introducers want more from the product here?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 8.9.

Respond on Code 8.9
Your view of Code 8.9

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 8.10

Code 8.10: make sure clients understand which of your services are regulated, and by whom, and do not present an unauthorised business as SRA-regulated.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSLOnly services offered to the public or a section of it
Kinds of duty (provisional)
inform
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Issuing a client care letter on a newly opened matter
  • Choosing a letterhead, which carries the firm's regulatory line
  • Marking a matter as non-reserved work done outside SRA regulation (a matter field this would add)

Why we apply it this way

Clients must know which services are regulated and by whom, and must never be told that an unauthorised business is SRA-regulated (P10, R5, DMCC Sch 20 para 4). The risk is highest in multi-disciplinary practices and separate businesses (F14), where one client may receive both kinds of service. So Legal Workflows raises an inform item at engagement and records what was sent, rather than checking the firm's structure.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Inform: the item asks for the client to be told something, and is discharged by recording what was sent, when and how. The assistant can prepare the communication as a draft for a person to approve.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

P10 (Unregulated organisations giving information to clients), R5 (Separate Business), F14 (Multi-disciplinary practices: Regulation of non-reserved legal activity)

Explain who does what and who is authorised. Never present an unauthorised business as SRA-regulated.

Legislation

LS1 (LSA 2007 s12 (reserved legal activities), s14 (offence to carry on reserved activity unless entitled), s15 (employers and employees), s17 (offence to pretend to be entitled), s18 (authorised persons)) (LSA ss12, 14, 17, 18); SA1 (SA 1974 s20 (unqualified person not to act as a solicitor), s21 (not to pretend to be a solicitor)) (SA s21); CN3 (Provision of Services Regulations 2009 reg 8 (information to be made available), reg 10 (dispute resolution information), reg 11 (manner and timing), reg 12 (complaints)) (PSR reg 8(1)(d), (e), (h), (n)); CN6 (DMCC 2024 s225 (unfair commercial practices prohibited), s226 (misleading actions), s227 (misleading omissions), s229 (professional diligence), Sch 20 (practices always unfair: para 1 code of conduct signatory claims; para 4 false approval or authorisation claims; para 13 fake reviews; para 28 persistent unwanted solicitations)) (Sch 20 para 4); FS1 (Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 s21 (financial promotion), s327 (exemption for professional firms)) (FSMA s327)

Reserved legal activities and authorised persons are defined in the LSA. PSR reg 8 requires a provider in a regulated profession to give its professional body or regulator details and professional indemnity information. Falsely claiming that a body has approved or authorised the trader is always unfair (Sch 20 para 4).

Civil courts

None found

No change.

What we are asking you

  1. Is engagement the only moment 8.10 needs, or also when a matter moves between regulated and unregulated work?
  2. Should a matter record whether its work is regulated, so the item is raised only where it matters?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 8.10.

Respond on Code 8.10
Your view of Code 8.10

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.

Code 8.11

Code 8.11: make sure clients understand the regulatory protections open to them.

Summary by Signal & Line, not the SRA's text.

Applies to
Solicitor, REL, RFL, RSLOnly services offered to the public or a section of it
Kinds of duty (provisional)
inform
Edition
In effect from 11 April 2025

Integrated

When something recorded on a matter may engage this paragraph, Legal Workflows opens a compliance item on the matter that cites it. Only a person can close the item.

Where it would apply in Signal & Line

Proposed. The activities are part of what we are consulting on.

  • Issuing a client care letter on a newly opened matter
  • Marking a matter as work where some protections may not apply, such as through a separate business (a matter field this would add)

Why we apply it this way

The protections clients are to be told about, the Ombudsman, indemnity insurance and the Compensation Fund, rest on statute (SA ss36, 36A, 37, LSA Part 6). Whether each applies depends on the service, so the duty is met by telling the client clearly at the start (R7, P10). Legal Workflows treats it as an inform item discharged by a recorded letter, because it cannot judge whether the client understood.

How it works in Signal & Line

  • Inform: the item asks for the client to be told something, and is discharged by recording what was sent, when and how. The assistant can prepare the communication as a draft for a person to approve.

Authorities

Codes link to the schedule of authorities.

SRA guidance

P10 (Unregulated organisations giving information to clients), R7 (Adequate and appropriate indemnity insurance), R5 (Separate Business)

Covers LeO, PII and the Compensation Fund, and whether each applies.

Legislation

SA2 (SA ss36, 36A, compensation fund); A2 (SA 1974 s2 (training regulations), s13 (practising certificate appeals), s28 (regulations on admission, the roll and practising certificates), s32 (accounts rules), s33A (inspection of practice bank accounts), s34 (accountants' reports), s37 (indemnity rules)) (SA s37, indemnity); LS3 (LSA 2007 Part 6 (legal complaints): s112 (complaints procedures of authorised persons), s125 (ombudsman jurisdiction), s126 (respondent's own procedure must be used first), s133 (scheme rules, including time limits), s147 (ombudsman's information powers)) (Ombudsman); CN3 (Provision of Services Regulations 2009 reg 8 (information to be made available), reg 10 (dispute resolution information), reg 11 (manner and timing), reg 12 (complaints)) (PSR reg 8(1)(n))

These statutes create the protections clients are to be told about.

Civil courts

None found

No change.

What we are asking you

  1. Should 8.11 be raised in the same client care item as 8.3 and 8.10, or as its own item?
  2. Is anything missing for clients of a separate business, where some protections may not apply?

Answer any of these in your comment, or tell us about anything else on Code 8.11.

Respond on Code 8.11
Your view of Code 8.11

Responses are anonymous. We do not ask who you are, so please do not include your name, anyone else's personal data, or details of a client or a matter.